„საქართველოს სახალხო დამცველის შესახებ“ საქართველოს ორგანულ კანონში ცვლილების შეტანის თაობაზე“

საქართველოს ორგანული კანონის პროექტი მიღებულია
ინიცირების თარიღი
23.10.2015
ავტორი
საქართველოს სახალხო დამცველი
ინიციატორი
საქართველოს პარლამენტის ადამიანის უფლებათა დაცვისა და სამოქალაქო ინტეგრაციის კომიტეტი
ნომერი
#3380/8; 07-3/498/8
წყარო

📋 განხილვის ეტაპები

ინიციირებული ვარიანტი
I მოსმენა
საქართველოს პარლამენტის დადგენილება

🏛️ კომიტეტები

  • ადამიანის უფლებათა დაცვისა და სამოქალაქო ინტეგრაციის კომიტეტი წამყვანი კომიტეტი
  • იურიდიულ საკითხთა კომიტეტი კომიტეტი რომლის დასკვნაც სავალდებულოა

📅 დამატებითი ინფორმაცია

ბიუროზე განხილვის თარიღი 2015-02-18
ბიუროს ნომერი 247

📜 ტექსტი

საქართველოს პარლამენტის ბიუროს გადაწყვეტილება
だ \ brjst6orgqrrnb Jrl6q,r0366ott bo36o5 6rqgr$g3g6oq,3br b〕 ,ヽ 03∞ mb b)hCゝ 0360∩ ― ヽ247/3 2∝ 5ぃ .18… 中 t rCJf,oucgrt, Jif,q'rac6odr F,m('iaco0ob l5G3 agb(rtr 0x-4 qu d3-5 [rgcdocq,$c, brCrr,o8cex'lL Neqrafo0olr aqc'6o J(bcal: Jtf,q'$C6,Od, 3gq'Jb.d,J A'sGoUJ (u qgfr}Qr,"J(' tt"r3oo$ot 3rfq!$9&, lN8oCrq',*.r o6O\S6rAff$ $$S$o Ja&t05r,) Qr 0r6ok{'ob tljJio8gqxlt, ttslq'b<'r (M$Cq'dJ 8oc6, 9irr&taacft rq'o lr5}ffi e'c0<m 3oAeFAo". "aOo&t) 3oaggpAo', BSJ('iAOE5 "t rCyrEBCe'('ltJ t rocdrqliCo 8CUrbCb", UJar$"J6ob .ljlxs(rro "SrfrJt6(ffirofffJ $C('r tsc,64d r(6(,gb36ol, hlrrw" er .t dr6,o,C9eol, lr$q'bo Q!663Cqd, a'Jr$C6' lxdifto,Oqrott 3$<nft00o meq{bc0ob ea,Ipqxro,: l$jlrlo6gqrc 3$c6olt Jdx"X$gDo,r6 q'r3)30ofrC0.,o' Q,J $ra$$Ar J('l&rOOo8r DqtsS$JOoq'CDol, orx"[JtC roh&',l, UrClr,<t,3C('alb Jrf,$0Cq5r,t, ACO"tSob EdrrbCD (N880, 16.02.2015) Drr;fx'ir. V b輌 ド輸∞Ψ出 b― 00bOが狭o協蒟o 喚 … 品 bα ぬ 岬 蒟 ′ 0● Op"Ub09斑 ぃで
წერილი
tr$t6o30qrll, t,sb;qbo qo8ggnqo Public Defender of Georgia N13/1090 1090‑13‑2‑201502111712 11/02/2015 ││││││││││││││││││││││││││││││││││││││││││││││││││││││ b.: ju6o63grnb J,:t6qr$95$olr orr32gqm0s6 glr, b.r6o6 q)r3ocr, gltggrQoqb l$3r6o60qgCbgar $cl6rsgrACbs "lrjrr6or3gq,olr bo&njrq;jcn brE{6o6gbrn 3anqgflbob" 3531-C qr.: 3632-9 ACbgSB", lrsjuiorggqrolr ottp6gqn 3$o5ob ,B6er0ob 3rnqggjbob" 38-C 0g@tso, ,,lrlar6o bo0b$g6olt Bgltb36" bsj.:<6or3gq,ob 3,:6cn6olr 127-9 A3\rEo, ,qnlr3t6o0o64ool,r $3cqtr gottOob rqO<ngb3ttob Egll5bgb" b,:jr6cr6gq,ob 3r6o6oU acr8 qg.> aC-9 aUbgg60o, "br$>6orggqxnb ltboqbo qgc063gqrob Eglrobg0" o66r6gq,o 3r6cn6ob 24a eCbgtso 6s6lsbcnt6oocgCbCq oSgoqCbC6cor6 qg.:3r3tsof,C0oo, り 1つ あ ∂く 9う ぐり ∂ぅ の 死 フ如 で″ ′ 澪 りで ιり うι '6tFtフ 物 汚 @瀕 り うこフぐ οう ιl♪ 汚9η ぐ ″ι ιDι ゥく 【 b″ ぐ D勧 ψ ttη η cの ι ιDめ ぐ わ″ 0),ぼ ∂ゆ θOノ うの ,,ι ぜ 響 οι 。あ あ (,ο ι oι の ι。り ∂ ″の Dの 解 ο″ 伽 あ ι の ノイ θ ι ン フ ι ιひ ο ι潟3響bgァ う́ ο あ税りο οιcD,,cο 的 う́ ιヒ ιの‑21θ う でね 27"´ う う 」 Oο ι,,c 励 の bぐο `秋ク Dぐ・ οわりι Dあ のι bぐ ο ιのフこ ,C 絲 6ι D"ar″ 伽ぁιの ̀化 フ 秋,ο ι′ θι のι lノ rヮ 〃盤:ブ: ″ 仕 都:品 よ鷺綿躙鋼亀&粘 :『 :3豫 亀酪闘瑞1滉 6M mm輛 ‖ 躍闘[襦8胤l臆 .鰤 0"13041 Ⅷ 7Q Goorgh,コ 」 し 。 。 60ooqO,0ら 」 995o"13841 i 2014 Sqrob 0mb0o ,,qrob36o0o6rgoob g39q,r grnr60ob rg0rngb36ob tsgb;bgb,, 3,>6rn6oU 0oqgboor bcj.l6or3gqrrnb J.r6qrr0g6g0r qrot.r36o0o6caol[cn.:6 06doq,,> brbgqr@$oggr[ 96or-916or g05o6363qro3.rbgb J6orn6oggglqr rqor6,:, 3o6roqrl6 qrob36o0o6s6oobr6r6 orr3obggrqn 5,:690r'rU Br0r.rgcqrobg0ob bgqtsg$gr'rbr g06ots36gqrrn3s63lroc Jqg6uqrob0olr oe,Cr%C q,:ggd69Agq,o qrgEcr3ttsgopq,o b.:Ser6rqxng6ol-r 5r'r60rqg6o g36j6ogr6o696obro3olr qrr Ar6trbgr3Cb3q,lo a6gggbob 6o0r6cn Or'lq,C6J6OCq,lrA-o br6$9s!6oE o go60o6gbobo3ob. JrEs!6Ar qrob3t6o0o6,:6oob .:q8ogb36ob,: er brber6rqgrgbotl crlrSrtJ$r'r6r'lbob gbr6g53gq,grng,:b9 %9q9r0bgq933q,rnbob ggbjgo.> b.:brq,brn q.or063gq,b 0oc6olc, 619 o0r%9 0ggg3gE gbb, 6n,0 r6bCbober bslo6rngbr, brbgq,S$ognao qrob36o0o6r6oob gtj6gbrcA 0e6ogc.r6o6gob g,:6Erbo6gogqgbgqro rn6grbar ,:6bgbgqrogrn. J)br'l6Ar ,t6r Ebrnqrr.rqr qg3qr.r6o6gbgqrJe' AoJ6o$J bobrqrbcn rgr0ggCq,ti .;q6ots6gq,o BUbCgor, .:6$gqr 6.roor3.:q,ob$o6,: j@gqrocno fujr6ob0o, 619 b,rbrqbr.r SgrOgBCE b cncbrtr$rn6erboll g%6gbgq,gcngr6o qrr3b0r6rgbr, 396dorqr qrob36o0o6r6oot_r AbCOCbob 0gll$r3q,,:, 0rn6o69boL J6rn69qrgt6,:, t66o096qr,:6ogbob qrr %r'r5.rqro $o6,:qrsqrgbol.l 6.lgg0ob CBqlCbr 6rn6rn6g g6drn rbg3g brart6r.r 3ot6g6ob 0o0,:6or. 0ogbgqrr3lqr JrEr.rbAeCbE otr Or'rbqrmEgbobr, bs0$gbr6rnqg gbqr.l rqo6o06rnl.l, 6r.10 XCd) JoSgCg ,:6tlgbobt_r l-rb34gclrbgr b,:0r6orqrgbt6ogo 6rn60gbo eJ br63CbCbo, t6rn09qo6 blbrq,bo AbAmCE',b pj06ob 69rqg6 erb63oq,Cbrb CWCOU6TA brbrbs)60oCq,lr.rlr 0rbb9 qrr3ot-r6gbgq,o qro!36o0o$r6oob rq0ergb3t6oU qrr orrbrb$rn6arbob g%6g63gq,gcrgob ggbjgor, berq,,rn qrol-r36o0o6.:6oob6c6 qgrbr6sE CbUE b b3q,b 3tsq,ob ggjgg6rqr rqoqr6obgrb 8ol-ro sgr6qgC3cp UBq,CbCbo. Jq6ots6UE o br6pb3bo 0godq,gbr gj3Lr 6cgoq,,>q9 br3gr'rol. 1. l-t,:jt6o6gq,r.rb er66,:6gq,o 3r6r'r6ot-r ,,B6r.r0ob 3rnqggit-rob" 38-9 Opbq,ob 09-6 Sg6igobr qgr ,,brar6ar bs0brbg6ob Bgbtbgb" l-r.: j.:6a63q,erb J)bsl6ob 127-9 0gbq,ob l-q,o Jg6jgob orbrb0r(,, qgrtJJd0Cbgq,lr 8ggdq,o.