საქართველოს საკონსტიტუციო სასამართლოს თავმჯდომარის ზაზა თავაძის მიერ წარმოდგენილი, საქართველოს საკონსტიტუციო სასამართლოს მდივნის, მოსამართლე მანანა კობახიძის მოხსენება საკონსტიტუციო სასამართლოს მიერ 2017-2018 წლებში მიღებულ გადაწყვეტილებათა აღსრულების მიმდინარეობის თაობაზე (2019 წლის 21 მარტის მდგომარეობით)

N 01/188 01/04/2019 188-01-2-201904011245 საქართველოს პარლამენტის თავმჯდომარეს, ბატონ ირაკლი კობახიძეს ბატონო ირაკლი, საქართველოს საკონსტიტუციო სასამართლოს პლენუმის 2019 წლის 21 მარტის N118/1 დადგენილების შესაბამისად, გიგზავნით „საქართველოს საკონსტიტუციო სასამართლოს შესახებ“ საქართველოს ორგანული კანონის მე-14 მუხლის მე-2 პუნქტის „დ“ ქვეპუნქტის საფუძველზე წარმოდგენილ საქართველოს საკონსტიტუციო სასამართლოს მდივნის, მოსამართლე მანანა კობახიძის მოხსენებას საკონსტიტუციო სასამართლოს მიერ 2017-18 წლებში მიღებულ გადაწყვეტილებათა აღსრულების მიმდინარეობის თაობაზე (2019 წლის 21 მარტის მდგომარეობით). დანართი (13 გვერდი). პატივისცემით, ზაზა თავაძე საქართველოს საკონსტიტუციო სასამართლოს თავმჯდომარე

boj,xi<n3gqrob bo3<a6b6o6Xgoco bobrSo6org<ab 8q,og5ob ScobbgSglo bo3o6b6ogXgoo ldro0o6otpob 8o9{6 2017-18 5<qp}3o Soqrg\qr g\D5$g6oqq,g}wr oq,b63qg}ob 8o8go5*6golob oro<'rlo8g (2019 Sqob 21 8o66oL \6co0,>69oboor) bojo6orggqxob 3<o6l6o53goob 89-60 Spbcqrob AC 5 h6d6ou o,>5'>b8og, l.ro3.o5U5o61goc'r bobo8,>6oqr<'rb Anq,ogggg$oq,Clo bobcoqx'rcoo. ltjr6o4gqrcnb Uo3<o6b5o63goto lrob8,>6ocqrcob Anq,,)gggC6oepg]o SgUot6XqrgBqroq Uog,>qqg]pc9<oo bgqrobSgcqrg]ob 59loU8og6o 36.oUoo4oU. o8obo,>5, b,>3c'r6b5o53go<" butroSot6c,,cqrcob g,>qt5gg$ocqrglott ,rq'b6Xc9glo q,o Ootl3n 3-g981qo 3<n6U5o6pgop6o t'OoEq,,>60CloU U6Xcggcogoqo 6gocqro8,>6oo 8<ooarbcogb 6o6o 8<o39boL Soqrglob 6<ogco6g o,o3oqr tlolloSo6olqgr<ab, obggg lgbotruSoUo ltSgql8Sogco <'rr63o5ogboU 3b6oqr>5. Uo3<o5b6o5pgo<o U,>b,r8,>6ocqx'rb 6,>qrr66ggocqrgloorr oqrt6ScqrgtroU 36<oggbob Egq,o8b9q,39qrcotr,> bgcqir X6gcolb bgcgobSScqplob go6oEocq'gbotr l6o6go3oU,> go ogoSooSob X3qgbglob qtg3otr pE6p6ggci,gco3oL. 6o5u0q,gbo6g gco3fg56o 8c'rogogb ltjo6coggqxoL b,>3<o5l4o5Xgo<'r bdt0o6cr,q><ob 8o96 2017-18 6cq,9[Bo 3oqr9]1qo goqr>6gggoq9l9]ob \rb6Xqg]o1., 8o8qo5o69<o]oU SgUobgb o6go.r6Sogoob 2019 6c9oti 21 8n66ol, SqlAcrSo6gcaloo. 2017-18 5c9g!3o boboSo6o4qnb 8o96 Soqg\qo ojgglo qrr 8lolo rqbt6Xqrglob 8o8qn5o16g<olo 2017 6gqb bo3o.,6U6o6pgo- troboS,>6orqxo8 Sooqo 29 6oqr,>Sgggoqrglo qro 6 3,>636gU6og9b9qn bbqroSoL g,rEBo6gI,>, 6<o8qqnc.rog Uoj,>6ca3gq><ob bo3<o5b5o5Xgoco b,>bo8,r6cncgr<'rb 3o96 o6o3co6U6o6XgoX6og g6olocq,o 5<o68gbob ogg66X6o 3o5oo6bob 5o609[o (,,qo8dqqr6o 5o68gbo") doqrogo3,>63Xqtq, ojSo gScolocqro o6bg]oooq bojo6c4gqxolt A.>51l)boq)OCq,rq, Soqrglol,r g,>t6glX. 2018 Sqrob A,)58.>3c9<'rboAo b3<o6b6o6Xgoc.r Uob,>8,>6ocgx'r8 Oooqr<o 19 6ogo6g3g$oc99bo qu 4 go5S6gU6ogglgcqn trbq<o8oU g,>5Bo59}o, bojo6-39qxob l$3cn6U5o5Xgo<o bJtSo6c',qrcoU g4,o6ggggoqgloU q,D0dcq,$o 5<o68gbo drqtqo3o66pcq,oq, oj6o g6oloq,o ,>6bgloo,,>q, g,>6b,>5oqrg9qroq, Soq,gloU go69tsg. Uoj,>6cnggqcoL 3<o6tr6o6Xgoott 39 60 SXbcqrob 89-s 3X6j5ob c,,>6>b8og, Lo3co5b6o5pgo<o Urb,>So6orqroL 3o96 r6r3o5tr6o66oX6rqr g6c'rlocqro ,>j6ob doqtqt3,>66pcqtqr 3,>Scogboggbo 13o3tso6qglo SgbrloSotr 6uqru6gg6oqrgboU go8<ofu9g69loU 8ca8g56b, go6qt oB 8g8orb3ggoUo, 6<oqg$g g,>qr>6g9goq>9}o oq,gg5b rd6ot r5 Sobo SJ6ocpob d,>qmb q,,>3,>66gob bbgo, 6gooSqrgqr goqol.r. ,,bo jo6or39qx'rb lt3<o6b6o61goco lroL$r6orqxolr Sgbbgl" bo j,>6or3gqcob <n66,>5Xqm 3o6co6oU 25-9 0Xbqrob 89-6 fu5j5oU or,>6ob8,rg, ,,b3<o5b6or\Xgo<'r tlob3o6-q,<oL oj5otr go3<'rftg96glog oo3qrgb,> Sobo b6Xcq,o OCdb$ob b3<o6t4o63gocn ltboSrt6orqxol-t g9lfig6q,8g g$rnft9969N". o3o39 3o6o6otr 43 g SXbcqnb 8C-10 \5d0ob oroSobSrq, Lo3<o5tr6o6Xgo<o tloU,>8,>6orqxoU,)C6oll b6Xqro OCdlrO", 6o6qro 3o6<o5oor 3,>o3oq>oU5o59bXc9o 3g8obg939lolt, 8oh SoqrgloqtS 15 qqoU 3oqroSo ftgg6q,gl,) h>3<o6l4o6Xgo<'r b,>b,>So6caqxob gglffig6q,8g q'r g68og59b ,,troj,>6co39cqxob lru3o5<o58qg\<o 0og69tr", 6co0gqog 8cn0qrg6<o 2 gqotr g,>qt8o oj3gg5gbb 8,>b.08039 fubqob 39-11 SpSCOoU Sob9q6oc., io, tt3<a5U6o6Xgoar boU,>3,>6cnq><oU 6oqoSgggoqrgd,> qr> gob3g5o, ,>g69o39 oO 3,>5<n5ob 25-g OXbqob 4' ip6j5oo 6oc.r3oq,oU6o69bXqro 3o68o69lo go o8o3g SXbqmb 89-5 3X6j6oor 6,>o,3oqrob6o6glXqro bxojS<o 8o5o696o o8 Solh b6Xcq,o ggjbgo 3,>5<n5oc.r qoqgg6oqro Sgboor gbogqgN bbg<o3.