„საქართველოს სახალხო დამცველის შესახებ“ საქართველოს ორგანულ კანონში ცვლილების შეტანის თაობაზე“

საქართველოს ორგანული კანონის პროექტი მიღებულია
ინიცირების თარიღი
29.08.2013
ავტორი
საქართველოს პარლამენტის წევრი ვახტანგ ხმალაძე
ნომერი
#07-3/180/8
წყარო

📋 განხილვის ეტაპები

I მოსმენა
✓ 82 ✗ 0
საქართველოს პარლამენტის დადგენილება (1)
II მოსმენა
✓ 80 ✗ 0
საქართველოს პარლამენტის დადგენილება (2)
III მოსმენა
✓ 91 ✗ 1
საქართველოს პარლამენტის დადგენილება (3)
კანონი

🏛️ კომიტეტები

  • ადამიანის უფლებათა დაცვისა და სამოქალაქო ინტეგრაციის კომიტეტი წამყვანი კომიტეტი

📅 დამატებითი ინფორმაცია

ბიუროზე განხილვის თარიღი 2013-09-03
ბიუროს ნომერი 92

📜 ტექსტი

საქართველოს ორგანული კანონის პროექტი
J6a?ddo l$j.ltto6gq,t,tb rn66s6gqr 316<16o "l$js6o69q,r'rb b\,trn *56Ut *.1 0glrrbCb" ttjst6o6gq'<nU ofus6"gq, 3.)6oEAo 6q,oq,g0olr tsgg.rEob orsobstg eJbE- l.,,lsj.:t6orpq,rnb bsbrq,b<n er0ogCq,ob E3bsbgb,, l6j.:6or3gqxn[ ot66sbgqr 3l6rn60o (Jr6q,rAC6Oob 9g936.:6o, N13, 7.06.96, 6. 12) ts3g$oqr ojfutr 0CdcpC6" g3q,oq:gbs: l. 09-6 Og\nb 0g-2 Jg6j6o B.>6og,>q,obqrgb ts90qr35o r6gqrrj6ooor: ,,2. lsj.:6orgq,rntr lr,rbrqbo qrsOg3gq,b 5 $qmb 3rqnor o6893lr bsjs6o6gqx,rb J,rt6qrs0g66o br6gq,o Eg046g6qxnbob MCAob g06s3ggberboo. Jr6(ner$U6ob $s64.o616ob UBqrCbr.:jgor brJ.:r6q,r0g6go g6rj6ostr, Js6q,$g6golr $936orr bgq,6o6": 3jgtr3s6os6 16ggb, 6o0q,9bo3 16 tsCq)or6 166 gr6or gr6rjgortso.,.. 2. 2I-g Ogbqob,,or" *gfuEjgo B.:0ergrqn@gb tsg0qpg6o 6gqrj6ooor: ,,cn) $g6ogerboor 0o0s6oxnb brj.><6oggq,cll., J6gtoqrg6glr, J6g0og6_0o6ob66b, org 0cn86ggb, t6o0 brbrq,bo !Qc0g3gqr6[ 3s63rr66gqgbs0o s6bg6gqro 6g.r6o63bob ItEgsq:g0g0o r6,rbs30s6olnr;". agUC- Z. gb 316o6o rOoj0gqqrgb 2013 $q,ob bJ6gtoq.og66er sr6Bg3636olr ACCgCara .>t6B311qo J<69boqgg6goU 0qr6 go6ob qrspg0olr 0o036goqrr5. bsjst6cr6gq,o[ Jfu$oqp6go Oobgoqr bsr3r0goq,o
განმარტებითი ბარათი