> lgrEbrC0Cbq,ol.r 0o96 g.:0rng90gq,o 5sot3oUggqrgbob b6dr6gbt arrtrrBo36crL b6ds6gboll Ooqgboqrrb gt6on orgob gr(,rBo. brAcnCsq,lrjer LcJ6r'rg9bo 3erqggjbob 3632 0pbq,ob Oob3qr3oco, 6gbob0o36 Jo6b, 6c'r0gq,o6 cnr8b eolt6o0o6rgoob 0t-rb3g6Jqrq.o 0oo86g3b, flBqrCbr ,:j3t-t, Illbl0t6oq)sl0o ACoor$slt-r t-rc6Bgq,o o0 Jo6oli/qrt$gbgbgq,gbob $obuq0q96, 6r'r0gqr0rg, Oobo 3r6rgqroor, Oob 0o0,>6co eotJ36oAobJooJ bJbrbr't6coCq,,J. Url,r.l0r6orqroLorgoll bs6B3q,oo 0o0;6cn3.> E3brdq,gbgq,or 3 or3ob 5r68r3q,obr0o, O.>l-t tsgEq9g6 6.:6 Jot60l 6ro6rn 16 g6qg,t 6195o o0 6.:630or3bob 0gb,:b3b, 6er03q,og Orb qnb36o0o6;0ouqre 0o,186o.:. ,,qrob3t6o0obrgoob 69q,r gr.r60ol-t rq8rngb36ob ts3brbgb" 3rbo6ob 0g-9 Ogbq,ob Jo63gq,o Jg6j6o 3cr XqbCbtr, t6rn8 Urb.:q,br.r QrEgSCqro rBgt6Sbb bcj@ob $r60rngbcb, cDU b53b6ruq,sl qrob36o0o6,:goob o0r33 grj$oU bJar'l e,rgJb brur0r6cnqx.r bJ6oboq,r3b. Utbrqrbrn qr,>6g3cq,ob J6ljgo3oqrrb 6r0r.r0qro6rt69 ts3odqgO,> oorj3tl-r, t6r'r0 qrob36o0o6.>gool.r ArCOCbotr gOgggbr.rbc Ab3b,> E6r'r0ooo b9qB336gg9A90ol.t ts9$939grb qrott36o0o6.>6ogq'o 0r.rgo33bocn. o0 Jo6obgbtso, 6erqrgbr6 qrUrj0gbgqgbb r6bCboo,bq, 03o63 qr{6r'r 3dqt33ror 0rSgr$$Cooq,Cbotj 5dlrt-rrBo3636qrrqr qrr blbrq,brn QrAOSCq,ob Eogt6 bcjaob br6boqtol-t 36r.rggl-rtso odgq,gbooro Arbr0q,C6otJ rbrtq.:g69br c6 0r'rbqrgbu, 303$9b ts304rb333r0o, brbcqtber e,JAG3Cq,lobcDgob Oo0rttror3ob Jr6rqrgq56,:qr 0cn0Bo3r6o blt6Bgqoco 0o0r6orr3tr brbr0r6orq,obrg, 6.10 o$393U Lrrbsq'bo er0ogCq,otr 8o96 bsj0oU Sr60rngbot-t 09B969b.:t-t. l-tb.rq,bgt erao3Cq,Ar U3gC rn6 06oE36gq,r'r3;6 Lsjagbg 09,>896.r t-rrjOol-t 0r6boq,gr brbr0r6orq,r'rlro6ob 0o0s6orgolr blao. brbJE br'r pJS3BCE,o JAJJAJ(, bJboboq,J3tJ 8 tqrs0or6olr qrotl36o0obrgogqro 0rogo3gboor 6corr3obggq,gbob Lrr3ocnbb, L,:qrrg rb333 odgq,3bgq,o oj63bs E3cB36<nb ttjOott $r60r'rgbr l-rrLr.>0s6oq,rntso l-rc6Bgq,ob tsCgr$ob Ao'bCbocD. o6o39 Bgodq,gbo oorj3lb bb3r qr3gbbg, t-rrqrrg brbr0l6orq'r'rbrqt0o 0o0,:6or3ob 3rQr r6oti b50o cDBC sgJ b;e,Jo 6r.r0Bo3.r6t-r t-rrt-rr0r6orq,rn0o l.l.:6Bgq,o 0grj3b oOotr 610o, 6r'10 borbolr l6r9cqr369botl 0rnorbo36rU 0gdqpblr. tsCeCbrqg 3oqgbco o0Jr, 6r'10 flrA6r3o (,r3r Qr O.:on b$6rgo 0r"r63r63boL Egbrdq,gbq,r'rbr l-r.rbrqbo qrrOgggq'ob 3r'r0J3$96goob 6.:t63ar 6Bgb':' lrsbtq,ber qrr063gq,ol-ror3ob qr.r l-rrbr0rt6orq,r'r0o lrs6Bgq,oor 0o0t6or3l l6olr do6oorrqro b36gg9bo o0 brbgqrO$oger Jr.rqrogo3ob OSCCOU6JA A56brbo60oCE',Cbq'lqr, 6lbrg qgob36o0obl6orborr6 b6derqrt 6gq,obb0erbl-r. t-rs3$r.r60qrgbq,r'r b.:qrg olr3 69odq,9b.> 0o3$gcrb, 6o0 U,:brq,bcr qgrAo3Cq,otrr qrr l-rrb$.:6orq,crb ggbjgo3bo ,16 gr6r3qr3U g6or0r63orb Qr Arcoo S6orerbq'o3o oJbJJ6bCbobr, gdtong6oqr;b0c63bol-r 6toor, r'r6o36$o63bgqro ognb qroU36o0obl3oob5'rb rerAorbcDr CBCCgp6 qt.:6s%9. q-or063Xq,ll-t Bggdq'or Jrbs)6ocr, 0o6o$3bgq,o ggq,gbr0r'rboqrgbol-r gr63q'3btso blbrq'brn b6gq,ggrgoq,rqr ts9ob$rgq,r.rLr bcj0ob $Cqr 6l630rngbl (,r 0br6ob qr0l6gbooro 0gc0qr6o0q,erbgbob 61169B9 aror.locnbr.t3(ntr 0$3o6bgq'9bgbo, 36obgbo, qrngEg6$3bo, Or'roanber3rnl-t rbbbr-brb0J66CbCbo, Brror6ob brgjbJgt6$r'r 6t0sB3q,,CACbo, 0oo$3ooll l;J9gorq,obg9bo, 9ilrJX669bo er trb3t. t-rrbrq,bcr QrAo3Cq,o 63rq,g6{9 ,:6r63bb 0r'rgq'g3Jr qr gb0r6gbr 0br6gU qrob36o0o6c6oot-r gsj$ob qqrqgbCbrBo. brbsq>br.r q.orOggq,ob 0o96 trrj6ol.l b63q,9rngoq',:q B3li$l3q'ob ts30q996 3o 0bl6gb 6lglqr3oq4ggbr b,:br0r6orq,er0o bo,:6ob r5.rbgrgt63bob 0oorbo36c. grnpq,o3g 9b 3o gb6g6pq,gergb ltr3r6rgqrgt qrol-r36o0obrgoob g.:jgolr ArAr.rBq,,C65b, CBCCOfl6 69r6o69brb Qr AbbSC6Jq'or qrb0r6gb':b' 6lr6qr; %90rntq5oBbgq,olrr, B3lldq,gbgq,o.l, Ulblq,br.r QrA3Cq,ot., 6Bgr036qgrgooL 6rn0 b.>l-ru0r6orq'r'rBo qrl3otr 6r56dgq'9br 16 6ror3.>q,ob$o6gboor brqrr3er tt3oorbo ob3 0r.r63r6qr9b, 6rbqgCL trtlo6s), 1616 6r0r'ro$gg3b lslt0r6orq,r.rb 6r663o6cr,3Ju rA $oJoU qrpbolr6r6. 0gb.lb.r8ob,:qr, 0o69$6o.>, t6rn0 06o6gbgqro3;6ol [tb;qrbo q60g3gqroborgob 6o016o13ol.r 09jr5ob0ob 9g9j6g6rnbol.r grtrt6qrobro6ob cagoq,gbgq,o l-r.r3.:6r.r60qrgbq,o 6r6r6gogboU ts9jE6r. b,sb,sq,brc e,tAOOCqob pr bsb;As6oq,ab, sd a6o 06o0362q,ogc6o o6b@ogg@olt ots1sttibgAa\ob gb6gfo2q,btgegsp 06o0g6gqx,zg,t6os, 6rq0 6gq,og,26t oj5C\t ACO;6oq,o ,,b,:j,;6agggrclt b;da7fuq,s7fu brt6o4;Xl-x,t gagX;lbob" 36,7 dgbq?o, lt,>j,:r6aggg,<,tlt a66s6gq,o 3s6a6olt ,fi6a6ob 3aqtgjbob" 38-X ?gbq,lt,: e6 ,,lbxl6o bsAbrbgt6olt 0gl-t;bj6" b;jc6agXq,ab gc6a6olt 1271 1gbqcno eJ ptCArlaLt 6n6030o, r6rn0q26o6 gsoorysqobfoij\lt, 6r,t0 ltsbsq.,ba erA1gCgobogob 0odstSotg; 6l0aofgggb .>a Agbq,26oot gsqgg1oq,o OsbsE%6CAoLt 7rpS\ob p26olt 7gBgtiX\;b. 2. tr.:jr6o39qr.rb b,:0rnjcq,rjo 3r'rpgjlro Jqg6Cbtr brbrgrtOgq,obob bb3.:qgrbb3r 3rqrgbb c@r org o0 er6e3CaCbolrb 0o0r6orgboco, 0c6rq,oorrqr brbCq,E&j63q,C0o ergC0otr brbqr,:b0gq,r.rbob 3rqrro 3 $gqo, gd6r3 jrnbgbrborr6 erJrg0o6CbgE o brbCq,BCa6gq,lgbcr qr,:pbob 6 $Cqr", q99q,ojggr6o 3Jq,aCbCE CACAoLI tsgb6gq,3b.:l-tor,:6 qrr3l0o6gbgq,o q9,>39bob 3 $3q,o, brnqxn br.r6rqro brbqrrb0Sq,arbol-t 3.:qt 10 $gq,o. o0 0o%6oco, 6rn0 qrob36o0obtgoob 0bb396Jq,o oj6;tt Jqe,bC6oq,o or.r3ol.r ggq:gOgbtso qr.