>o,o qrrt6}r83o, $996qr9b,> bo3co6U6o6Xgoco U,>U,>So6cncqrcob ggl&g6qE9 qu g6Eog69lo ,,ltjo6o4gcqrcotr bo3o5<nSSqgbcqrcn 8og59tr", 6o.r89qog 8oq:9loboo5,>3g oftgg5gtrb 8,>b. o8obor$, 0049 &gbqoU 89-1s qn 89-16 \5d6Clol, bqXd3gqrEg, bo3<o5Lt6o5pgoro U$$s6orqxo goqo6ggggoq4doU o,oc',<', obcgb p68og5ob 8bo6g93L, ttjst6or3gcgcoL 3,>6cgro8965b, Uoj,>6og9qxob l69Eoqg56lr, Uojo6orggqxoU Sot36coloU qro ttjo6cn3gcgcob X896,>9b UoboSo6arqrob.2017 qt 2018 SqrglSo o6 6$c',gq,g5oqt 393or$6o, 6coqgUog qro6qr3o tlojo6o3gqrcob Uo3<o5U6o6Xgoco UoboSo6ocqx'rb goq$gggocqrglotr 6o0ro$ggSgboLs go 3og8o35otr bo3o6<oSSqgbqrco 8<oob<o36glo. oOobc',$, Uolt0o6orqrco OXq0qog gqocir<oltr 8ojtro8rqp6,>q, CSgdOX6n qt 8<'rjSoqro 3obqgtr Sotro 6oqr>Sgggocqrgbglob oqrb63cqpBobor,>6 qr:3,:g3o6g\cqro 36<oggqrp69[o. o8 3Xarboo oqrtrsSoBSogou, 6<o8 2018 BcqroU o3qrboqr>6 b>3co6b6o51goco bob$o6orqrco Aoq,o3oqln ,,b.>jo6or39qxob Uo3o5<'rSSqrglqxo 3og59tn$" 3<o8X6o3,>gooU gcgr9j66<oSpcqr gg9j6X6o 3<nSXSojogoob pE6pSggcq,gcogoU 8bt6og 36oB369cqrog,>5 9o63o89, 6!9 6o56,>qr>q68Xqr 5oboloqr 35go Booorgoqxob. bo3ca6b6q6Xgoco botDSlt6oxp.rl.r goqt5695oc99lob 0gqrggrq o{6r3<o6L0o0lt o16q g5<olocqro 5<o68ob docqroqro3o66Xcqroqr g5<olob 6oqqogglo qro Sobo oqrb6Xcqrgbo ItSco6U6o5pgocn bob,>So6cocqrcob 6ogo6g3ggoqrgBgBoU oqrb6lqrgb,>bot6 SoSo6cagloor gr6lt3po6gtr3cq, gXt6oqq,gtrotr oSttbp6glL 8g8o,bgCgglo, 6<oqr9tr4 tr,>j.>t6q9qroU 3<o6U6o6X6oob 89-60 SXbcqrob 8C-5 hSd6obo go ,,b,>jo6c,ggcqrob lo3<o5U5o63goco troli,$o6urqroU SgUobgb" boj,>6o3gcqrcob cn66,>6Xqo 3r5<o6oU 25-g 8gbqrb 89-3 \6j6ob boqXd39c989, U,>UoSo6ocqrco o3,>qgbb bo3Xcno6o gogoEgggocqrglob ,>q[6Xc99]ob loq4<o 5<o63ob drqtq,r3o66pcq,,>q, 6$<"gboq,glob 5o6ocq,lo. Uo3<o5b6o6pgob,>bo8,>6arqrc'rb 8o96 5<n68ob d.>qtgo3,>6g3qtq g6colob g,>qtg,>qglo bco6gogqrqglo 8,>3o6, 6<oqgbog b,>qrgco 6<n68ob g,>1gcog6gbqn3 docqroqr>3o6gXqrg 6o8<ogboggbo8 lgbdqx'ro, 6r8<no63o<otr 85o3359qx'4r5o 396dco qrr tlo5u6<'r o66g69bgbob q,r8os5gbo. og6o35Xqm 89j$o88otr 8o816or, 696gcqro6gloL 6o6939 16 qr6Bgtr otrgoro 85ots359qxag.>6o b$<o6oq<ogl6qo p6oog6cncolglo, 6<'r8qrglog caogoUo lpSgloqr$ 3u8<o8qro5o69, fuqrOo3,>qr tt$o6coglU troSo6cnq,g}6q 8<o69U6o69boU. ,>bgor Bg8c.rfugggllo 6o6tt3po6gloor 36oBg5gcg<ogoSoo o6o3co5b6o6Xgop6oq, g5c'llocq,o Jd6ot' SoSqgbo <o63,>5cnU oj5oX6o Oco j8gqgb,>, 6,>o,> lloLr.:8,>6arqrcoU 8o96 6oEU,>8q,g6Xq> gnq,o0o An5ba,60ogq:qrgtr tsgtroboOol.ro l.ro3o6coS0qrgbcpco gqroqrglgdo, t6ocno !6lJcoSttOoOX0oX6o 5<o639lob drqtgr3r6gpcq,rqr g5<olob 39qrg6rg 16 qr>8o$qgb 8gb,rl,>3obo 396drn q,) b!SD6<', oSOC6CbClo. ttj,>6o,3gqcob bo3<o5U6o5Xgo<'r bobu8,r6o,qxo0 o6o3<o6U6o53goX6o 5<o60olr docirsqro3o66Xcqtg 96<olo 2017 6gqrb 6oqrro3oqro 5 6oqo66g6oqgbotro qro 2 6s5Bo59b3o, b<oqxo 2018 Sgcq,lr - 7 goqru5g96oc99lr3o. jgg8coor go6boqpcq,o oj59}') oqSo8Spcqn bjSgglo qro b,>j,>6o3gqxob bo3co6b5o6Xgoco bobo8,>6<ncqr<nb 64t5g96oq,glotr 3g8qr6co8 g$bcot6gogcqrglXcq,o t r3$o53q,9!cq,o $q,oq,gbgbo. bojo6oggcqrcab lo3<o6b6o6Xgo<o boboOr6orqxab 2017 SqroL 15 orglg6gagob No3/1/659 goqr$gggocqrglo bj8gEg ,,bojo6orucq,crb 0<ojocpojg <'r&6 $<'r6lgGDdC 1.,!jo6orggcqr'rl, J,:6c98956ob 5o6o.rqr8qr6" 2017 SqoU 15 org|g6goqrtr Uo3o.r6tr6o6pgoco Uotro0o6cnqroS Sooq<a 6oqo6696oqpb,> ttj8gSg ,,ll.