0rEAr6OC0oor, 6sr6son bsdrtrro6Cqx'rb <qfur6gq,o 3rb<'r6ob J6r'rfil6q5g "tlrjr6o6gq,rnb lrrbrq,b'o qu06gqolr tsglsfub" t$jrfto6gqxnl, r'r<66sbgqr 3r&.r6Eo 63q,rq,gAob tsCos$o[ oxnbssg r) lb<'l6rAo o6got60s6o.: 3s6<n6.yrx'!Cd$c,b tsgbsbgb r.r) 3.r&'r5&trngl0r,t &,{?Cbob AotC$o 3s6rn6J6ogjgob Ooqgbob Oobgbtr $.:60cnq696b 2013 gq,oL blJr6gboqg66er s6B669bob tsCqgCbre ,:r6Bggq,o Jr6g9roq.og66otr 0o96 go6ob qrsqggbob 0o0g6goqr.r6 .:b,:0oj03pgb3qo brjs6or3Sqx'rb 3rn6bgogggoob 73-g 0gbq,ob 03-5 Jg6j6o, 6o0goti or6rbArer0, bsjr6or3gq,c'rb J6gboqrg660s 0berqxnq.o bsj.:r6or3gqob 3oEbgogggooor ggggbs6rnt-roq1brbo g6qr 6r6sbr.rr66o3qxnb. 6s6bsbq36gq,o s.b) 3s6o6J6x'rglgoU 0obr6o 3s6rn6J6ogjgob 0obs6o 0q6r'r0s6grnbL o8r0o, 6r.10 ,,lrsjs6or3gq,rnb brbsqrbrn qr,:063gq,ob tsglsbgb" trsjs6cr6gqxnlr o66s6gqo 3s6<n6ob 09-6 Ogbq.,olr Ag-2 Jp6j6o, ,rtr6X 21-3 0gbq,otr --" CACJU6COo, ts3bsbs0olrrn6r8o 6rn3oqrgb brj,r<6cnggq,rnU 3rn6b$o$ggoob 73-g agbq,ob 09-5 Jgbj6ors6, 6odgq,o6 2013 gq,ob bsJ69toqg66er .l6B669bob SCspCbre s6B3gqo J6gboqrg66ob 0o96 gogob qgsqrgbob 0er0966oqrs6 gbqr.r r6rnj0gqrqrglr. r.6) 3.:6o6ltftnglgob dodnorqn s{6ln U.>j,:6or33q,ob 3r'rbb6ogggoob q.oqgbqgqgr.rboor 0ojOgqgo 73-9 0gbqob 09_6 Jgbj$olt olsbrbArcp, ttjs6o6gq,ob J6gboqgX6go ggq,3bs0r'rboq,os s6.: flbrnq4qr 3o6b6o6ggooor, ,:6.>0gqr Jr6r'r6ool 6rbb9cq36gqro ggqpbsOolroqrgbrbog 6r6sbo6gogqxnl-r. 2013 $q,oU bsJtfuboq,g6go s6Bgg$gbob ECcSC6re r6B3gq,o J63tcopg6gob 0o96 go6ob qgrqrgbolr 0o0g6goqg,)E sq6ots6gq, 3rn6b6o6g6og<+r 6rnt60sl-t Bss6,4gqrgbU 73-g 0gbqolr 69-5 Jg6jgo, 6o0q,ob Oobgqg3oorsg, bsjr6or3gqrrnb Jt6gboqrg6gb Oboq,rnqp 3o6lrgog96oo0 6r6tJrbe36uq,o UggCbs0oUoq3bgbob 6r6ber66ogq,gbolr tsgUsdqlbqoAs 3jfubs. bsjr6or3gqrob 3er6tr6o6g6oob sr66 qgqXbqrqg<nbocn 0oj0gqn qrr u66 2013 $qrob b,:J6gboqg66o r6Bgg63bob tsg0q6cn6 ,:lts0oj0Xqpfuq,lo 0gbqrgbo ,16 tsgo6s3b Bsbr$3<6b, 6c'r0q,ob cnsbrb0sqgr6, J6gboqr36go bsbrq,brn er03gCq,,ob 3rbqnq.osgg6ob $s6qg6g6ob ggqSboor lrt663bq,rnblr. rybotsEggoqrrb 6s0er0qn6r6g, o0olr 6sor3rq,otr$o6gboor, 6rn0 2013 $q,"tr tr$6g9roqrg6go ,xcrB6fubob tsCASpCa, J6glcoqg6go Obrnq,rnqr 3rn6trgogggooor 2 6sblrsq36gq, ggq,3br0<nlnq,Sbrb sbrn6go3q,Xblr, s0rborr6sg, gicA6r3bo 316o6o 16 oor3lq,olt$o6g0b 0olt 0o96 ltb,:gbrn qgrA0BCE ob 3.:6qgoqrrggr6ob $rr+rq.obC6otr EXtsdq,gbgerbrb, Obreor, t6rn0 2013 Sqob bsJ6gicoeC66o s6Bg36g0tso s6Bgggo J6g95oq.og6gob 0o36 go6olr qgrqrgbob 0r'r6g66oq.or6 0rlr lrsbsqrbrn qrs6ggXqotr 3sbqr4grgg6ol-t $st6q,bC6otJ ggqpbs s<6 gj6gb.:. bg0osq6o66gEoqgr6 br0oAs.oo6r6C, sggoqrgbgqor 63goqgbr Emoqggb ,,bsjrt6o6gq,rnb tr.