> 3jr.rbqggb 0oggEgbgq,o ArOC6orE U6o er 0s)6iE',U6o %o$ob $rtqrp6gbolr ggqCbr, b,:j,:6copq,oL ltr0rnjcq,,>jo ).1;J6oggbo 3erqgjbob 363Lg @gbq,@r 6,:oor3,sqrolr$o6.: Jo6otr ggqgbr 0o0r6oxnl-r btbr0l6orq,r'rb bc6Bgq,oor o0 6.:6g0r.rgbrboJ6 etJ3tso63boor, t6rn03qrog 0;b qrol-t36o0obr6ogqrrqr SorB6or 3 ar3ol.r g$0r3q,r.r0rEo OcU Eg0q936 619 r0 Jo60c brobr.r JE U6er brCbo rQ6ots6UE o A56C6oCbob tsCtJrbCb. g6qgt rqo6o06r'i.l t6rn0 qr;qr6g6oqro br0or3o.r6o BJet dJq,oJb 0go6gs b.:6qrrt0gqrr.rbotr Lb3.r grq,Cbolrb Bgqrr6gboo q)r r8rbob6 ,:6 s6ob br30r6obo btb$r6cnq,rn0o tr.:6Bgqrob 0gbr6.:6rq qgr brj0ob 0rblq,,gbob 0erbt0t.:qrgbq,sqr. 3g6doqg, OocnocnSbgqro 3rqrob 6r60r3q,r.rbr0o qrob36o0o6.rgoolr t-rr3r6rgqrgr 0bbp6Jq,0s g6qgr 0er:US6ob: brr%6Cbr, 6rn6 ob br6C6oCbr, 6er0gq,0r6 bgq,o tsgg0.:qrs trcj$cngq',rnb JJEmEAeCbE 1';bo6r) 6ror3,:q,ob$o69bgqro ggq,gbgbob 6glq,obgb.:tso ogr.r qrolr36o0o6r0o3E o; Orn3Obcqrob gbojmq,rn6og6lqr qr,> Oooqerb 6lqru$$C$oq,Cbr brJ3cDr6o UBE CbCbob qgrbrgr3rqu 8r'rodor.rb o6g3qgjgg,>qg6o, rqr.:6os6g6o (cng 6rqgrggo$r, d)c'rA blo6qggbr $r66rn0uqgp69qo), go5,rbbg6o 6gbg6bo (brU$rt6orq,r'r br62qgbo), 610 Urlo6r.rr t-rr0r6orrq,$r60<ngbob 36r'6gboUor3ob; 0r.rrbg6br.rb brjOob grjgmb6qo 5.>630r'rgbgbob 0gb.>b3b .:61-rgbgq,o 0g3o6bgq3b9boLr 0r'166o39b,:/Or.rJr.r39b,: ; b,>jOob g.:jgrnb6og 6;6g0r.rgbgborrb qt3r30ot6gboor Ec'rodornb QrArOCboo o53rn60'>6or; 0o.rEb.:qrei-t bc6Bgqro. U(.lgCE,o3C %90ruq6ots6gqrobor3ob, 3o 3 or3g s6 r6ob br30rt6obo. tsglrsbraobrp, brbrqrbgr qr$633q,b 0o%r6tsg$rn6oq,.:qr 0o186ol, lqboBbgq,o 3rqroU br0o or3oqrrb 36or $qr$qgg 6.)%6q,r. 3. ,,qrob36o0o6s6oolr g33q,; 3o60ob rq0r'rgb36ol-t 8gbrbgb" Urjr6or39q,r'rb 3r6o6ob 09-9 O3bq,ol: Jo63gqro Jg6igob ,,b" fu9fu6igob B3b,:bs0ot-rrqr, b,>j.>6org9q'r'rb brbrq'brn sgJaoScq'o ,:B963bl-r t-rrj0ol-r $r60er9brb, cog br3r6rgqrm qrob36o0obrgoob o0rgX grjgob brArn ,,AoAQobr6Cobl-, い lqr0o6otrg6rgogq,o $r60ergbr". tqr0o6oU66rgogq,o $ct60r'rgbo rq0rb63q,3b3qo bgq,oLrggq,gbob brjOorbr.rbol: 6s$oq,ot, 6rn0gq,o6 grt6orrn qrob3693ooor 0o%r5tsg$r.r6oq,r'rbocn br66gbq,rnbb. Eobo Urj0os6<nbob b369bob 6ror3rqob$o63boor, "Je6oE s(," €godq,gbr Oer3oqrgb 3r.rbgqrojgtso 5(,50oJ6ot., 3gqr3b3borr6 qnb36o0obr3ool-r grjgob Brqgg6r ol3 UJ3C 0r'rbqgr jpOq.ogcn0o rqr0o6ol-r$6r6ogq,o rn66r6erb 0o36, b38qg6c'r0 rqr0o6ol-r66rgogq, ert66rbrnl-r s6 6rtB6ot g63 0rn0bqr.:6 EICO%C 69;5ot63bobs Qr Q,r6QSCUqo ggq,Xbol,r CBJCOU6o sqp6g6ob Bgb.:dq,9bq,erbu (qrob36ro0obr6ool,r gcj$ob qrsq.o636ob, %or6otr rbr%q;g6gbob, 6o11 6r0elg ol-r l-rrb;q,bo et033cq'olrb brjOob 6rbboq'3ob cq'gx66r6ogqroqr ogj$obOrqg 16 tsgodq,gbr br6goboq,oo; gBg;qoqr rqr0o6ob66,rgogq,o $.r60rngbolr qr6r'rtl btso6rqg reboE o .;j3b $,>60cn9boL 6ulor6363bub, $o$r'r0 $.>68ogbot-r qrrl-r63q3bobor3ob qrrq,r.rqr3br qrob36o0obtgootr g.rjgbg 6rg.:6ot6gbrl.r qrrcarn36gbb. 0gbrbrOoLrqr, 0o63186ol, 6rn8 0o'br609$rn6oq,o oj69b,r, cog 09-9 63bq,oq9;6 Eorq'orfilqr rAslqCbgq,lo oj696c ,,b" #gJgbj$o. 4. ,,qrob36o0o6,:6ool-r gpq,r go60ob rq8ogb36ob 0gbrbgb" br jr6or39q,rnl-r 3rbrn6ob 0g-8 Ogbqotr A3-4 Jg6jgol-r tsgll.rbr0obrqr 69bob6o96o NrffiobQd,Scr"Jqro, brbgq0$ogo bgqrolrggq6bolt pr re0oqx'lb&Eo orgoof6st6o46qo6oU r.r66rbrn (0.1o 6c'r6ob, J6s)JU6JOU6otr, l-ts6t0rndo9bo, t.tbr0r6orq,rn rn66$r'l) gJqlACeCSI,crJ l-rrj6ol-r 5;6boq,3;borl6 qrr3s3tso6303qo OrU,:qrr, brbpoto, Jbb6r-ArbAr6$Cbr er bb3r o6go66.:go.t Jr6r.r6ool qrrqr6gboqro $3t-tgbol-t Qr3SocD 6JQJIJ6Cb bsj$co3gq,r.rb bsbsqrbrn ArA$CE b 0r.rorber36oqrr6 10 3lq,gbqgr63q,o qrqob 3rQJAo. o0JBC 0gbqob tsgbrbr0obrqr obgrn6Ergoolt Ooqgbl 3g6do .lc,6crbbt6 tsgbrdqgbgq,ol 0boqoqr 6g0lgogq,o6ocD. Uubrq,brn sgr0ogCq,ob $r60ergbstso .>6ttgbcrbl-r 8 b.:jOg qrr 15 qrr%r6cq,3bgq,o, brqg,:6 OeBrbgbg 16ol-1 396do Jot6o. Jt6,:jgo3r6o g333 t6l-rgbr.rbb er6o tsg0orb3g3r, 6r'rqrgbr6 r'1601 3g6der t-t0r6orq,ob og6oqrogq,0.> Jo60.> obgr.r60rgol 16 Or'rr$rnqrr brbrqbrn q.:06pqrb. Jr6o68o 16 u6l.rg&nbl-r bg63ggo, g6cn63,>6o odgq,3Ool-r 09jr6ob0o, 6<n0qoLt O9ts33arboa;rg 3g6dar br0r6orq,ob og6oqrogq,o ql gobo3g6o Jo6gbob5rb Or'rbqgbr brj0ob 6r6boq3,rborrb qrt3u30o63b3q,o Ocbrq,ob, brbgorolr, rblrbr-AbEab6OCbobr qrr bb3,r obgrn6Orgoob Ooqgbr qpr o5o ao6qroboq,or Obrnqroqr 0bu6gor 3gonqr 63br%g. rq6ots6gqro 06ots36gqro3r6 J6r'rbqrg0;b j06ob 36sjgo3.r6o, 6tOqrgbrqrsg l-rr30rrnqr 6cngq,qr3br q,J %oAXC6 ts33dq'gbgq'og Jo 56ob [rrCAob 6c696r'rgbgbob go3gq,0b6o3o AsAoJBE Car, qrob3t6o8o6rSoob qrrqr696r QJ Arb95C bccn$rqro 69.r6o6gbob 0rnbqrg6r. bsbsqtba g;anCqb 0osB6os, 6a0 0,tt7ot26gq,o o;1690s ,,qrob36o0o6'sgoob g33q'r ger60ol-t uq0r.rgb36olr 0glrrbgb l-rsjsr6or39q,ob Jrbsl6tso" obgon 8s6cf96olt 6s32ory0c, 6a0q'ob 03blbl0oltsps6, otg 3g6dot Jo6g0o s6 bry.:tirc p'tfiXb26gqe262Ao s6 fc60tttqt52636 0aabag6oq' o6ga60s6osb e,) brCACAo ,:6b36gq,o 0sbsq,26o ;106o16 9ol4t7o0o6s6oob g;fi)ob t6lt2aa6ob fubtfuT 6e6og6gq,o gctisggob bcggdg7q,b, 0,t0o6 lt;8ogt60o/6,:66bspgAs0o 0ootootg0gq'o gtCla\ho7o gt6CAICA3Ao QTAOJz1CACyTQ fr.toorysqab. rlr3or E90orb393'rBo, cnu l_r,>tso3r6Bo/5$gbrqr3b$o Oooroorgbgq,o bJ6caslcbcbo og6oqroSq,uqr .:0,r6coqr9bl,r 6<'rorbcr36sl-r lruBogr6o/6$gbrqggb.