> jo6or39c1x'rb 8<njoqrjg <'10o6 So6bC5ldC b{s6o,ggqxotr 3r6qlo0955ob 6o5o,>q8gg6". Uojo6orggcg<ob tr3c'r6b6o6Xgo<o b,>b,>8o6cnqro3 o6o3<o5tr6o5Xgop6og gSco ,,bsg6c.xo lDtt8rt6cDqgogbob lgbobgb" bjo6c.r39qxoU o66r5pc9o 3,>5<o5ob 6<o68,>, 6o39qqrog oorguqnbSoSgbqt Uo,>Sgqtgoro q,r t6wcoSSqro (bjocqr>jco) btloSo6cnqxoglob 8o.rU,>8o6orqmb otSoSqrgb<obo8g 3or6oU pgoq,<nq, 6,>56gLgbo8qrg 36qm,>6 l-r.>3,>qqrgbpcq,c', ArSolrrgq,Ccq, goqob 8c',llngD6s,q,9rnbob o3 3oSqrogo6glob 8o8o6oo9, 6r'r39qlol.>g 3339 6ouB6qror 8<oUoSo6orqrgq ll>jSor&olob 3-5qroo6o A!8o9q,oci,Cbr. tdroSr6<ncqrc'r8 a,)68,)66o, 6<o3 <obo9j636oqr lgb cqplgqro ogo 0,>oro 6o6bXcqro ttjSoo6cnlob tsgb6,>3qr> q,,) J,)Eq,oq,.)Oot ScotloSr6orqrob oroSo8qgdcnloborS SgUoloSob<oboU Sggolrgll. lgbotr,>8oboq, gotlobgqgbXqo Jo6gbob 0o8o6<o b,>q,4<o 6<o68oor go6glliXcqro tsgEqXqr3,> ,>6o3cn6tr6o5XgoX6o ogo. q'! n6q'gC0q,o 8<ob,>6tgqrotr b,>bgq,06og<o ot5$qgdcnbob qo3qgbol-ro g; or$rb5<o6<olob 3<'r6b6o6Xgo16 1gcq,g}glu. Uob,r0o6cnqxoS AnqDogDq'n 5<o68ob doqrqro3,>6gXqrqr o3cSolt0qrg qo b.> gSo}l 2017 6qob 3o6g9qr j.:6<o3gcqrcoU Jo6qt3956L 6oSXboEq:g6o goq!, 6,>aro goSbcn6gogqrg\rgogco BghboSob tr3$<o58qgbc9co g3qroqrgtrglo. bjo6c.rggqxob 3o6cq,$g608,) 2017 6qob 16 qSoUlr Sooqro <o6g,>5Xqro 3o6co5o Nol052- IIU ",,ltg6orco trbo8r6arqx'rgbob Bgb,>bgb" bsjGorggcgcnb o66,>5Xcq, 3o5<o5'8o gqnqrgbob tsg$o5oU caocob,r8g", 6oL Sgqggrqog 6ogo h3o6coSSqg\<o 5co63glo, 8oc.r 8<o6oU tr,>qt3<a 5co6$ Bo3<ogocqrolq,,> ob,>qn t69q,,)jgooo qt Sotrlo oobbo tt3coStr6o6pgocn bob,>8,>6oqr<ob 3ogo6gg6ocqrgl$o Ao6OocDo6CbJq)o SU5gqcobo. qDlrlbCcq,Cdlq)o lrrJ,>6o.r68qg\co 6qroqgbgbo doqtEo lgoqn aoA<'rdgCg69lolrd,,)6.>39 - 2017 Sqrob 27 q5obb, U,>jo6oggcqroL bo3<'r6b6o6Xgo<'r b,>boSo6oqxoU 8o96 go6lt8qrg6Sqro 3,>qroU qroq,3coSr8qg. lnjo6or3g<9<olr bo3o6L6o6Xgoo bobo0o6oqmb 2017 6cqrob 16 Sc'rC8ldob IS26/658 A!qt6$C0oq'Clo t rjSgSg "ltojo6o4gqr<ob Sojoqrjg o8o6 5o{6}g6odg brjr6oggcqr<ob 3ot6qlo09ft pb 5o6ooqr8g6" 2017 Scqrob 16 5og8lg6tr tro3<'r6U6o6Xgo<'r bob,>8,r6cocqrco8 qr.:r3Ssgogoqt lojo6or3gcqr<'rb 8coj,>cqojg ar8!6 So6bCSodot, 3<o6b6o63go36o U,>6Bgqqro go o6o3co6U6o6XgoX6se U5- ,,bjo6arggqxoU bog6oo to6Sot6orq:<o9bob 3rob,>3u6a,q,go,o qobgo3qm5X6o lJrpbotrS3glqr<olobo q'! qobgo3cgo6X6o b,>3o6orsq$o60<nglob ts9b,>b91" boj,#orggq<olr p5<'r5ob 6o6o 5<'r689bo, 6oSqrgbog ,>69b6o3gbqr> 8<oboSo6oaqqrgaroorgob gobgolqm6X6o JuLrXbotrSgglqrraloU q,lJob6ClDbcD)E qtJngtso6Cl$g b3oorbglb. bob$r6orqxoL 3o58ot659boc.r, 8<'rb,>8o6or9gc.rr q,obgofq,o6X6o 3,>blboLrS6gbqrolob 8<o85gb6o69bgcqro 5co68glo, Sooo 3o5ro6bog$ go8c'r3qro6o6g, go6g3y459bo 8<oboSo6orggc.ro c.roSuSqgl<oloqtS grc,ogobXgcq,glob 69$bb. oro3ob 3b6q, 3<o5lt6o6pgoo (b,>j0ob 6oq,,>6g39goltb 8<oj8ggo 69q,! jgo,)) ,>qr6g6b ,>3 6o6ob35gqro bo8,>6o,>qp6<oo96a,<olob o66oSXcqro 3o5<o5otr lrogXJggcgSg 8co6gL6og9boU goqqgbXqgbob. h>qr>3cn ,>j6oU o,>6.:b8oq, 898<ooq5ots5Xqm b3oorbo 6o6bo8qlgt6pcqn ogco 3o6cn5ob, qrr 16r co66o6Xcqro 3o5<o5ob UoSXd3gcp8g. 8gttl$otrog, bJroSo6oqxoS qr>,>g6o5,>, 6cn8 b,>qr>gco 5co689bo qc'r68oc9p6o bogXdgcqroar g6o5ooq,0q,g69l<oq,o bojo6c,,39cq,-l.r 3<o5U6o6Xgootr 8<oo$<og6glU qo o6qrgggqro Sc.rtro66gqrotr trobgq$Bogco ooSoSqrgbcoloU qr3,>3glob 33qrgb,>tr. LJo8r6o,cqr<o8 troS#ro o66g6gU9}ob ql>Sor6gboU ar,4oq,,>6 ,>gocqplob 8o85oo, oqrSotsfucqn 5o68gtrob drqtgo3o66pqtqr g6cnlo goqouguqlo 2018 Sqrob Jor63gq> O,>ob,>8qg qo Uojo6o3gqcoU 3o6qro8g55b 8ot4,> lghdqrglcq,<obo, o6ryo6U5o5XgoX6oq, g6<'rloqto 5<o639loo1 3<o69t6ogglXqm p6o,o96c.xobr 8<og6gb6oggbo5,> 3<o5b6o6X6oob 3<oo$<og6gloL Egttb$ottqr - <o66o6Xcqn 3o6c'r5ob b,qXdggq,8g. trojo6oggqr.rb 3o6qro8g568o 2018 6q9ob 20 oJ6ocqrb Sooq<o boj,>6co3gcqrcnb <o66o6Xqro 3o5<o6o Nn2194-IIb ",,U,>g6<oco bob$o6oq><'rgbob tsgh>bg}" llojo6o,39c9<oU <o66o5pcir 3o50.,63o 63cqroq,9lob ACOrSol, otcoloSg", 6oU bqpd39c989g U.