>bsq,k'r q9r06gCq'ob tsgltsbgb" rnt66r6gqro 3r6o6ob 09-6 flgbq,ol1 0X-2 fuEjgAo er r0oeCbuq, oj6Jr Bs6s$96o, 6rn0qrolr 0obgq.o3oor,:9, brjr6orggotr J6gtoq66go b.>brq,trn SgrA(BCq,ob Jrbeoer$U6otr $.:6q96g6ob Sgqrgboor tts66gbq,oblt. qpqgbqpqgoboor 0oj0gq9o,,brjs6o6gq,rnb bsbsgbo qgrAogCq,,ob tsgbsbgb" o66rbgq,o 3s6rn6oU 21-g 0gbqnb ,,or" $gJg6jgolr or,rbsb6sqr, bsbrq,bo q.o,)06mq,1, Ugq,Cbr rfib $36oq,r'rboor 0o0r6cnolr brjr6o4gq,rnlr Jtfu9ropg66b, org 0ooB6g3b, 6o0 Oob 6.:63,r65pqgbstso,rdrbgbgq,o 6gr6o6gbolr ls0gsq,gbgbo r6sbr36r6olro.:. 2013 $qob brJ6gboq66grn r{68g36gbob tsg0q6rn0, 0.>6orsq,or, J6g9ooq66gob 3<n6Jgg36gorb 0o3go66g0gq, lrs3oorborr $69 06ots3fuqro36sqg 06o6qgbs, 0r66s0 Oslr Osobg 6Bgb,: br6JgCgq'lo ggq,gbr0oboq,gb.:6o, <6<n0gq,orr 0r6bo66oCq,3b,r6 sqrs0or6ob ggqpb36lr,r q.or cnr3obggq,gbgblrg sbqpbb bg6r3q,96rb. 0r6sq,ocnrqr, J6g$oqgg6gb 6fubr ggqgbs Oojrq,rigobobr qrs cnr36gbsg6ob 0o6g0ob br3oorbgbo arer$U3oomb; lrso6s6o sE br6s66gbo 0qr6cr0s6ger0ob qg6rnb 0ooqolr 6rqrs$6ggoq,3bs Je)r0or6otrcDgob 3er6bgog3goob 03-18, Eg-20, 21-9, 22-X,24-X,25-9, 30-3, 33-3 pr 41-9 0gbq,gboor 0o6olgbgq,o ggq,gbgbols q_o,> orr3obggq,gbgbob tsg9rqgqg3ott 0gbrfub, rbg3g 6s0ob6gb Jr6tn6ot dsq,ob 0jofu q.og6gg3bo, 6o03qro6 ts3ltdq,err sqrs0o.:6olr ggggbgblt,: q-os orr3obggq,gbgborrb ogotr qrr3r30o6gbgqro. 3o6roqrs6 2013 $q,ob b,:J6gboqpg6go .:6fu36gbob tsg0q6r'r0, J6gboqrg66U 33q,s3 6Bg0s W)rAorEcDr ggqgbgbls pr orr3obggq,gbgborr6 q.or3s30o6gbgqo 6,rqt$6ggoq:gbob 0oqgbolr 0gbrdq,3bq,rnbr, 6sor q.os63sic9 bgAsdbge3Cq,rnb.:lr 3o lrsbrq,bo erAogCq,lo sbar6goSq,gbb, 63.:6o6gbob lr,:tsgsq,gbsorr r6rbr30r6otrerbob ts30orbg33stso, rggoq,Xbgq,o,r rA g3sbsb36gq,tr J6gboq666obo6ob $g6oq,<nboor 0o0s6or3ob ggqpbs ts996.:6Bg6q9glt. 2013 $g"b b:J6gboq666o r6B669bob tsg0qr6o0, J6gboqrg6gotr UtsE Cbr0oboq,Sbsors tsgirqgqr3s J6g0ogi6-0o6ob$6ob ggq,gbgbob brt6q.oob b.:6aSg bo6gogq,qrgbr. 