> qrr30,rgrngoq,qg9b.>, So6ocq0q.o36 E30orb333r0o 0b,>691'r 916o 3a{093r Oot-r qrr30rgogoq,gbs$g grjgerb6o3o g;6g0r"rgb3bob px.o.)trgg6gbgq,sqr 0oB633s o6gn60rgool-r 6rn3$oq6bq'r'rbob.rl-r ojbgbr jagq.oooro o6bg6g036go, 6oE bcboq,br.r qgrA3gCq,Ar Ornrbqrobcrb o6$oqrol-t36o0obr0oUq'o 0gjs6os6ob Lsorr6rQsl(, rOrnjOgq3b.: qrr qrru3ob6otr o69r.16013oolr $,r60rnqr636ob ,:6r3o6qrrJo6o bgoOgq'ob 6o0g90o9 oj69b'> 3o 3rq,q-o9bgq,9bc ag6der Jo63bb. 3b o6lr$63036$o 96or63r6rq9 gpq,r p6drn Jo6otr.: qrr bras6r.r qr.:$gtrgbgq,gbobuar3ob, 6rn6 lrr3r6lgqro qrob36o0o6l6ootl BTCObC OrcDo J<nbogor qr.r.rgojbo6r'r6 qrr o3ob6rn6 brJot6obSo6r'rU 0$3o690o1-t g3o6on' 5. qrob36o0o6,:goolr g3gq,,r ggr60ob rq0r'rgb36oU E3brbgb 3.:6r'r6oLt 09-6 Ogbq'ob a9-2 Jg6j$ob ,,t" l4'-C ftgJg6jgol-r qr ,,Utjr6opq,r'rU b,rbcq,ber q.os0o3CEotJ Egbsbgb" r'r65rbgq,o Sr6n6ob ogbqrob 0g-2 Jg6jgob ,,or" $g3gbj$ou B3L$r0obcqr ttbrq'ber qgrao3cE,o ,,ggqrgbr0erboqror, 6r'16o69 q9ro6gg69bgbgq0r 3o68r, brj;6orgq,rnU .:qr0o6oUg6rgogqro b.>J6r'rggbo 3arqgjtrob 0gbrbr0ol-tqr 0o0r6cnrqb bcbr0r6orq,r'rl-r eJ AoocDbo3sil tqr0o6ob66sgogqr-tl0r6oqrgb6o3o rj6ol-r 6.:0r.19301 56 CACeCbob gt6brn66ogq,gbr, org rQAo5ot.,O6r0ouq,0r o66rbarE 0ol.l 6go6g6qrr6orLr 16 UJrbUbr cb gb 633cr0gbqtr6or 16 6sobol6r q,r J6bCbclbtJ bca0r6obo 0g3o6gAgq9b9bo, 6r'r0q,gbog qrob36o6o6sgorb 4.orb6363bb". rtr933 ,,b$r6ogq'r'tb bsb.rqbo erAG3Cq,lob tsgbrbgb" art6gr6gqro JrEc)6oU 2+1 Agbq,ob tsSltbr0ottqr ,,brb9qr0$ogor bgqrobggqr3Oolr, rqr6oq,r'rb6o3o cr6oor06t6or39q,r'rbot-r ro66c6rn, l;rxr6o q9,:$5b9bgqrgbc, olrbsAeCbobob Jo6o, 6rn03q,o6 0ooq9bl,r brjcricn3gq,erb brbsq,bar qgr@g3Cq,otJ 693r'r096q,:3o3bb 16 $o6,:qruqrgbgbb, 3.:q,q93bpq,oJ brboboE r'rtr obo6o qrc 20 qrqotr 6r60r3qrgrbrflo $g6oqroboor rgbr.rbob bcjs6o3Cq)(')b brbrq,bo q,rAogCq,b Aroo brbboqBol-, ACQC0Cbo." rq6ots6gq,o OgbqrgboL tso6s6troqrrb bbAr.rAeobr6C, lltbrq,bo er06gCq,tJ brrB6or 6C5q,C6o 69649o oOoLrcor3ob, 6cr0 gtt6g639q,gcrl"t Ool-t 0o96 6c0er6c6oqo Arqqr$g6Cgoqrgbgbol.t rqb6Sqrg6c rqr0o6ol-rg6rgogq,o cr65l6r'r3botr 0oE.r6or. o6qg brbob 03j.r6o9r0o ,:6 ,r6otr 6lo6rq,ol-r$o6gbgq,o gobo3g6o qrr 33ttrdr.r br0t6orq,ol"t og6oqrogqro 3o69bob 0o0r6orcA. o0 0g0cnb3g3r8o olu go%o3gt6o Jb p6dcr b,l0r6orq,oU ogtioqrogqro 3o6ol.1 0o36 5rbbgr6gogq,gbgq,o br3l6rgq,ro qrob36o0o6;goob grjgo lgJQrbOU6Qcbr, tJrbrq''bo QraoSCq'o 090r.rogr66q,gbr 693r.r096qrugoob rE bog4go $obsqrrqrgbob ArAsIgC0oo. c0ob E96qrg6 16 r6bgbc'rbb r6cbro6o bgt639go, 6.ror.: g9r6g63Cqgmgoq ojbrU 3g6do Jo6orr 0b6oqgrb 6g3r.r096qrc6oob 09U6gq,9bob !rgerAbCq.oBCq,slbr 16/qto gb6g63gq,gogr. 0gj06oq, 3oors6gbrEo rg6oq,9b3q,or rq6ots63q,o 3qrqg3bgqrgbgbob 6c63393q'o g<n60oco g.:366q,gbr 66d<n br0,:6orq,ob og6oqrogq, q9s go9co3g6 Jo63b%93, 6':qr6s6rg ,,b,:j,:6or33q'r'rtl brbrqbrn QrA6SCq',ob Ogt-rrbgb" ert66r63qro Jr6o6ou 0C-3 @3bq,oU 11 Jg$j$oor 6o3oqrob$o69bgq,o 9:gqr0b9qg39q,rn0ob g36jgoc, grjgnb6o3rqr q,cJq'r6r0oUq' bcboroir odgbb bbgbgbgq,o 3o6cnr $6ob 6o0s6o qrr qrol-r36o0obrgoob $o6uq0qg6 b6drnq,sl-t .r619g3jgg6b bq_oob. T7bsAs1obtg, blblq,bo q,tA11tg,b 0osB6o,;, 6r'td ,,b.t;lstlotgXqab bsbsq'ba QrAOSCq'olr fubtbX0' a66s6gqeo 3s6a6ob 24-g ?gbqb g6qr p40s6ab 336da l-ts0s6otqcob ogtlogogq'o <rJ gobqgt1o Jo6Sbob 3cqcg7\gqg\t 9ob36o0o6s6oolt ,tg0agbg6;bor6 Q;J8AI6CA2<1 b,:jag7\bg as6obo(,a6 623n0x6ps6o; qts Oloto ariboq?ob 02gx6jao t66roaa6 lt,tbsrybot a;apJq,b. 5. o0 06ots36gq'mgJ6o 6olq,,oq)s6 5r0cr0qrobr6g, t6rn03qng tlbrq'bgr s.oJao3cq'tJ caob6or qrob36o0obrgo,:borr6 pr3r30o69bgq, Ucj03gb%3, 3goj6erbor rggoq,3O3q,or, ltb,:q,bo QrAgSCq,b Oogggb 0gLtdq,gbqxnbr ,,brl-rr0rt6orq'r'rb 036rnb6ob" 0gjr6o%0og bJ0rnogCbrqb r0 3r$g6rn6ooL qrr3gbob Arbboq,gob J6r.r69bEo. 6r6pr rOobr, 06o036gq,rn3s6o5 rA bC6JCOob 6r0erg36gboll 89brdq,9bq,rnb.: 0o963l.1 6gbolr0og6 pro6g969b9bgq, Jo6b' t6r'r09q,br6 gs$6or bJg6orqrg6o gnqrbl qrr 3er0J3gg66or 0rbtrsboqr3gqr bl3oorborr6 qrt3r30o6gboor. qrob3t6o0obr6orlorb qrr3r3Bo6r3bgq, q9,r33bS3 ag6a3tier6oor 16 rt6bgbcrbb 0qroqr.r6o bolrc0c6orq,r.r 36,:jgo3r t-tjl6or3gqrr.rBo, rOogrn0 06oB363qrr.rgt6o,: l-tg6cnr6r'r6ober g,:0r.r6poqrgbob 6,:!ror69b,: qrr rqgJAorbob ggq,3brorr qrrg3ob Lrrg6cnr0r.r6obm b6sbqgrt6ggbob 6r0rngg6gbr. c0 3rgg6ar6ootl brjOggOob 5r6boqr3ob qr6r'rb ,,t-rrl-rr0r6orq,r.r 0g5r'rb6ob" oEbgogggob bbOr.lgCECOrA Egbrdq,gbgq,or b.>96ot0r'r6obro 6r0r'6qroqgboU brtor6Cbob gggorgbo B3brdqpbq,obr 09i06rb. rg6o66gq,o qrrqrgboor 5r3q,g6rb 0r.r.