>jo6o49cqxoU b>96oco tdt0o6orcqrcoglotr 8<ottSo6oqrgcoo qoUgo3qmSX6o SoUXbobS6gbqrcnlob,> qln gobgo3qro6Xt6o lll8o6otq6s63<ogbob 6gbgbo 3cn69t6o6go ,,Log6or<o b,rU,>8o6cnq>o.rgbob 8gltbgl" lt$>6or39qxob <'r66053c9o Jn6oSocrr. ogSoSSpqro tro3r5<o6Sqrglqro g3qoqrglglo docqtlo Bgoq,o 2016 Sqob Jo6ggqro 8ootngo6. tsgb'>l>8oboqr, bojo6orggqxol.r Jr6q,$g568r o8 SgScohgg$og o6 go$<o3o X6oog6o<olo 8co6gt6o69dob 6o6939. brjr6oggcqrob bgir5b6o66oar ld$o6cnqgrob 2017 Scqnb 1 qr93g8l6ob N?J6f,t6 a\tSggC6oq'Clr boj8gSg "?lb "5o65o05 0o6go598o" bojo{6oggqob 3o6qt8956ob 5o6ouqOq,6" 2017 Sqotr Jo6ggcqro gg98b6oU goqro6gggoqgloc,, ,,13b ,,50.165o,>5 8,>5go698o" ttjo6<nggcgcob 3,>6qr>8g56ob 6o5o,rq8q6" b3<o6b5o63goco Lott8r6c.rcqr<o0 ,>6,>3<o6l4o53goX6og g5<o boj6or3gcq,c'rLr lnO<ojrqtjco tro36<oggtm 3<oqgjbob 1 99-g OXbqnU 89 2 Sr6oqroU 3o63gqm 6o6oqoqgl,r, 6<o0cqrob Sobgg3oorrg, b6B9c9oU pS6X6ggcqrg<ngob gcoSobdogboU g$cog95gloL,>! bob$ot6orqxoL tsgXdqror 806,>qmtr X86p539cggoqob 3<oorbogSotr 8<'r€orbcogS 3bo69b qllr3ob6<nb 8<obocqr<oqr5gcgo 386X5ggqgcoqr. 8<ottqxoqr6gq>o Eo6oq,ob 38635ggq>bogcoqrg 3n 36<oggboU 8bo69b gdq6<'rqr 7-qqooSo goqt. Uoh3or6c,qxo8 SoXcrooru,6<o8 b,>qo8<o 6963qror69locn Sur6rqrob 6,>5bo8q3r6pcqn g,>qt, 6og 3C3o'bOCAC!3o, lgbodqxro, 8caU,>cqrcogSgqm o6 X8635g9c9gcogob,>orgob oXgoqrglgcqn ot6boU 39bog6<ogglq,sqr bo38o6obo gcogocqrog<'r. BgttloSotr>g, boq,>3<n 5<o68oo1 3qt63g6X6qr qoqggSoqro 7-qq,o,>6o 3oqt o6o3<'r6b6o5pgq6rq 0fu qn qorqr6o6; Uo8,>6orqro,>5o lttr$,>6orqxnb xqqrglotr qro6qg6o. b,>b.>0or6orc3<o8 5<n68glob d,>epoq,oJb661cpDq, U6<olo gogoogsqo 2018 6qmb 3l 8o6OrAq,C. bj.>6cnggqx'rU J,>6c9o8g568o 2018 6qotr 4 oS6oqrb Sooqx'r tr,>jo6caggcqr<'rU 306-5o N02115-Ilb ,,trojo6or3gqrcob bo8<ojoq,ojco boS6coggbco 3<oqgjtr8o $qoqgloU 8g$$otr ts9bb91". oqSoBSXcgo g3qroqrgboU UogXd39c9E9, ltqrogco 5cn68otso o6bglXqro bq,>63ggX6o 7-qqouSo 3ogo Bo6og3cgqo bolloSs6orqrob 8o96 6o6boSqr36Xqro g,>q'ocn, 6o89c9og ,>6 X6qro oggSl6gbcoqgb 30 qqgb. .>q5o353qo b,>3o5<o58g9bcqr<o g3cgoqrgb.> doqr$o 393oq,o 3oScoj3gg6glotn:6qg - 2018 6qrob 16 ,>J6oqrb. oqbo5ots6ogo,>, 6-8 o8 3g0arb36otso br3o6oSSqglcqrco 6nqroqrglglo 6o6b<o6gogcgqt lro3<o6U6o6Xgoco b,>U08,>6orcqrcob 8o9t6 6,>5bo8gg6Xqo 3oqnb 390q6<o8.8gUols3ob4r,2018 EcqroLr 31 8r65oqr>6 2018 6cqrob 16 o36ocqr,>8gg 16a,og6co-br qr6Bo 8<o59b6o69}otr 3,>6gts9. bojr6oggqrob bo3o6b6o6Xgoo boboSot6oqnb 2017 6qrob 28 q'CJCAl6ot NoZ8/734 goqroSgg6oqglu bojSgEg "ooo3 "9698o" tro jo{6%9cq'.'lr 3o6qro8g56ob SoSooqr8q'6" 2017 6q>ob 28 qrg3g8!6oU 6rqt6g3g5ocirgboco ,,,>oo! ,,91698o" boi,>6c49q<ntr 3o6q,>8g56ob 6o5,>o98ql99" n6nJoSb6o0lgol6ng ojSo g6oloqr boj'>6orggcqrcotr b6oqtbob,>gco 3coqgjboU 265-9 &gbqrob 0g-2 6o6oc9oU 0g-2 6oSoqroqgb,>. qdrobgcqrglXq>o 5<o68ob aro6obSoq, 3ogo3gglgqo 3,rUgcgrooo Uo3oqtU,rbogco 3g8<'r589bob 8g8orfugo3o, ltgoqobb,>qxo <o6go5<nb XgqrgBo 3jco5q',>, 3oqrhbqrob Lro6ogobobogco go6og6<ob,>/o3<ocngo, 6,>g,>0bqrgqroLr j<o6gboSg 6o66ggq4lo6r 0oXbgq,4og o0oUo, 3jco6qt orp o6o 8ob bogoqtbobrqco ggocpooEglo. bob$r6oq>co8 AD6An6O,), 6<',3 ttlq,ogor 5<o68,> oo3oc9ob6o59lqro b,>6,>q'>b,>b'>qrco go646<nlob/o3<'rorg3otr Ao8c',$C5S[!t o8 8<ogXqxo]oo, 6o ScogXcpco]obog lgbdcir<oo .>6 g<'rqloq)ogo ob Uo3o6,>Xqco trogoqroboboqr<o qro3,>qro,>591o, 6o0qroU X86X53gc9bg<.rq4tg bggtr<oqt oq'5olfucqn qrcaSotrdogloU go8<ngg6glo. lgblo0oltq, boq,ogco 5c'r68oco g,>c4oq>oU5o59!Xc9o qrcoSoldogb o6 og<o q6ogo8X6o bo5o6<n 3o85ob 3oqr693ol-t g3gq:o8g So3cggloq, 38q,Xqro3o botsXocqrg!,> q,,> o6q,ggggo 3<obo6Bgqqrob lo3Xo6gbol-t XgqgboU. bob0o6o,q,<o3 Loqr4<o 6<o68oU doqtqt3,>66Xqtq g5<obo 6ogogoqro 2018 6c9otr 3o6ggqq, o3q,oLro3q,g g,> Uo j,>6or39qxob io6qto3956b Sotrp SglrJq,glcqrcolo, b3oarbo 8<og69L6o39bo6r l-ro jo6o3gcqrc'rb 3o5b5o6Xgoob Ooorb<'rg6glob lgttboSotroqr. 