6s<6qrr oOobr, t6rn0 lljr6orggq,ob 3o6lr6o6p6oob 79-3 Ogbq,ob, 6rn6ot66 qgqg\rqgobocn 0<njOgqn, oltg 2013 $q,ob bsJ6g9coqrg66rn s6Bm6gbob tsg0q.og6 rtr:0oj0gq6bgq,o 6gqgsi6oolr orr6rb0sqg, J<6x0o3<5-0o6obo6ob 3efJgg36gorb sqArb6a3q,Cbgq,o b3q,obggq,gbob ltsj0o,:6rnbolr 0o0s6ogq3bgboU br6b;9bq36r, rn63s6obg0s, 3oo6qro6s6or Cgs 3rn666oq,o Sr60etqr6g6b, ob rb6g 0orr36erbob 0gcnrg6o bpgbr. OoU 0o96 6rbb.:kn60oCqCbCg ggq,gbs0rnboq,gbrors 636gq,o6gbob bggt6rn0o sqr6os6ors UEq,CbCboO gj6gs. tsgb$r0obsp, o0 ts30orb3g3stso, org bsbsqbrn er0ogCq,otJ 6s63r66gq,gbr0o s6bgbgq,o t6gs6o6gbob br6grq,Sbgbo r6sbr30r6obo rea.',Ebecbr, brbsgbn, qM6gqb J6g0og6-0o6ob66robor3ob $g6oqxnboor 0o0s6or3olr Utsq,Cbr3 p6qgr OoCOCb. 6r6lrsboqSSq,sqr $,r60oq,AC6oqro b.rjr6or3gqob or6p6ggo 3,:6o6olr J6rngjgo l$o6rgqr rq6o86gq,o ggq,oggboL 6s6ber6gogqgbsb oor3sgob$o6gblr. b) 3s6o6Jfxrglgob go6s6bg6o qprbrq3oCbr b..l) 3s6<n6Jrtrng{l$ob Aoq,C0rbor5 qr3.:38o69&3qo sg6oqgbgqo b.>e60ob qrgo6r6bgbob $gsd)t'r 3s6rn6J6rngjgob Oqgbr s6 5s0<no$3g3b bsbgqrO$ogrn 0ogaggoqgr6 qrr0,:63booro bsbb<63bob 6,r0ogrng,:tr. b.b) 3.:6o6lt6rnCC$ob argqg6s Aca3166olr llrtsg0r'rll.:gq,o 6r$"cftC 3;6rn6J6r'rgj6oU Oopgbr ,:16 0osbpg6b 6r3q,g6,:b bogajgol_r trrtsC0<qtJs3q,rn 6r$ogbg. 6.$ 3sEoEJdrnCCOob araqC6s bcagaS$rlr b.l6r;g.lo, 6sgoqtg; 3s6<n6Jt6rngjgolr Ooqgbs 16 6r0oo$333b brbgq,0$ogrn bogalgolr b,:6x3ooro 6r$oq,o! 6goq,gbslr. b.q-o) bsb3q,a$ogolr rbrq,c, go6r6bgdn 3.>q,q)CqJq,CbCOo: JrEt'rbJ6<nCCOob 0oqgbr s6 oor3sq,otro$ofubb brbgqO$ogrnli 0o96 rbsq,o go6s6bg6o grq,qrgbgq,gbgbotr sqgbrtr. b.g) 3.15<'rE)t6<nCCOob Aebrq,o(6gq,o 9o6.>6lrg6o AgAC6Cbo o0 Jo6orro6ob, 6cn0gq,or.: 0o016or gr6ggqq6br JrFx$Jd,oCdOob A<nj0geC6s ,:6 rdrbSbobb. b.$ 3s6o6&6rngl6oor q,rq6C5oq,c, 6sqrslrsb.>qnb, Aous3r6gbq,otJ 16 bbgs lrsbolr &ArbbcSCqol, oq66o0s qu oq.oC6obob 6r6trs\g6ob J6o6goJo 3.