>bp36lr b;l.t0s6orq,r.r brer$ffiC$oq,Cbgbolr b,:6obbol.r rArqq,CbrbC, 6rqg6l6 brbr0r6orq,r'r gg6c.r 096 S9c6r'rb qrrgg6qr6mbr. $ubcn,>6,>33, o6o bgq'l.r tsgg$gerbl-r t-rr%r.r6rprn3bob B.:6orgq,r'rbrb, 619 3oqgg3 UB6<n ACOJq.o bJ$6('olj brtrc0l6orq'r'rb Arcgs$g0Cooq)Cbob 0o8.:t6or bqt(.lbol-t bl6ol-tbb. rorrarlg ,,tJrbsar6otq,eru 036rnbr6ob" obt-r$o$3$or.:6 qpr3r30o69boor aotjagqgbb ts90q936o 696gq,tgor: ,,brjr6orgq,ob blbrqbr.r QroogCq)ob 0gl"rrbgb" brjct6orpqrob er66.:6gqro 3r6o6ot-t 21-g 6gbq,oU ,,g" fugJgbjgob EgUrbroobrqr brjc6o69q'('lb brbrq,bFr qrrag33q'o 3gq'gbroarboq'or: C) ,,orq,JCfq, 0gOcobp33b8o ts0rbr6gq,rnll Lrrbr8rt6arq'rnl-r 036erb6ol-r (Amicus Curiae) gg6j6or b,rg6cnr.r brbr0t6orq,r.rgbl-rr QJ b)c56o:,3cq)sru l"rr3rn6u$o$g3oar urb$l6orq,r'rtso." ory06r, ry6o06gqn pgq'9br0r'rboq,Sbob brbbcl63oCq,CboL J6<nggbg'sq'36o 6'>6r6$ogbo abgrq,oqr bobbq,ol-r bc0r6orq,ob brJ6o6gbr.r JJ6o6A(,cbE (nboo QJ br3rn6tj$ogSgo(rt l_rr0r6orrq,$r60o3bob tsgbrbgb Jr6o6oo, r6ob 5r6;6$o6r3bgq,o. brl-ruar6orqrarb 095r'rb6ob gg6jgo,:b bsb,:q,bar sgrAGgCE ob $1616o $.r60rggboo oucbgblr 6er6r'r66 lrol-rbq'ob l-rr0s6orq'oU rbg3g br3rnbbgoo0oos) brl-rr0r6coq,er3borrb 6o0r6or3boo. rArrArQ' bcbrq'bo ArA03CE'tr $r6qg6g6oqo rj3ll Lr3.:6er60qg3bq,r'r $o6rqgrq99bc brjr6o63qetb J$q'$36$0o, 6er09qto6 oor3rq,ob$o6gbt-r .>qr0o6obg6cgopq, brJ6cnSgt-rr.r 3erqggjbao Bgl.rsbraobo G3q,oqrgbgbob Ecorbrtr, 6r.r6gq,og t66grq,SbrU Eob690b qqro6$963b3bgq'' Jo6b r663fu6$9bo/0r'rl't%63b9bo $r6pp5oboL brbr0c6orq,erb arbtJrboE,3Cq'} brj0Slrorr6 q13r38ottr3boor' rAsQC6rqg, brlo6r.rqg 0o63186or ,,lrr jo6or33q'rnb bsOojsq,rjer t-rrJ6<n69bo 3rnqggjbob" o0 ors3tso, 6r'r0gqog t$3bgbU bJ3golq,g6 Ur0s6orrq'$rdr6rngbsl-r qroU36o6o6':goJrorb qgBrSBo6CbUq' Lr.rjOggbbg, 093oq9Xb g3qroqrgbgbo/qgr0r$CbCbo, tioOgq'og brts3rq'gbrb 0obg90b qrro6gg6gtr3bgqr Jo6t_r, 6or0gq,og 16 r6ou 0br69 s6 03br09 Jo6o r0r3g qro3$o, 1669096ggbo/0r'rUrist6gbgbo $.l6gq6obrnb l-rsll0l6orq,lerb. gr,rgCqo3C %gac.rorjagqroqgrb 6u0oraqrobr6g, ,,ltj$or3gq,r'rb l-rlb.:qbo qgraGgcE,,olj ts3brbgb" <.r66r6gqro J56o6ot Ogr141 Egtrq,olr 03-2 Sgbi$otr ,,C.o" i39J36i6ob qrc ,,qtotr36o0o64oob 939q'r go60ob rq0r'rgbg6ol-r ts3b,rbgb" 3rbn6ob 03-6 O3bq'ob ag-2 JAbj$ob ,,q-o" fugJ36j6ol-t 83br0r0ob':qg Eo60o6or;3or $oErqtqrgboco 6r6tbrn6go3q,c.rco BX0qrg6o b.:3.16r'r60q99bqrer S3qroqgbgbo: 1. ,,bra.:6<n br0bsbg6ob Bgbcbgb" b.:j.:6or33q,<nb 3.:6cr6olr 1271 agbq't; QrCOrOciJ 23J36j$o ts90q935o 6gqrrjgooor : ,,(,obJ6o8obJ0oot, UBCq,lr Brn6AoL JeAoBb36ob 03l.rrb9b" b.>ju6or3gq',rnl,t 3;6er6ob go66q,gbBo l-t,:js6or3gqrob b;brqrbcr eJOogCE otJre8o aJ60brq,c6oor,fu.rBo36oo Eo0rt6or3.:, o$gmb bJr.:0,:6orq,erb 6boor rigolr brbrBog6cbob br6qr.:b0gq,<nbob 3rqrob pg6ob ts9Bg6gbrb brbrq,b<n qrs0633q,ob 6ogt6 6r66brqggbob,furBq6ob tsgbrbgb brer$U3COoE Cboti 0op3b.>6qgg." 2. bsjrt6or3gqrr.rb r.rtig,:6gq 3s6r.rbb ,,L.rj;6or39qrerb ts6rn0ob 3rnq.ogjbb" 381 agbqtt qD3Er6r.rb 0g-71 Jgbjgo Bg0qr36o 6gqrrjgoocn: ,,qrob36o0obl6oob g33q,r go66ob rq6ogb36ob B3Urb96" b.:jl6o33qrr'rl-t 3r6o6otr Er6bq,Cbtso ttjr6or3gq,arb L,:b,iqrbrn erafficq,otJrqg0o br60brec6oofurBo36oo 0oE.r6or3r, o$393b E6rn0oon bgq,tsg6pq,gbott 89$g39gol,r B3l;rb3b qr0brj8gbq,ob 5rq9r$93ggoq',gbot-t butr,>0,>6orq,r'rt-t 6boor 5,:blBo363bob b.r6qtrtr03q,r.rbob 3sqrotr q36ob EgB36X0rU brb.rq,L,r'r Q,rQ63Cqob AoC6 gr66brqggbol-rfu .rBo36otr ts9b.;bgb brqgrS$COoq,,Cbob 0oqgb,:0qrg. " 3. ttjs6orggqr<nl-r br0rnjsqrrjrn LrrJ6r'6gbrn 3r.rqgjbol; 3632-3 flgbqb QrCArgartr 054 6o$oqro ts90q996o 63qrrjgooor: ,,qrob36o0obr3ool-r g33q,r 3r'r60ob uq0rngb36otr 63Urb3b" bljr6cn33q,r'rb 3r$rn6ob 3r65qr9b6o bujs6o39q,r.rb brtrcq,brn er0Ggcq,,oLre8o brbGbrsPcboofulBo36oor 6o6c6or3l, o$393b r0 0gbq'oU 0g-2 6t$oq,oor 6ror3rq,ob$o63bpq,o bst6Bgq,ot-r b.:br0l6orq'r'rBo $,:t6qp6ob br6qrltOgq'r'rbotr 3;qrob qgg5ob B9B969brb brbrq,brn qgrAgSCE ob 0o96 6r66brqr3bobfuoBo36o[ 03UrbXb 0rar$ggCooq)CAob 0oq9b,:0q9. " 7. tr.: j.r6or3gq',<'rb Lr.l0r.rj,:q,r jrn brJ6rn63l-rcn 3r'rq.ogjbob 3632-3 Oabq,ob 03-2 6r$oqro Br0ogrq,obqrgtl E36qg6o 6Sqg,rjgooor: ,,2. blbs6.:6cnqrrntror3otr L.:6B3q,oor 0o0r6or3c 8gbrdqrgbgqror g6oro $qroll 6.:60.:3qrobrtso Orl-t ECOsgCb, 619 Jo60r b)o6sr rb gbqrc 6t96r'r oO 6r6g8o3bob 0gbrb3b, 6rn09q,o6 0ll.r qgotl36o0ob13o3qr.:qr 0orB6or." 5 ,,qrob36o0o6s6oob g33q,r go66ob rq0mgb36o[ 0gbrb3b" U,:j,>6or33q,ert-t 3rbrn6ob 0g-9 0gbq,oqrr6 rOrnqgbgqr oj6rb r0r33 Ogbq,ob Jo63gqro Jgbigob ,,b" fu9fu6igo ,,8o0qro6rt69r'rbtr .rqr0o6ol,tg6ogogq,o $.:60r'rgbr". 6 t-tjr6or3gqr<ntr b,:0c'rjrq,cjer brJ6rnggbr.r 3r.rqg3il-rL ercarOciJ 3637 Opbq,o Eg0qgg6o 6gqrrj6ooor: ,,0gbq,o 3637 brbcOr6orqrerb 0g6cnb,l6o (Amicus Cuiae) l.6gbol-t0ogt6 Jot6L, t6c'rEgq,o6 16 16o! 0b,>63 rb 0g!$g Jo6o brfibrboq63q, brdACBc) CEqCbr rj3l-r brj0ob r6bC0oor brbboq,,gr0eC rt6rbr3q,gb 5 qrqoor re6C brt tAr6oq,art., $r6gqr6o6r'rl-r br3flor6o SC6oq,a)6oon 0erbrll6gbc rE l.t,:j0gborl6 qr.r3.:36o6gbocn. 