2018 6q>oU 27 o36obb bojo6or39q,<ob 3u6cqrr39563,> Sooqco llojo6o4gqcoU 3$co5o N!2640-IIb ,,tro j,>6ca3gqroU bogogoboS,>qcn 3coggjb€o 6cpocirglob Bg6o6oU 8gb,rbgl" g.> tr,>j,>6cnggcqrcob b,>g,>qrob.>b,>qco 3<oggjboU 265-9 SXbqnL 3g-2 5,>6oqrob 8g-2 SoSoqoqgd.> B,>8<og,>qrlgo .>bocgo 6gqrjgoo-. rg5o85Xqo li,>3o6<o58qgtrc9<o 6c9oc9glo dtqllSo 8g3oqt 6s3<o$9g69loLrcao5,>39 - 2018 6cgrob 6 o3qmbU. tsgU$o8oboq,, 2018 Bcq,oU 3o6g9q>o ogcqrobogsS 2018 Bqroll 6 o3cqroU,>8qg bo3oobo go6BgSoqro ogco 8<'r59l6o69lotr got6g8g. bojo6oggcq'ol, b,>3co5\!ogXgo<o bJr$r6cacqrob 2017 SqoU 28 qrgdCAb6ol, lS211667 gogo6gggoqgho IToCBCEC .li, "OCq,CGCOo" bojor6orggqg<ob lo6q$C50otr 6o5!oq,8q,Ca" ttj#orggcq,caLr bD3<oGU6o6X0os, bob,>8,>6oq>oo8 2017 Sqob 28 q,CdC3[C6U 8ooq,r, 6oqo6gggoqgbo troj898g,,bb "OCc+CECOo" ltjo6or3gqxob 3o6cq,o8956oL 6o6oog8q,gg" qr o6r3<'r6b6o6xgop6oq g5<o bojo6or3gcqrcob b,>g,>q,>bobrqco J.,q,cdlrol, 202-9 3Xbqnb 8g-4 6,>6ocqro, 6<oScgob orsS$3.>qr,>g, U,>gog,>l-rob,>qco <o6go5<o pqcggloScotmcqro ogco, goU36ggoXcqro XgqrgloS<oUoq4bob So6Aq)ClBo, $a5glob g,>qtb,>boqob g,>g,>8bggqnbc,3ob bogoqr,>Uoboq,<" 398co689}obob qroblg66o jco6glob qro6gdXcqrglo g,>5gbo8q36o bolo8t6.o gubc',. botroSo6oqxoS 6o58166o,6<o8 boqr3<'r 5<"680 16 oca3oqmb6o6gbqo bbgcg0dq3o6gq<n 36o6go3L, 6<o0gc9og Egodqrg}coqrr 6oga4ocqrob5o5gtro6o tr,>3oqr>Uoboqx'r <o6go6coU, b>qrg<'r 6ggXqo6glo- q,oq,6g5oqq,o qob36ggooU go66qg}3o, jco6gboU 6ogolroboqroU 6oq,>SbqrgqnUogob bogoqob$oq,3oq4rgBXcgg!,> 6o5gtt8q,36o boboSt6<o Sobob oX bobocqro6Ucn qn6g}Sqrgdob 8obgg3oo. oqSoB6Xcgo lt3oSoSSqrglqxo 6g,>cqrcoB,> odqrgcogo 5<o68ob q,otr36o3o5ogo3qtg 6o0oggSgboU 8gU,>dqrglcqxoloU q,r g6o6ooq0q6gb<'rgo oo5oU6<o6cabob X3qrgbob. ldrs8u6or9co0 5<o68ob doqtqo3o6gpqrog 6o8<ngboqrgN 6oqroqoq,> 2018 6cqmb 30 o36ocqro3qrg. bjo6oggqrc.rtr Jo6qro8g568o 2018 6qob 4 8,>oblr 8ooq,<o lrujr6a,ggqx'rtr p5cn5o N02327IIb,,llljo6a49qxob bgsgsttbsqrco 3<aqrgjUSo 6cqroqrglob tsggo6ob Egttbgb", 6<o8q>oU Uqgdggq8gg, bojo6c4gq>o.rU Uo6,>qtb,>b,>q<'r 3coqrgjUoU 202-9 OCbcgb qJCODOT 4r 6o6oc9o qr> go5ob,>8qrg6o 3<'r636gg1qo 6gUo, 6o SgSorbgggg}Bog brgrqr>ttbrqro 666o5<o pgqpl>8<'rbocqroo, A,)8<oogC6ob 8gU,>loSobo qnb36ggoXqo XgcggloS<al,rocqrgl>. ,>q6o35Xqr b3,>6cn58qrglqro ggcgoqglo doqi,oSo 393oqr go8<oj39969!obot6qg - 2018 6q>ob 1l 8ooUb. tsgUobo0oltq, 2018 6qnL 30 ,)36oq,oq'o5 2018 Sqqrob l1 SuohSqg tr3oorbo qr>6Bg6oq>o ogco 0<o6gb6o6gloL g,>6989. bojo6o3gqob bo3o6t6o63goo boLo0o6orqxob 2017 6q!'ol, 13 ogqrolnb N0V13/878 go6fio6gll boj0gEg ,bojo{6oggqob Sojoqrojgg}o - aelB} a!}6rdC qo qCA!6 }g6oo5odg ttjo6<aggcqrob 86c'r8ob, 3o586ogc9<ohobo go bogooqX6o q,ggob 8o5otr6t6otr 5o5ooq'8qrg6" Lr3<o6t4o6pgoco ltttSo6oxqxo8 2017 Sqrob 13 o3cqrobb ,,h>j898g Lroj,>6or39qxob Scojocq,{ggbo - 6coBo 3ol<odg q,,5 q,Cao6 bg6ooSodg trojo6or3gqrcob E6<o3oL, 5o586cagqxobob,> qo bogo>qrX6o qrrggob 3o5ob66ob 5o50,>q'8g96" Oooqco g,:58o59lo go golrBo36gbXcqro 5<o68o 2014 Sqrb 4 <ngbg63cirob Na2/l/536 64rr5gg6oc9glob g8dqr6 5<o68oqr 8oo86o,>. tsgU,>bo8otlog, 6co68s doqtqt3o66Xcqtqr ojSo g5<nloqn ItrjSolt r6ltgloc.ro gsSboqpob 6o6919. ,,bobbqrobo q,o SoUo Jc,83c,6C6OCbot, q,c,5o6c'[ob 6o5ooq'Oqgg fug5g}glob go5h8q,36oU Bg|l.