>6o6Jt6ogjgo s6 oor3.rq,ob$o63bl.r 6rq.osttb,:qoU, 0olr,r36gbqrob 16 llbgs lr,:bob 6sqgrbbqggq'ob rnqrgbrnbotr 5r6lr,:9cq36sb qr.r tsgbsbsOotrsqr ,:16 sq6g6lr Eobo 6s6trsbqg6ob S3ttb. b) 3.16o6)Oog36ril Ao0.:r6orgbs lsgr6or$o6olro br0.:r6oqpb6og k>6(,r6OCOo,r6 6.r) 3sfu5J6rngl6ob ffi ur,crrCbs 9916<,13130o16olr qn6glgqgbor6: 3r6o6Jt6rn3jgob 0oq3b,: s6 9$o6r,rp0qrg6bg,r 6r6rn3r3tso6ob qn6gjgqgbtr. 4 b.b) Jren6Jdxnd$ob Ao0ytorCAr brgr6olstsor5olm orrr5r6ots6ogb0o l$js6to6gqxnl, $$6c,b.ilorr5 AD3.)30cx6CbsJq, grq\gC6"Jq,CbC0os6: 3r6er6Jt6oXj$o 16 3$o6srt60qQgbCbs brg6orrlrrn6olrar rn66r6obrgogb0o bsjst6cr6gq,r'r5 $66obsllolsb qt3s3botfu6gq, 3rq,qggbgE ghbb. 6.$ 3s6o6&6oCC0dr AoArd,crrgbr llrjrtt$gq,r',b ot60bdrq qgr 0r6sgrq0b6og bXq,Eel6,!,Jq,C0Cbors6 : 3s6rn6J6ergjgo 16 g$o6.:sq0pg6gbs brj,>6o5gq,arlr o60b6o3 qr,r 06,:g.:qb06o3 b9q,tsc.t6{cE,cbcbb. qg) 3s6er6l6etgl6ob Ao0trqgbob Jdx'rOCbAo fuqC&Jq,c, 3o6lryq,gs6ogbo. qg.s) b.:bgqO$ogo, ilA*rbgq,A$cl3r'r r6/q.or ls1r6cnsEo6olx'r o66r5ot4or/ Cgr$ClrCb"JqCe,s, CCbJC6,OCb", f-AqlCMsO Oobsftq,gobs 0ooqglr 3s6o6J6<ngl6crlr tsg&J8sgC0sBo, rbgonb st6bg3xnbob tsg0oD3gstso: ,:6 ,>6olr. A.b) 3r6o6&ftrfikjob tsg&JtssgC0s8o &.rbr$cry,3 o66.r6ots6oob (sps$ClrC03qlCboU) r6/qu dbJC6,O"b Aggsl4bs 3s6o6JtftDgd$ob 0o0116or, sbgorrb rd,bC&ebob AC0o$3gstso: s6 16olr. C) Jr6er6JdxDg6l6ob rg0el6cl: ttjst6oSgq,r'rb Js6q,s036gob $6t6o 3,:bg.:66 b@sq,sdg. 3) 3s6o6Jt5rnglgob o6ogoq)<'rt6o: Itjl6o6gq,ob J,:t6q,s0966"5 9O6o 3$gs66 bfl.>q,sdg.
იმ მუხლების მოქმედი რედაქცია, რომლებშიც წარმოდგენილი კანონპროექტით შედის ცვლილება
oa ag\tbob A<nj0gqn 6Cqorj6o.:, 6rn0qgbtso6 gs<60oq6g6ogo 3s5o6Jr6<'r$6oor Agqrlb63qrryCbr 0gbqn 6. 1. bsjr6or3ggotr bsbsq,b<n qgs03gCqrqg so6Bggr tr.:jr6or33golr flojsq,rjg. 2. bsjs6or3ggob bsbsq,bo qrs0ogCq,b 5 $qrob 3sqoor o6Bg3b brj,:6or3gq,rntl Jr6q,,:0g6go b6gq:o Eg0rq6gbq,r.rbotr bOgbob g0t6s3qrglrnbocD. JrEqQoerOU6ob $s6qr6g6ob UtsqlCbr sj3or bjrt6cn3ggob J63boqp96gb, bsJ.>r6qrAC66o g6sjgosb, Jr6qrr0g6gob $66cns b5q, OrOr gjgtr3s6os6 XAUAb, 6rn0q,gbog sr6 Bgqos6 169 96or gtqsjgorao. (16.07.20@ N l,160) 3. g6$oUg6ob $oE bsjst6cn3gqob Jr6q,,r0X6gol-r orr36aqxn0r63 brjrt6or3gg<ntr Jrt6qrs0g6$b r66obgbb 3sbqnqrrgorr lro.