2. $96oqx.rbooro Eerb,:%696ob $c6q96C6ob Eobt6o gbqrs ogrntr 16.: J6erggLol-t t6r'r09qo09 Oar6r$oq,ob 0br6qgr$96r, r6r0gqr o6o g6qrs qrc0b0c6erb brLr0r6orqrob brorrbrqroqr tsgrgrbcrt-t bJbtJJboq,gCqo bcaocnbo. org lrsltOr6orq,er 0ooB633b, 6r'10 $S6oqroboon 0obrS63br 16 lt6ob 0gqr636oq,o rO 0gbq,ob 0etorbrn36rorr e,J03oo, o5o Ocb 16 6r6oboq'r3b. 3. brbr0r6coq,er 116 rr6ob 3sq,qrgbgqro, 6.:otrol6ol-t $96oq,oboor 0r'rlrt9r6gb,:Eo 6oUBJ6oq,o r66g0g66gbo. orgEgr, t-rJ-rr6r6cnq,r.rLr ggq,gbr rj3b, org o6o Uslo6arqr EooBEg3b, br0arogC6r'rl., bsb.:0r6orq,r'rb 8g6r.rb6ob 0o96 6;0o6br36oq,o 0r'i-r.:t6gbr, 6r'r03qro6 tsgbrdq,Sbgq,or rottb<'rb rtrCaC brer$UgC$oq,lCbob brAo$o3.:6o<n 6r$oq,Bo. 4. UrbrOr6coqrrn 3gq,gbs0r'rUoE or brJpor6o o6o3o.:$o3ocr, 56/QJ 0bc6ob qrr $gt6oqx.r6ocno 0rnb,r%6gbol-r Jg6rn6ob $o6rU$.:6o oJ6bAclbocr, b;jOoll .:t6llgboo bJEboE'3Jt5C 0olr490rqr." 5u0r.rodrbc'rl-r $g6oq,obooro 0r.rbrb6gbob t36c'r6o %9Jo6o 5s6016$9bol-t Z ,,qroll36o0o6lgoob g3gq,r grnr68ob rq0r'rgb36ol-r 6gbrbXb" b$.:6orgqrob Jr6cr6ob Og-8 aglbqob 0g-4 Jg6jgoqgrb .>Ooqgbgq, ojbrb bo693l ,,60Asgngc',oAoot" Qr BJArngrq,lobqggb 0g0q9g6o 6gqrrj6ooor: ,,6gbol-r0ogr6o rqg0o6obg6c6ogq,o, t-rlb3qr0$ogo bgq,obpgqgbobr !9r lqr6oq'r'rb6o3o co3ocn00,r6o69q,rnbob ot66.r6o (0ror tsr.)6ob, J6r'r3g6s63t6ob, bc6u0erdo3brn, brb.:0r6orq'r'r rn65sbrn) 3rq,qggbgq,or brjOob 6.>6boq,grtJo56 erJrgtso6gbgqro OcUsq,r, LsbSoro, rbb6r- 6r60r6g9br er bbgr o6ger60,>gol 3rbrn6ocn qrlqr6g6oq,o $3b3bob QrGSoo 6tq-orb6CtJ b{t6or3gq,erL llb,rq,b<n qgrA3gCq,b Ernorbm36oqrrb 10 3.>q,36q.ost6gq,o qrqob grQt0o. cDC o6grn66rgor 396dr.r Jo6olr6r6 (E6eogeegq.eeseo| 6ooqgbt, Orb br3gorr6o 0rnorbo36ocn tsgodq,gbr rg6r'bqrg6qglr obgo6OcaooLr 6rqr4g0ll,rorr6 qgr3r30ot63bpq,o rbE)ob 6rqcqgbob sgJ br8(')troo! Sroabrbgt6gbob br6aXbo. " 8. ,,qrob36o0obt6oolr g3gqrr 9o60o[ tq0ogb36ob Sgbcbgb" 1.6 j;6or39q,r'rb 3r$96ob 03-8 fl3bq,tr qr.>gOrgotr 69-41 JU6COo 0CAC9CAo 6gqrrjgooor: ,,o,U .:p0o6ob6ttrr6ogqo, ttbgq,S$ogcr bgqrobggq,gbobr er rqr6oqrob6ogo or3oor08r6or3gqrgrbot-r rnt65rbrn (Otor tsr'r6ob J6er3p6,:6g6ob, br6l0<ndo3br.r, l.l;l;r0.:6orqm r.r66.l6er), 3g6dr.r og6oqrogq,o qrr gobo3g6o 3ot6o b,:brq,bc.r q9;0633q,b 16 5sqgr[ggflb brj@gborrb erJrg0o6cb0q,, Orttq,rl-t, b;bgorl-t, ;bb6;-5.;60.>6690;lr.r trrg bb3t obgrn60r6orb qrr bj090o .:61-tgb3q,o Orbcq,gbo j06or6 grn6o36uqo Ab6rgeolr tlrggd3gq,b qrob3t6o6o6tgootJ BrCOotJ $b3Or'rboll Bgbrbgb, Er8ob lsBo3r6tso/6t6gbrqrgbrtso Ooo'roorgbgq,o grjgerb6qo 6r6g0ogbgbo qt0g3oggbgqrrqr oor3qrgbu. " 9 ,,t-t.: jr6or39q,r.rb Lr,rbrq,bgr eJAo3Cq',oti 091:rbgb" o66r63q,o J,56n6otr 241 Egbqro Bl8ergsq,obqrgL 030qtg6o 6gqrrjgoocn: ,,1-tlb9q,0$ogr.r bgq'obggq,gbob, rqr5oq,rnb6o3o cn3ocn00s6orggqrrnbol-t er66r6r.r, brar6r.r Ar$CbCbUq,Cb5, cDrbrAeCbrnbob Jo6o, 6o03q,o6 Oooqgblr bljr6at3gq,r'rb brbrq,bo qgrAmCq,ob 693r.r096qrcAo9blr rb $o6;q;q9bls, sb?g? goboJE6o es JC6drq bs0s6orc,,ob oE6oqoEcoo 3o6o. 6adlq,o0 .,eobJ6o0o6s0oolt ggrq,s ga60ob tq0agbg6ob lclt;bca".tt6r't6ob gs6aq,000o 0ooo?cblt 6Cda0C6qs0oC0b gs baAsq FodsqtqCb7\b 3lq,qrgbgq,or br6oboq,otJ olro6o qrr 20 qgqob 0)EArgq,r'rbr0o $g6oqxnboo r66rnbotr bljl6or33q,rnb brbrq,bo Ar0o3Cq,ti Oran 6r6boqSob 09q9969bo." Jr6o3ol-t6g0oor, gBr 6$9rB3oq,o 拶 ltlbrq,bo qg;@gggq,o
წამყვანი კომიტეტის დასკვნა
だ \ ― 0■ ‖ き 翌:lCmb ζ ぅ ζ ̀ORO■ R し58001bm5 8円 oo0000 4600. I〕 00〕 00b〔 l, 1)̀13RI〕 0も ヽ 0000し N i-0.!.{-... 6038 26 11- -A-1 ----2or rso*o brj,:6or3gqobJr6qrr0g66obrq.or0or6ob ggqrgbrco,: qrrgSob,: qr br0ojrqrrjr.r o6$366u6oob 3r'r0o$3$ob or.:30aq9rn0':69b Crq,br6o6 Car bgbgq,ortt rUq,o: brjr6or3gq,ol.r Jr6qrr0X66ot-r rJr6toob bro66r6obr6oo qggBrt6gc0g6gob gg6r.rtrtr jrq'b,>6r'r6 go4t6 b3or6rodSb o06o● q9響 `300bO。 30000000b q95b3355 δ 6o30響 Ob b調 OJ5qゃ JO哺 6o00bo30QOJblo o3響 0智 曲 しOo055ob ルδ 」 00bSbF ,"QOb36oOo55000b〔 爛 R58060ob δ QOoOb36ob 00bめ 0び 355o536oOJOoOb,い 」b6o∞ 岬 ob 0665馳 響 355o問 o調 6oOob 3090JbO Q。 δ 6o30Ψ Obbめ ヽ 6o∞岬ob 06い 60響 o30Ψ Ob 00bδ b゛ b司。 "bδ 」 35師団 003W"PFOb助 "Oq Ob6ob ob 恥 0 o6い 50響o355o5ob36q」 o● Ob o5o5δ ЪO bδ 」 δ 6o側 Robb ぺPbo● 50… Ob b5355o5090aqo Q黎゛5b05595353350¨ D op3380,16.02.15) "5δ 096。 90つ Ψ じ ∽b∽ 。3000000052015,9ob 17 0o60oじ bbq2oO力 06o5oboΨ o 場。 し δ 。 6∞ 出 し 5bδ bm● 5003090b0006'56009∞ 5oΨ o b53。 5∞ 60900Ψ o,o5oゃ o90。 δ 」 30Ψ Ψ 。 "し Jδ 6の 309∞ じ bδ OC」 δΨ ゛JO b。 36C℃ 0し ∞ 3mQOJb00 o3Ψ oΨ 060b 800δ 6oし 00bbb00 , 60。 し。 ∞Bb36ob 00bob06 5o536oOJOo60。 5,し o」 o6030響 出 雙∂ 3。 "90b36oOo5o600b 830Ψ 。3∞ o66550Ψ 355o50o,,86oOob 3∞ 90」 し。 Qδ ,,し 。 6030Ψ ∞ bじ めδ ttbOや δ0030Ψ 。し 00bδ bOゲ Jδ 6030qPmし ∞6655つ Ψ 3● 5o団 o33Ψ oΨ 06。 し 300δ 5ob o5o6JbO bδ 」 。 ∞66559ぐ Υo 355o5ob 360o」 Ooδ ∞。 69憾o300606oo δ 6030Ψ ∞b じ δ bδ ttbO e50o30Ψ O。 ` 6の 30Ψ 出 3。 6。 90050し も 5JS6∞ 30Ψ ∞ も し 」 J。 356響 o6050oし 606Ψ 。 Oo50ob 150‑0 00bΨOb 00 2 396」 oob "ゃ J303っ 明Ooし 。9。 60oし δ 6∽ 30響 d53。 5o5ob 00‑6 00bΨ ob o」 δ 賛Oo3b360も 00い b06 し "QOb3600055600b 830Ψ 。