>bgb" U,>j,>6co39cqrcotr 36<o8oL, 5,>686c,gc9colob q,,) bc'rgooqt6o qnggoU 8o6oL66ob 2000 Sqolr 5 qggSbgt6ob No24l/5 b6d,>59loU N"l qr6r6ontr 24-9 3p5j6ob ,,o" j39fu5j6oU oro5,>b8og, ,,8,>8,>3ogob Ujglnb6o3o 3,>38o6o 8o8o3ogcno5" 8oo659<o9o trotrbqgoUo qo OoUo 3<'r03cn5g56glob q'<o5<'r6<olob ,>lbcncqrpgX6 6oSoogSggg fug6gloqr. BgbloSoboq,, rqSolSXcqr Jo6or 669b b63ql'>g Jjco6qt 8o8<o6o139xq9o tdrbqnlt q,J Sotro JcrSSdrSCSOCboU qcoS<o6<olob Bgbodqglqxnio. ltUo0o6orcqrcn8 A058060o, 6<o8 b,>qo3<o 5<a68o gSUobX6gbcnqro Uobbqrob qo Sotro 3<o03co5g55gbolr 699o3o956oro 5o586argcqr<'rlob q,rg3obo go bobbqrob qcoSogoob 36<'rgglloli Xb,>g6obcogbob X8t6X63gq,gaqob q,CAoOoOX6 3o859ltr, orX8p tsg8or$g3otsog, 2014 6c9ob 4 $ cngbg63qrotr Ne2i1i536 Aoq,ogggC$oq)ClocD o6o3o6tr6o6Xgo16rq, g5oloq)o 5o60ob 0b6,4b,>q, oAo olb<',qt6l6 q,! lcq,!5JCOl6 o36d,>cqr3,>b oq6g5q,> o8 SoSo3rgglob 3o3o6or, 6<'r8qrglb4 3j<oSooor Ujglxol6ogo 3co66oj5o 0o0o3ogcas5. lrotr$r6orqx'r8 bobbqmb,> qo Sobo 3<o83<o5956gboU 6ggo3og56ar,r tmgcogbqntlo qn goS06cngcqr<'rboU goggob Oo.rgqoar, b,>qt3o.r 5o.r68oU docgugr3o6gXqroqr Ao8ragb)qCbn anq'nognqlo 20U 6q)ol, 3o63gqr 5<o98l6o8q,g. U,>jo6<nggqxob E6cn8oU, 5o586orgqrcoboU,> go bcogooql6o qt6ob 8o5otr$68,> 2017 6q,ob 24 od6oSbg6lr g,>8<obg,> b6Jo59N N{l 53/5 ,,,,bobbqott q,o Oobo 3<o83co59569}ol-t g<o5o6<oloU 6o5orq,3qrgg B3959b9IoL g$Uft,g6oU tsgbbgl" lrrj,>6or3gc9<'rb 06<o3ob, 5,>686cngcqrcobob,> qt bcogoocgp6o qtggob 8o5otr56oU 2000 GcqroU 5 q,CJCAb6oU N"241l5 b6do5g|,>3o g3qroqrgbob 3g6o6ob 8gbbgb". ry5oB5Xcgo gcqrocqrgdob 39qg3oq, 8o8o3ogob Ujglr.rl6ogo 3o3lo6o 8o8o3ogcr,$ 6.>6oli,>8q66o o6o 6<o3<o66 qcnSo6rnlol-t sbtr<oqrX$X6o 6oSouqr0qgg Bg95glo, o6o8gqr, 6<o6<o69 lggo6gglocao So5ooq8qrg3 63969[,>. qtbobgcqrglpcgo ]6do59]u oScojSgqrqro 2017 Scqrob 31 <oj$co8trg6b. 8glto]$oli>qr, o6 qo6Bg5ocqr,> 8<oX5gb6o6gbqr>g. rqb$o35o3o,r, 6<o8 ll.> jo6ca3gcqxob lt3<'r6b6o6Xgoco bob,>8o6orc9otr $cpo3 6o6gqr3o5.> 3cn5b6o53go36o b6Bgqqro, 6<o0gc93og So.rlt6Bgcqgglo ocabcogg6 8o0o34c.ro6 3o6b,>boqrggqr 8g8ob3g3otso bo3oo$o bjgtxotr6qo 3og3o6ob Sjco6g 8s8o3,>gob bobbqroh> q,o Ootro 30.,83<o5g56gtrob qr<o6co6o.rlob 6oSooq8qrg6 B3g59}ry 6o6bSqg6ob bo3oa,bob 8<o869b6o6gbgcqro 5<o68ob doqlrq'r3o6gpqtqr g5<obob'. lroj*6oggqmb bo3co6lgogXgoo blro8o6oqr<olr 2017 Sqro! 16 6<og8lt6ob l:Iey15/1214 g166o69lo boj8gEg,,ouol 8<'rjoaqtjgcar 3<eq)o6o3!6o gog6oroo6glo,66om$o SogocoSoqp6o 8od6oeio" lrojo6<a39cqrob lo6cpo0g56ob 6o5$q8q,gA' br3o6U6o53go<', b,>b,>0,>6oqto0 2017 Ecqrob 16 5<'rg0tr96U tr>j8989 ,,oooJ 0<ojocgojgor,> Joqogo3X6o gogr6orooSglo ,,96<noo5o 51oco5,>qrX6o 8<aJ6*'rlo" Uojo6or3gqcolt 3o6q$966oU 6o5o,>q0qg6" Sooqr.r gr6Bo69b,> go 6obo6o369}Xcqro 5<o680 2016 6cqroU 29 g6g8b96oU N.2/6/623 6oq,o6gggoqgboL qtSdqrg3 5<o60oqr 0ooB5oo. lgltloSob,>q, b,>qtgc'r 5co63o drql>qr>3o66Xqtq, oj6r g6cnboqr bojSoU o6Uglooo go6boqgr3ob 616939. tloqtgco 6<o68ob 8obgq3oo, bo6Bgcq:oU p86X539qrgcogob Sgtrobgb 3o6gbog9}o89, o6t4go3g boBo3,>689, lto6lo$6,>gco 5o60<'rgloUcns6 g,>3o3Eo6glXcqro tr,r6BgqroU $ g6cobobo go oqrlrt6Xcggbob X86X6g9qrgo.rgob qr<o6otrdogbgboU g,>8<'rgg59boU 6o68<ogtrob a)Enbai,Clob 3o6gb,rgglo89, $citq, oq8<oBgSoqr 3r6g8cnglocno 6,>8<'r brj0otr tsgbobg} ?gtr$gb g,>Sgboq,glob q,o bojo6or3gcqrob tro3<o6U6o5Xgoco boUo8o6orc9o3o 6,>SltSocqr3gcqr boj8ggb8g U,>bgcqrSSoqco hqo oX6oqoXcqn 3o6gtroLur3ob 6,>6h>Eg3t6pcqro ogo pg6<o 89go <oqg6<oloor, goq69 3oEo316o 3o6gboU 898or$g3olo. lt3<o6U6o6Xgoco bobo0o6c.rqxoS SoSorooro, 6co8, Uo8<ojoqtjco q,o ' ob. N13a3 ,3o6b6o6X0ot6o b.'6Bgq,o lt3<'r5tr6o6Xgoco b3,>6or,>q$o68<ogbglU ts<o6oU l6Ugbobb 05o€g59q<',3,>5o 6o6bb319!g!o, ca3Ogo 3<oB93Xq, 398d,hg3rEo oq,g55p6oo ttbgql8Boqca logob qr$gUgbob 3o85glo qt q,r5o3fueg,Cln. Bgttb,>8oUog, o6 Ar8t'l33Ccloq)o 6oo39 qr,>3,>$gloom, 2016 6qoU 29 ggg0lg6otr ll'2/6/623 arq,Dgg3C6oq)CblBo an6bol9lcPo Bg8cofu93obu6o6 6o6l-tb34gbXcqro o5OC6Cbo, 6co89q,ng 3gU,>dcqro,>, 3$,>Jo6<olgbqgb $ It3.>6otcqrX6c,og6oxo|,>Bo go8o3X6o gr oX6oqopqro 3o69lob qoqg6g6go6g\>b. 39trotr,>8oUoq', ltq,l3<o 6ggXqro6gN 3oB69pqro oj6r ,>6o3<o6t4o6Xgo36oq, g6colocqro 5o689}ob ogg6gp6o 3o5,>o6bob Sjco6gq. oqr5oEfucqro 6<o689bob docqr:grpr63pqr>qr tro3oobob 8<oXSgL6oSglqtqr 3o8<ogboqglo Aiq,ogrq,qo 2018 6q:oU 31 8o66,>8q9, 6raro qr6<og9loor, 8o,>5o,>6 8obq,g<o3<og,> 36o8g59qxogr6 ltSr6cn oSOC6CbClt'. 