>lr er Osor $3t6oqroboor ors6b0o0rb ttrjr6or3gq,tnb bsbsq,btn eJA(BCq,ob orsbs0q.ogbobstC J6BCaob Eglrsbg6.g<npq, rbst6Bg3 3s6qgoqr.:gb p6$o gg63br 3rq-OrgJC. 66$obgt6.: B,)6uq,lor. 4. g6]obg<6ob 03qg6rqr r6Bggq,rq.o B,roor3q,gbs 3r6qgoqrsgo, 6rn0gqro6 0gg bArb Oooq3btt, 0166,:0 r6,:6r3q,gb bsjr6o6ggrnb Js<6q,s0366otr tr63qlo tsg0rqr5g6q,rnbotr g0t6rgq,gbobob b0gbobs. oru ,:6B33obrorgotr trs36s6olro b03bo g6orbg 0gg0,: 3,:6qoqrr$0s Oooqrn, 0s6<6s0 Ooqg0gq, bOrors 6,rrnqrg6<nbob $oqxnbolr 6$rn.:6Bggq,o 3gt6 6s0o3q,obqrs, r0 3sbq.ooqtgg6gbb g<6orsqg gg6gb,ror $6$o qgr r6Bggq,.:p Broor3q:gbr ob,3o6g 0gg b0rtr 0ooqgOb, 6l6t6r0 st6s6s3g3b brj,r6o6gq,ob Jr6qr,:0g66ob bt(ryq. 6g0sqr6g6q,rnbob g06s3q,glterbob b6gbots. 0oq3bgq, b8sor,: gerqobob 0g0orbgCAstso 396$ob96ott &+r6gqq36s 3<6dgq,q9gbr bsbsq,b<n qr,r0ggq,ob 6r0o3qg6s0qgg. 5. org r6B33olso6ob br30r6obo bAg0o 3C66 36ot0l 3r6q.ooqgr66r gC6 Oooqrn, 396$otrg6oqrs6 rt6r grqr6gb 7 qrr s6r U03or6Cl, 14 qqobs, gr6q6br b1q,,>b,>q,o s6Bg36gbo. bgq,rbrq,o r6Bg3636obrlr 3r6qropsg3bob $r6q.o6gbr qrs rdrBggqrolr brAetgq'lC6r begb,: r0 Ogbq,ob 0g-2,0g-3 pr 0g-4 Jg6j63boor q.osqr6g6oq,o ggboor. 6. s6B66gbob gt6or 6o3q,0o g6cno qs o0s3g 3s6qnqrr$U6ob $r6q6g6r tsgodq,3b,: <n6p6. 03bq,o 21 (21.07.2010. N3565) brjr6o6gq,rnb ltbrq,brn qpr03gCEo ggqgbrOrnboqor tsgErn$Ogbob tsgq6pbotr 0obgqrgocn: r) sqrs0os6olr ggq,Xbsor,r qgs ors3obggq,gbrors qprg3ob gb6g6gq,gogob, qrr3s3gbggors, Jr$o66obrtso 0gog rE lrb3s63s6rqg cnsgolrggq,Xbrtsgbqgqrgqr Jo{6orr q.or Ebp36pgbgqurr Jo6rn0gbolt qrr 0ror 6o0s6cn OoJgrftnbolr 5rg0ae0gbgboU, s6t6gcr6g $,r0gOolrs qgs bb3r brb6o3o, s6uqrs0orbg6o,:6 qgr0r06o6gbgqo 6oJg6o6ob sb bsb13q,ob ors3oqrr6 .4oq:gboU 0ob6oor trsjst6or3gq,ob 3s6<n60q6bqxn0rl_rcnrb q.o,> 3s6efiJ6rngjggbors6 qr,r3r3Eot5gboor $o6rqr,:q6bgbo, tsg6oE369bo qrr 6X3ar0g6qrgogbo $.>6a3qg6o6erb lsjs6cngqxnb J,>6qrs036gb rE lrb3.r 0gltbrEolr rn66r6rnb; (9.03.2010 N 2711 r0oj63q9q99tr 2010 $q,ob I oCOoa66oArE) b) rqrs6os6ob Sgr6egC3q, gggg0sors qrs orr3obggq,gbsors,rpblqr516rqr $o6,:q.osqrSbgbo qrr t6g<n0g6qgrgogbo 6sg6ts36rnb o0 lr$3q,0$ogrn bgq,oliggq,gbobr e) reboq,lr'rb6o3o cD3oolA0r6ogCq,clbob o66s$rngbtl, l5a,:r6r'r qr:$gUgbgqpbXblrs qrr or.