9∞ 0023っ 6」 ooし p J3南 6JOoし Ooい 0。 30oboで ,o60oo9605oも o355o5090δ ΨO'0559δ 9065, b。 3じ や 。 b36000550oob 5Q00も 58b360Ψ 。 6o00Ψo3 0o%55● oし δ 980」 05oΨ o J809ooo 95 し b3j。 o6● Ob36000550oob し b3063Qし やδ 6賛 300Ψ 0 5o00Jo5oЪ 006。 し 00Ψ θ ,6∞ Qδ ooD」 00。 ttQ関 5ob 605Ψ 96 00b。 OΨ 06Ψ 06 00b000b 099060b δ bδ ,く o06oe,oUq, bs3oorborr 3erOogggb bs36rn60q.o3bE c.r $obrqrrqrgbrl.lcnrb qrs3.:30o63boor 6uB6or Eg0qr3go ts36ots369bo qrr 0r.rb,:%63b3bo: 1. b.:j,>6or3gq',o bsbrq,brn q;06gq,o 0oo8633lr, 6r'10 6gq,oq,gbr gbqrr oj6gl.l 6C056oq',o ,,brjr6cog3q,erU b$ojtq,.rjo b$6erggb<n 3r'rqggjbob" 363'? Ogbq0o, ttjrt6otgq,rnl-r rn66rbgq,o Jr6cr6ou 38-3 Ogbq,br er ,,l.,rxr6o b.:8ltbg6ob BXtrsbgb" bjrt6ogq,erb Jt6r')6ob 127-9 0gbq,0o qrr qrrSOrgr"rb 6r'r60gbo, 6r'r8q,3bog 5roor3uq,ob$obg0t-t, 6r'10 brbtqbct eraogcq,obol3oll 8odr6o6.r brar'rotrgcalt rB SgbqrXboo qrrqr6x6oq,o 5rl-rrBo3t6gbolr grq-o3bob p36ob 63Bg63brb. 3r.r0ogggo obor6Sblr Sobrqrrqrgbob JBOr'r6ob 6r'rlrs%6gbrb, 6o0qob orr6rb0.tqr.t13 br3r6rn6SpXbqo bsq.og 0godq3br oUg Orng$grnU, 6r.10 lrsbqr.sbrn qrr66gSqoll qrr brbr0rt6cnq,r'rLt gg6jgogbo 16 gl6r3qgb 36of$3cob er 6roro 36cnobq,o3o or;6r.>t6bgbrnbr, g6on36orqrtb0lt6gbolr 6%oor, o6oC6oo6Cbuq,o ogerb qrot-r36o0o$rgoob6l6 rqrr6or6orr CECd0U6 er6g)qbC. org86.:, 5rLror3rq,ob$o696gq,o; ob grjgo, 6r'10 ,,qob36o0obr6oolr 69q,r grn60oL rq0r.rgbg6ob 09bcb9b" b$;6o39q,r'rb Jt6o6oor qgr,,brCr6o3Cq,lob brbrq,bgr qrr0633q,ob Egbrb36" bsjr6org3qrnb o66rbpq, 3rbr.r6ocn lrsbrqrbo erAogCq,ol, AoC6 qrob36o8obrgoob grjggbolt 6r6boq3oU Arer 16 r6ob 6,:$g6oqo, r0Jrorr6, brjr6org3q,r.rl-r 'bo5rqn rqr0o6ob66rgogq,o 3rnqrgjboor 6r6brbq36gq',o 3rqgOo 16 g66gq,q.oXbr lsbrq,brn a-or63gCql95Ct. ?gb$$obrqr, brbrq,ber erSOgCE o $obrq.orqggOob r0 6r$oqob L6gq,rqg brbor6CbrA 0Curdq,r'rr, 5r0r'ro$3oob r0 grqrgbolr qg6oL ts98963br Arb3trrbq36Cqrqg. ,:8qg6tq, oOobror3ob 6r'10 lljr6<n3gq,r.rU brbrq,br.r erflGgCq,lb c6 ts3gj06rtr 6grqg6o qrrb63oq,gbr or.r3obo br3r6o60q9gbqrm 3sq,q6bgq,3bgbolr 5.r6brn6gogqgboltb, g8arnbgl-ro.l, ,,qrob36o0o6.:6oob g33q,r go6Soli rq0ergb36oU EXbrb3b" [Jjr6or3cqrn! 3$r'16oo6 qrr ,,bjr6o63q,rnt-r brb,:qbgr sgraogcq',ob Bgb,:b3b" b.:jr6co33qrr"rb rn66r6gq,o 3rbo6oor gr6olrs%q36rnb 6r'r6o36gq,o Brq)r aob 0o36 ll3r6rgqgr qrol-r36o0o6tgooU grjgor.:6 qr,r3r36o6X6oo Arcgr$U3C$oq,lCbotr br0ogr6ol-,cD3ob. r0rbcnu6, B3brdq,gbgq,or qob36o0o6s6oob bt3r6rgqrrn 0bbggt6Jq,ob 0o96 Lrblq,br.r qrl063gq,ol.ror3ob 0o016o13o11 3.:qol.r lgbqgqg3ob b56brt q36r. Oocrnorg0gq,o 3rqr3bob gt6ls9cq36ol,r 0gficrrb333.:tso, E3t6dqgb3q,o oj69br ,,Lrjs6or3gq,r.rb t-rrOcrjrqrrjgr U.:Jt6rngSbrn 3r.rq.ogjbob" 363, 8gbq,0o, lr.:j;6or33q,rnb rn66,:6gq,o 356o6ob 38-g Ogbq,ls er ,,ttxr6o LrAbrbg6ob E3li,:bgb" brjr6o69q,mb 3r6r'r6ob 127-3 6gbq6o obSoro 63q,oq,gfuboU 6r6brn6gogqgbr, 6r'r6qroorr6 brbrqrbrn qrr0g3gq,oba6ol-r 0o0r6co3,r bt8rno$BCab ra Sgbq,3boor qg,rq96g6oq,o 5rLrBo3690ob 3,:pgboU qg6ob EgBgr63brb. 2. br3,:6o68eCbqo $obrqr;qrgboo r3oar6o oorbr.r3lr brjr6<n33q,r.rlr l_r.l0r"rjlqrrjrr brJ6o6gbr.r 3oq6jbolt 363, 0gbqob 0g-2 Jg6jgoo 5rcogrq,ob$o6gbgq,o 3-o13o16o 3rqroL gsb6qrrb 96or $q,$q3 o0 8o9c6oor, 6rn6 qrotl36o0o6l6oolr trrgr6rgqrn 0bbp6Jqro gg3jgg6rq ojbrb rqqr536oq,o cosgoU ggqg06btso. ,,3rqgOb 06o636gqxn3r6o $9b6o6o ts3rj3t_r b.:0rr6oq.,or6o brL.:0r6orqrnb ggqrgOocn brt665bq,r'rbob Jr6rnggLtso6. q6er tn0r6oq,or6o brbr8.:6orq,oL ggqgbrb 5;lxpg3l1 0tq,o,:6,:qr ggqpboo br66Xbqrr.rbob 6s60r3qrnbrtso. 0bsr6gor,: brbr6tsCq,o tsCbrdqrgbq,mb1bo bBo6rqr c6olr 3rqgoor 00bggqggq,o. brbr68gq,r.r br6prbdgq,r.rbob 3rqgao 0oo8633r b.rjEol-r b$arr6rq 6rq9,r$ggggob 96or-916o CBCCOU6 6r6r6gorqr. 3g6darqr: 5,:q9rggpgoq36s gggd6g0r 0brr6gor,r 1 br3r6o6gq,ob g:ogrqro .rqr0o6ob66r4ogq,o 3r,rqrgjbob 053 agbqob A3-2 Jg6jgob ,,g,, fu9Jg6jgob or,:6rb0rqr, r0 3rnqg3jbob 0oj0Xqrgb,:, 6s6qgr o69o60;9oolr orr3obggq,gOotr or.r3obr, 16 36g9q,qrg0r btjr6o6gq,ob brbtq,bc'r qrr0g33q,ob b$0orbgrbsb3. 0o96 $r6qrp6oq' 8$3o6gbgq909bL, ts3lr.rb$ol-rrqr, O$3oggbgqgbror Uo3fl56mbr, aroo 3.r6gobo,l6rnbol-r, 6r0q3oqrr"rbolr g$ggr6rq q9rqr636ob tsgludq3bq,r'rbr 306o8363q,r'r3r63bol lr$rn6o qr obogjgg6o 6lq-or$gggoq,3bob Oobrqgb.:qr. lt0s6orrq,$160r'r3brtso Bg6qro0ol-r orr3oqrr6 r6oqr36t gJo63gq,gbo 0o$.16o.>."2. oOobrco3ob t6r.r0 qrotr36o0o6r6ootr Ur3s6gqrr.r BrCOCbo,rb qrr3r3tso69bgqr l-rr0r6cosq,$r60rn3brBo BXgper0r 0,>jtro0rql3t6;qr ojbrt-r co.:3oqrr6 s6oqr3bgq,o, 3r'10o636o 0o%.r60g$rn6oq,rqg 0ooB66b $o6rqrsqr3boo 0o0r"rorr3rb3bgq,o 36or$q,oo6o 3rqroL rbrb3lb Jrbmb6eCbqobr6o, olga6r E.:jl-ro8sqg6rq cDtgoer6 36qr ojbXb qorbrq,r6bCb3qo 8b.r69or.