8oXbgqo3,>qr o8oUo, 6<o0 lttlo3,>6oq><nU 8o96 898o,>q:5oB51cqro 6$Bo6gbob Ooq,gtrogo6 96o 59c9E9 SSOo A,)Boq,n, ltjor6c.r3gcqrcnb 3,>6cqt3956tr ,>6 SoXqoo BgltbSoUo bo3,>5o50q,gbqxo 6qroqgbgbo, 6ob bo3Xd39q89g goSoboEq36glogo trobgqfBogcn Iogob <oqg5<'rb98o, 6<o8gc9og oo6$9ql613o 8<o3ogcaqt U,>3<o6U6o63goco Uob:Sr6orqxotr o66X8g56rgooLrcoo6 qr>, o8rUo,o549, X86X6ggqg<ogqrr trobgcgS6oqco logob qroSgbglob qg6o6o3pt6o 8o85gbob 8oq,EgJr. lDj$raggcqrob bo3<o5l6o6pgo<'r boboSo6coqpcob 2018 6cqrob 3 o3jgobob N012671 goq'rBgggocgglo bojSgEg "ltllol "Uojo6o3gcqr<ob c8$accqt6-bol0olt0r6o gqtgboo", jo6orggqr<ob bogogbtq,ob lxr66ob gsggboJ', lirol gqglmo", b{ml oooJ "d6ot 00t, "tro qrqrob jt6ob$o$bob#glob 658g6ob gqgboo", olo3 "bojo{6caggc9<nb "ACAOoqp oqrggS6ol6ol gqgboob 66,>&3g3obcrX6o r55oo5o", bUoS "cqrodroS iDclarcqtoJgdro J{Joboob lr$ogodlqo oq8o5ol66ogoo", oml ,jo6oggqr 0gbqroSoo 340o6o", ,,58o5qo lrD8Clol, gcggboo" ltjot6caggqob 3r6qro8g56ob Eo5ooqr8qgg" qro bUol b{o6orggcgcab tt3<o66o6Xg<xo boboSo6<acqrob 2018 Scqrob 3 ogcgolmb N01/1/811 goqro6gggocgglo $89Eg "btrol "bo jo6<nggqr<'rb CSoSACcq'$6-lol0olt0!6o 6cq4ltJ" t bol ,,bjo6oggqrob go5g9q16-cqryo96Xqo gqgboo', trbol ,,b6Xcgorqr boj 6cnggcqr<ob }gbcpo8-o X\c{'gt o bobXqogt6<o b08o6o3gc9ca", btlo3 "q$b5oqr jo6og9c9<ob bobo6gbob C6ob6oo5.'r! boq,goo g3cqrgboo bojo6qgqmSo" go bbol ,,lro 658g5oL gcggUoo" bojo6c4gcqxob lo6qr,>8g55ob 5o5ooqr8qr6" 2018 6qrb 3 qcqrotlll tt3<o6b6o5Xgoco lttruSo6cocgca8 Sooqco Ssqro6gg$ocgrglo ltj8989 ,,liroJ ,,Uojot6orggcgcoL gg,r6ggcqrX6-tro36ott6J6o gcqrgbo", ooo3 ,,1-r,>j,>6orggcqrcoU bogogbcq,oU bo56ob gcq,gUo,>", l.tuo3,,d6ob69b 6qrgbo'>", btroJ ,,Uoj,>6a,3gcqrcotr bbo6gboU 66895ob gqrgtroo", oooJ,,Ogtsgoqg qqrolr j6ob5oo5-oq3g65ot6c,,> g3qrgllootr 10 g6r6b3ogohX6o oX6oc.r6o", LUo3,,qqrraro6 pc.xocqro3go,n Jog3oboob b,>Oogojpqrco ,>q3o5ol-66rgor", .>.>oJ "jrt6arggqr 0gtrqn8cr> 3193o6o", l.rllo3 ,,58o5q'.> ll.>8gboU 6qgboo" trj.r6or39qcob 3r6q,$C56ob 5o5.>oqr3qg6" q,o o6,>3<o6bgog1go1t6oqr 96<o bojo6cnggcqxnb lt6oqob$oq,o., 3<oq:gjbob 168-9 SXbqoL 89-2 6o6oqroL,,b" dBC3f6COol, llo5g3glob "ttjrt6o49qq,cob 63o66oo6j<'rU qro33goroo:" ob 6co63o5oXqn 3o5o,>6Uo, 6<o89cqrog Boogqrb XqcggboU 9,>6939 qg6-otr6o5 rorr3olrXgqrglqt Obcoqx'rqr Uojo6oggqxob bo3,>66oo6jcoU q,rdgCo,oo: ArgC!c{, Ord6Cbolro qr g3qrgbogbob SSgSglcqrcolob, 69t6.46ogoobo qt 8<obog3ob 8<o8U,>bX6glob. b,>b,>3,>6orqxoL Soomorgloor, 69qro6o36o go96oroo59d9bob X8o,>g6gUo 8o8o6o 8<o668X69ot Sbobp6glotngoU oXgoqrgbgqto 3o6<olglob tsgj85o go 6gq:o3oX6o boj0ouS<obob 3<oco6q,o5,:go,>0. oqSots5Xcqn o66g6gbo o,>5,>I6oq A0186rlr t6co6<o6g ttjl6or3gcp<'rLr lo3o66oo6 job, obCSC gggcpo Ubgo 6gqo6oX6 <n63o5o8ogoob. Uob,>0o6cacqxo8 396 qrooSobu qqgt6g6go6glotr 6o8s6orqrg[ob trooro6rqro o5596glm qr SoXcaooo, 6<o8 boqr3cn 66Xcqro6gB,> o6gtS[qt qrotr36oSoSogoXqT 8<'lJg6o]ob 6gqrogoX6o 5ots5oor. ojoqr>6 6o8co8go5r69, 6<o0 3o6<o6Sqrglqnb 8o96 cn,r6ob6cn6cob,> Sgtrodqxoo Sog6gpqr oj6gtr 6<ogc'r6g bogoqtb,rbog<o Sgqt3ocootr $Cq)o o6lrCloooq' or5ob6<'r6 Jo6Eg 6og6ggcqrgloar, obg3g Sobo b6Xqr>qr 6oXjSgloor, boboSr6orqx'r8 ltql>g<o 6g61qn69}ob d,>qtqt3o6gXqtqr ADOc',Bboq'Cb! ADq,Drgrq,o 2018 6qroU 31 qg90b6o8q,g, 6oaro 305<o58q9b9cq,b gob36oSoSogoob oqrSoh>gb36gqtqr ,>6UgbXq>o 6o8qg5o8g rqrgg66ogogoqoS o968oo 96o-96oo. 2018 6q>oU 3 o3qrollb U,>3<o6b6o61goca trolo8r6c.rcqrco8 utlgg Sooqro Aoq,oggACOoQq,Cl,) Itj0989 ,,Ubo3 ,,bjo6or3gqrcob g3o6g9qrX6-tro36otr6p6o g3qgtroo", trtroJ 'llojo6o39qrotr CaoGACCq,X6-q'!.rrC6Xc9o 6cqrgboo", tirS ,,b6Xqroog bojo6o3gqrc'rb 81bqn8co,> X8oqcggbo b,>bXqrog6co Uo88,>6org9qxo", trtroJ ,,qrbbSoqr j6otr6orSorr boqrgcn<o gcqrgboo l.rojo6oggcqxoSo" qlo blnJ 6bo69bob 66896ob ggqrgUoo" Uojo6cn3gcqxob "ttjo6orggqcaU 3o6qr8g56oU 5o6oog8qgg" qln D6oJo6b6oOl0ol6,>qr g5<o ,,U,>bgq$6qco j<o6glotr Bgltbgl" bojot6cn3gcqxob 3o5<o6ol.1 63 SXbqob Jo6ggcq,o Jp6j6ob bo669lotr ,,trojo6coggqgcob b$ogojXqo ogO<oJ9t,)q)16 3,>6orqf ,:qroqrg}9c9" ob 5<o68o6oXqn 3o6o,>6bo, 6o.rSgcqrog hbgcqrSSog<o jo5g}ob pb$gogqcoq' bo33or69do3o 3oqoggSob Sgbodqrglcg<od,>U oog,>cgoUSo6gbqo 3b<oqrog Uojo6orggcqrcoU b,>8<ogojgcqx'r ogg<'r3gqoqrX6o So6arql8 ,>goggbgcgo g3qrgtrooborgoU. lrotloSo6o4qxn8 oq'5oB5pqr 8g8ob3g3o8og 996 qooSobr ADStobgogCllcpo 8<o3g6<olob go8,>6orcqrglob boor,>5og<'r h4Xd3gcgro qo qt,>q6o5,> 6gcqrogoX6o 5o36ocn qrotr36o0o6qJoo. o8obc,.,o5, 8g8ocD 11 goSboqlcgo 6ogo6g96oc9gloU oq,g55X6o qrb,>Igcogtroo 6,)q,orgnq,o bogogo.r 5<n68oll docqroqro3,>63Xcq,oq 6o3<ogboqrgbo 2018 6qqnL 3l qgg8b6o8qrg. ,>gb,>5o35o3or, 6<n8 b3co6b6o5Xgoo boU,>So6orqrcoL 0o96 Uojo6or3gcgc,rU J,>6qr>8g56ob,>or3ob arSt oEq,B6lq)o gDq,r a{oq,o, 8,>66o8 bo3o5ro58qg}qxo 0.r66,>5rob .>6 gs6Xb<'r6gogqrgtroo SgtroboSoh g3qoqgglglo 305<'r58qglq><oboEo o69 g6cn 8g&noq6o35yqr b,r3oorboroS 3o8o6ogloar. strgor 3or6<'rb9l8o, UD3oSroSSqrglqq,o <',6g,)6r,l.t j8gqrglo tsgodcqrgbo oqjfuqo oj59b o8gg,>6oqr, t6cn8 8o6 o8 9go38g qrob36o8o5,>goob oq8<'rgb36o 0o8o5396o.r5ocgrqr 0ooBSoo b66gbqroL ggCcgo 6gqqrogop6o <o6305o8,>gooUoa,gob goXjSglob 38oar. bo3o6b6o66oca boU$,>6oqrob 8o96 g4ro3oqg\qo Anq'l6ggC6oagglClo, 6<oSgcqroo oqrb6XcqploU gqro o6 o8<o53{6pqro b,>3<o6Lr6o6Xgoco bob$o6coqqrcoS 2013 6Ccq,t, SoqrgbXcir 3oqr6 5 6,>go6ggg$oqrgl$o E)AcrogS6,r ,,brjo6o3gqxob bo3<o5b6o63gocn UotroSo6cnqx'rb 8gU,>bg!" lrj,>6<nggqxoU <o6go6pc9o 3o6c.rSotr 25-g OXbcgoL 89-3 Jp6j6ocn 8o6o$gbXqro XgcggB,>Scoboqrglo qro aoqll)Onq,r o6o3<'r5U6o6Xgo36o 6<o689loU doqrrqr3o63Xqrg goO<ngboqglo. oqrSolSXqro Aoq,og$g6oq,Cl9loar goar3,>qnlrSoSgbXcgo g,)q,n ,!8 q6<ooboor3oU 6,>UXqn o6 o6ob. gb g,>qr,>6gggoqrglgbo,>: . bldv6ogCcpoab tr>3<o6b6o6pgoo bdr.>8,>6oqrob 2018 6cq'ob 19 ofoo0b6ob lS2//79 gog,rS6ggoc{,C}o t odACEC "brjs6oggq,<'rl, Sc'ljrqrjg qrgoco SoqqroSoo brjo6%gqq,<el, 3o6qq'r8g56ot, 6o5,>o98qrg' - b,>q,>3cn 6c,r689|oU d4qrogo3o663qrqr g6c'rlo 6ogo3,>qqr,> 2019 6c9ob 31 8,>66,>8qrg; bojo6qgqrob bo3o5U6r53goer b,tu8o6oqotr 2018 6qrob 7 q,$g0!6o1, No2/8265 3r95gg6oqr9lo boj898g Sojocgojg qqoo do5g5od9 "Uojo6c4gqob lsjo6o4gqrcob 3,r6cqro8C56ol., So6uqrSqg" - Uoqr>gco 5<o689!ob d{p,)go3r6gXepoq g6co},> 6rqrogoqgo 2019 6qnb 30 oJ6oqrrSgg; 12 lojo6c4gcqxob lo3o&6o6qpco bobo0or6otqx,rb 2018 Sqnb 14 qggS&6ob lW1ln47 goqoSgggocgglo lDjAgEg ,,,JU, go6o66o bgjoX6ooro,, go ,,BJU gltg6ob<oghob 3<o83o5oo $o3<a5obo" lojo6c4gcgoL fo{6q,o0C6$oto q,o ttj.r6o49qrob 3o5o9o6 Uoj8goo 0o5oU66ob 5o6o4r\6" - b,>gog<,r 6cn68glotr docqr,>9,>3r66Xqqroqr g6co8r grqr,>3,>qrqr 2019 6q.ooU 30 qGoU,>Ogg; Itojo6o4gcqr<ob ls3<o5U6o6pgoco UoboSo6orqxob 2018 6qrob 14 qgggldob N0l/4/809 goqro6gg6pqqrglo $09Eg "bojodorggcqroU Acdoq,odC OoOoJ.D E<a66ocqno6o bojo{6rnggqx'rb lo6q$g66ob 5o5o\€q,$" - troqrq<o Eco68g}ob doqtgr3o6gXqqrg 96<olo g,>gogoqqt 2019 6qq,ol, 30 o36ot o8q,g; bujv6<nggc9<ob bo3<o6b$o$Xgoco botro8r6caqqxob 2018 EcgoU 14 qr6g8|6otr l$2/13/1234,1235 gogoSggC$qpglo 1,.rj0989 8<ojoqtjggbo - 6<oo6 "tsjo6orggapotr O.dCcp.dC qu 3oca63o \r63o6od9 bjor6o3gcg<ob Bo6qt8g66ob Eo6ooqr8qrg3', Itqogco 5cn689dob docqrgo3o66Xqtg g6cnbr 2019 6qrob 30 6oqogoqgo q6otll0gg. 85o8g5gqx1,>5o,>, 6co3 ,>6o3o5b5o6XgoX6,>qr gScoloqro )d6ob AoEq,CbAo <,169,>&o918,> g6<opql.>qr Sooqrco6 8gb,>loSobo 8<o8gtro q,,> 0{boSoqrX6o d,>qgoUb8g3r 6ob6oo6, 6oo.> bojr6orggqxnb U,>3<o6t4o6pgo<,r b,>Uo3o6<oqrc,rb 8o96 g,>Eb,>8qr36Xqqr gogo8o Eo6ggbob docqr,>q,>3o663qrqr 6o8<ogbrqglo8q,g SoqrgdXqr oj6gtr Bglrol,>BoUo br3o6cn68qglqxo ggcgoq,gdglo go argoqt6 oj6gtr ogocqpbXqro lr!$D6<'l o6OC6Ct,Cbob qo 8gb89 Jor6or,> Xgq,glglob qt8o,>59bo. brCr6oSCq'olJ lr53o6b0oog0os) A$JbJ.lobJbodC l,,5lJJ0J6crq'rt Aeqrbo 13