>6s0qr3bobob Jo6gbb, rft'r03q,ors 0rnj63q6bs0s6 brA11osgor tr.rbgqfl$ogerb 0o36 AJ6r6Oo6CbUq, rerAorbotr Utsq,Cbsor qrs orrgobggggbror.: qrsr6q3g3u $ $obsqrsqgboor 0o0s6ox'rlr tsglrsbsOob br6s&ndog6o o66.:6<ngbb brAodoCbob $/qgs bolrbq,oblrs0s6rorq,Sb6o3o aCAEob er$gCbob 0rnorb<n36oor, oru l_rrjOol_r 5,:6boq3ob E3q.o36sqr 0o3s qrrl-r336r0qr9, r6rn0 sr6t_rCbrnblr qrs6s0rgq,ob 6ots6gbo; (24.09.2010 N 3621) qr) tsgli>b,:Oob o63r6ogbtso Egogs6ob $obsqrqr3bgbo o6 Jo6orr qgolr6oJq:o6g6o J6 rqr0o6otr66,>gogqo Jsbgbob66gbqobob tsgbrb3b, 6rn0gq,or.> 0erj0gq6bs0rg 5rdrnoS3os sqt0or6olr ggq,gbsorr qg,: orr3obggq,gbsors qgr6qggg,r; GrqlJCUq, 0g6cr,b3Cg300o tsgsb6gqxnb bstrs0s6cnq,rnb 0g6rnbr6ob (Amicus d Curiae) gg6j6or [rt36om [rrbs0r6orq,<ng0t-rr q.o.> b,:js6orggq,rnb b,r3er6lr6o6ggorn b.:lr$r6orqm0o; (1 1.1 1.201 I N 5264) 3) 0sbob6o3o o6gor60s6oolr brtsgsqpbgbb s66arbrnlr rer6os6ob ggqr3brort qgs otr3obggq,gb.>cns qrs6q3g3rl-rorrb q.os3r3tso6gboor 8,r6,:6gbgq,o 030o$0gbob tsgqrg6g0o; b) 0oqgbgqo 6rqr:$6ggoqgbCbo tsCo$r6rnb grngq,$q,og6 qgs bJ3gorq,,C6 r66r6o6gbtso; or) $g<6oqrnboor 0o0r6oxnlr lr{r6o6gq,ob Jt6gboq9366b, ory flooB$g3b, 6r.10 flob 6r63s63gqgbstso st6trgbggo 6gs6ot636ob br0grqgfubo r6sln30rr6olros; o) bs3rn6tr$o$g6orn bsl-rr0r6orq,ob 0o6r6cnob 3rn6bgogg6og6o lrs6BXq,oor 63gg6g6q60olts qr,: s6893fubob 0o0$gbt6o6gbgq,o 6or60gbob qr r0 6rn66gbolr trggd33q,94 Bs6s6gbgq,o rE BsbrgsSgbggo sr6fu3fubotr (6gg9636qry0ob) 3o6L6o6ggog6rrbrtrcD$ qrs3r3tso6gboor, s6 org 6o6ArOoUE o sjgoor s6 Oobo 3rqtJg3qlo 6o60gboo qrs6g33gqror bsjr6cn3gqob 3rabbgogggoob 09o69 cn,r38o lqortSgbgqo Jer0orbob Ugq,gbs6o qrl ort3obggggbrbo; 3) 5r6ls3go6gbgq, 6C0orbgCa,:0o 0o0s6oxnli brjr6or3gqrmb Js6gr6g6gtr sqrr0or6olr ggq,gb.>cnr qrr or.>3obggq,gbsorr qrr6q36oU grj6ors6 qgr3r3tso6gboor b,:jr6o6gq,r'rt1 J,:6q,s0g6golr q6ogboom br6r6rndogbo 3rn0olroolr fuj06olr q9.> J,l{6qrrfu$665 6o96 lrs3oorbob 6sbbog3ob 0oorbrn36oco. 7