> o6g363bgbo. 3. lrs3rbm60sgCbqs) So6rqgoqggbob 19$r'160 oorbrn3l-r ,,qroU36o8obr6oob 63qr,l ger60ob rq0crgb36ob 09brb3b" l-rrjrr6or3Xqrob Jr6o6ob 09-9 flgbq,oll 3o633qo Jgbj$ob ,,b" fugJgbjgol-r sSopSbJ-r, cnrbrbO;qr, brjrr6or3gq,r'rlr blbrq,bro qrr663gqro rBg6gbb brjOolr gr6Emgbrb, cDU l-rr3r6rgqrr.r qrob36o6o6r6oob o0r33 BrCOob 6rA<n 0o0qro6r6Srnbl-t ,:qr0o6ol.lg6s6ogqro $,r60rn3br. rg6o06gq,o g3q,oq,gbr 3r'rOoggglt 6r6orgbgq,rqr 0o,rts6o.r, 3o6roqrrb sq0o6ob66r6ogq,o $r60cngbolr brlor6363botr 0g0orb393$o, brb,rqbgr QrA6SCE olr 0o96 6r66brqg3bobfurBo36olr 6.>6boqr3ob EXB36Xb.: bSqb B3g0q,ol-t qrob36o8o6sgoob g,:j$oL gggjgg6 rq0r'rgbg6Jr. 4. ttjs6co3Sq,cil lr.:brq,brn lgrA$Cq,tJ 8o186or, 6rn0 ,,qtob36o8o6r6oob g39q,r go60ob rq0ogb36ob Egbrbgb" ttj.:6or3gq,rnl-r 3r6rn60o gbqrt 6rbbn66oCqQCtJ g3q,oqrgb.;, 6er0q,ob 0gbobr8obrqrrg, or3 33t6do Jo63bo uE bryr6rn q9,:$gbgbgq,gbgbo 16 $r68rn,tqg66g6 8erorbo36oq, obger60t6orU q.or brj0g6o rt6t-rgbgqo Orttq,gbo j66oc6 cgot-t36o0o6rgool-t g$gob r6b3br.rbolr tsgbrbgO 6rn6o36gqo 3r6rgqroL bsggd3gq,tr, 818o6 brBo3r66o/6r66brqggbr0o Sooroorgbgq,o BrCOob6oBo ar6camCbCbo eraOJoocbUq,Jqr Bmor3rqrarb. 3erSogggb 8orts6or, 6r'10 0rn6gEgq,o 6gq,oqgbu Egodqgbr cobrbob rq6o[6gq,o Jr6m6ob 0y8 flgbq,oLorgol-t EgbrbrOolio Eobsr6lrob 4' Ogbq,ob qrrOrggboor. org0gr, 6r).lror3tq,ob$o636gq,os ob 5s636r'rXbl, 6ar0 qnb36o0o6r6oolr br3rt6cAq9r.r g;jgcor$ qr,:3,:3tso6Xboco 3o6b Bggdq,or 0oEr6ornl.r t-rrb0r6cnq,r'rb, 6rn0gqbr6 3.:6r'r6Eqrgbq,r.rbob BgbrbrOobrqr UgCE,r bC6JCOo ri3b o0oLror3ob, 6r"10 336do Jot63bob6r6 o69r"16019or ojfub Ooqgbgq,o. s0sbors5, r3grn6olr 8o96 Bg0r'rorr3rbgbgq,o grnt60gq,o6gbob 3r6r'r6tso .:brb3ob 0gOorb3car0o, oCa6cbr Llg6orbg, 6o0 Lrbuq,bo qgrAo3Cq',Ar 16 q,rrerb0u6oll LrBo3c6tso .:blbgq,o o6go60,>6oob 6$qr3oq,r'rb,r t-rb3r bgq,0oUs$3q9r'r6o $gr6rn3boqrr6 qs oO 0g0cob3g3r6o, org 336do Jo6o rb lrsar6r'r qrr$XLgbgqSb,: 16 ocnr6r0B6r.r8qSbb b,:brqrbo qr0g3gqcn.:6 o0 go60ocn, 616 l5brqbgr q.ot6gpqrb 0o186ol Sobrg3brqr, lsBo3r60o 0ocooorgbgq,o BrCOo66oBo 6l6g0r.rgb3bo B,:oor3,>qx.rl-r q.or0$3o6gbgq,.t(,. 6.:6qr,: r0obr, ,:g6oqg03q,os 316o6oor qgr9Cab6qg3b, 6r'10 lrstrrqrbrn q.o1063q6.: O3ogornqr eJ 6JcDE re g6qr.t Oogoroorerb gs0r'rbrorbn3o o6grn60r6orbr otg q9o3g836g.l6orbC. JarAo$C$o rtr33g 6ogomco3bb, 6rn6 6,r66b.:qrgb,:tso/lrttso3r60o Ooorocogbgqro BrCoalb6ogo 5r630rngbgbob q.orAOJogCbUE rq.o OoBbg3rb3 g8agrfutr E3b,:dqrgrr, oggrtr Jot6qrrJo6o grq,q3bgq3bob 6r6blbq36r 3gr6do go9co3g6o/og6oqrogqro Jor6gboto3ob, 8or$r'rqr.r6 brb,sqrbrn qrr6g33qb obgrn60r6o.r/qrrn3g036gr6or, 6ol_ro tsgglu6gqXbqrobolrorgobrg 0.ror qrrg6oU6gbsor 03tt6.r0obo Jrbgbot-r05gbq.xnbr. 5. b.rb.:q,br"r qrr0g3gq,o 0oo8633lr, 6o10 ,,[ljrr6or3gq,rnb brblq,br.r q9r063gq,otl tsgbrbgb" bjr5or31q,ob rn66r6gq,o 3rbgr6ob 2+1 Agbqllr gbqrr qgrgflrgr.rb 3g6dgr ll6r6orq,otl og6oqrogq,o qrr 9o%o396o Jo6g6ob 3.:q,qg3bgq,g0,:, qrob36o0o6s6oob t_rr3r6rgqo grjgcor6 'Us3r6o,3gq,. tJJJc}bbOoOCoom brbror6orqx'rb 2013 $q,olr 5 6og0b6nb Na3/1/531 AserfuACOoq)C0r brj0g$X ,,oU6rgq,ob 0r'rj.rq,rjg30o - orrQrb arbs[3oq,o, 6rbr 1.r6,:ts3oqro pr o60r a,r6.l0goq,o b,:j,:t6or3Xq,ob Jr6q,r036$ob $o6s.:q0q95". erJrOBo6CbUq,l lsjOggb9ca g$oboqro6 6go696pr0or er Oron 6rbboq6olr 0gq9g6Xbo rg6obr.rb ttbrq,bm qrr0gggqb, t6r6 3ro0ogggob .:iot5oor, gsbrbor6gbgq,or. 6. lt3,:6cr60s9C6qo $obrqrrqpboti 13gr'16o 0ooB6ggb, 6r'10 ,,ltjr6or3gq,r'rtl l-r:0r'rjsq,rjgr brJ6qpb<n 3r'rqggjllob" o0 orr38o, t6o0gq,o6 r$gbgbb bJg6orqlg6 tt0r6orrq,$r60ogbrb qntl36o6obr6ortrorr6 qr;3r3Bot6gbgq, U,:jaggb%3, tsggoq3b 63qroqgbr, 6r'r03q,og br8grqgbrb 8oUg90b q.o,>o6gg69tr90gqr Jo6b, 6o03q,og ;6 .:6ob 0bc6g rb 0gbr09 Jot6o 10,:39 qt3rBo, $6g8g6g9bo/0ob,:S6gbg0o $r6gqg6obrnb brt-r.l0lt6orq,r'rb (brlrrOr6oryotr 0g6rnbr6o). ,,l.tbr0r6coq,erb 0g6rn06ob" obtgogggb brn6rqrrqr rn6o qrsqgbocoo 8brt63 ri3b: qrrq3boorrqr oOojOgqggbb 0rar$$C$oq,C63bob bs6olrbolr $sqq,gbrbg, 6rqr6r6 brbr0r6oq,r.r gg6er 0gg $9,:6ob gg6q6rnbr q.or 8ynt6g 06ots36gq,rn3r6o 0r'1096gor ob, t6rn0 lrsbo6rqmgbob $r60o0sq5gbq30b Cdqggrcn brEgrq,3br, 6ar6r$oq,gobr 0ooqo6 brbr0r6cnq,r.r 6,:pr$$ggoq,gbob 0oqgb,:6o. rAoo, Jo, brico6,:qrn56rbr er lrrt,JAJ6oq,r.rU 0c.r6olr 3r3tso6o 6gr6q3br - gb obtgogggo g6org3r6rqr r6oL lr.:jco6rqrr.rg0ob 8o6,r$oqgrnbr b.:lr.r8,r6oqxo J6rogSbBo. rA ofugogggob erbC66gr qrotr36o8o6s6oob U.r3s6.:gqm BrCOCbcnr6 q9r3,)3tso69b9q, brjOmb9m orq,lrrbrc.o $o6 6rq9rqg60gq,o 6rbolo oj69br, t6J$g 306o939o 8oSbq6gbr. o1g86r, oOobror3ot-r t6rn0 cDrgoerb oj63b ,:6oqr3bgqro o6gg6gbor.: Jo6tsq,oC$o, cA6oq,gbgq,oc flogoroomb, 6rn0 bsbrqbrn qr$g3gq,b c6 r$b ggq,3br bobsOs6orqrol_r 035r.rb6otl 0<'rbrb63br $r6lq6o6e r qrob36o0o6r6oob o0 boj0Xlca, 6al6gq,crrr6 qrr3r38o6Xboortg 8,:lr Or'r0brq.o3bgqo rjgb 6g3r.r0g6qgrgogbo. gm3CqogC ry6o66gq,ob 6so3rq,ob$o63boor, grg6obSbo, 6o0 3rnaog3go 0b.:6t-r g]g6t-r brj,:6orpqerb brbrqrbo qr,>OogCq,ob 0ogt6 $.:68rnqr6g6oqr lr,sg,:6r.r60qrgbq,r.r $o6;qrqgbrt-r qrr brjrt6cn3Xqrob Jrt6q,r096gol-r r6g6qr,:0966ot_r 150-g agbq,oU 0g-4 Jg6jgob ts31_r,rbr6ol$qr, 0ob,r6ts5frn6oq,rqr 0otB6or Sotn floq3br. J.:6o3ob6g8oco, 3rbgc66 b0.:qrrd3 3o0ogggob ot30aqro0r6X