საქართველოს პარლამენტის განათლების, მეცნიერებისა და კულტურის კომიტეტის მიერ 2012 წლის 22 ოქტომბრიდან 2013 წლის 3 სექტემბრამდე გაწეული მუშაობის ანგარიში.
📋 განხილვის ეტაპები
სხდომაზე განსახილველი პროექტი
📅 დამატებითი ინფორმაცია
მიღების თარიღი 2013-09-05
შენიშვნები ამონაწერი საქართველოს პარლამენტის პლენარული სხდომის ოქმიდან N56-Iს-ის თანახმად ცნობად იქნა მიღებული საქართველოს პარლამენტის განათლების, მეცნიერებისა და კულტურის კომიტეტის მიერ წარმოდგენილი ანგარიში გაწეული საქმიანობის შესახებ.
📜 ტექსტი
წერილი
,/f
tt\
-\
b)6J0)li,itb0L. iJi)o6t)irri,lrlt)lr) RJ
Jt E) tS llrir t)lr Jfltl0tbi)tbt)
b)i)horrcnu
<- lllrL')il
rh0ll
.ll,) ir,LD(rrtr
0nn,rq0 )n,)n0,il[, x,)irr ]h
, 1r/U
U
[)-t :trrvrxt
bsjstior3Xq,etu Jr6q,r096$ob otr301qro0rt63tr
0q)o6 qrr3oor pbpgr6goqb
A$(')6(') (r!Oo(',,
$J6ao6o(Q6C6o 6r6roq,3bol-r, 0gg6og6g6our er JCq,0U6olj 3o0o$3$oL 0o36 2012 $q,oU 22
o jgo006oqps6 qoq3AAC 6r$Ctrq,o A38robol.t r66.>6rotstt.
qc6stron 13 9969.
q.>69 3oqgti.:dg
ამონაწერი სხდომის ოქმიდან
r0oEs$gt6o
t$d.:Oo,30e'(tl, $d,q'5ACqjol, \,C6!qCq'o l.,bA(,8ou ('rCaoArS
b)J)h0t3lcmb
J)hc)al60n
N56-IU
05.09.2013 $gq,o
Urj.rr6o4XqroL J,vrryJa3fuob 2013 $q,oU 5 t CdoCabfr,lj Jq'CEn(rCq'
l.,bQs,ArtC LrCr6ol.JCq,(,lj Jr6q,rACEOoL t636q,.>6366oU 52-l ACbq'oL
8Culbiaoure, 66obrqg ojbc aoR0bflq,o tr.>jsr6orgq'oU Jr6q'rac6oou r86r6uq'
lt3ooDorr, ac66t6or9qx'r6oL q-or63ols q9.> l.r6o.>q56 lt3oorborr qpr 616wry'3boL,
agg6o36X0otr> Ar Jflq,Ou6oll JcIaoOCOCboL Ao36 $.>OAoag66oq'o r66)dnaCbo
6s$9gq,o lr.>1po.:6<'rbob agltbgb.
brCr6o,gCq,ou J!6q,rAC6OoL
or30xesfr6C
qg.>3cror gUggr83oq,<t
ანგარიში
Irq#6,('BCq,(jU 3rf,q$CqjrrL A!5.)oRC0olr, aco6r,c(r,c8our q-o! 3Uq'OU6ol, JoSoOCOob &{lf,
*r6!(69Opqt Auarobdr .)%.)dr,Ao
(bu.>66u6o0o JgSooq.oo - 2012 $q,oU 22 oCOoa66oArE eeCaAC)
U,:j,:6o3gq,oU Js6q,s6966ol-r 69639 o(.lgg3ob 5u6.>oq,3bolr, 6906oC6C6obr er JCq,OU6ol.r
J('lAoOCOo o,rgouo AUa.robolr Jo6gq, $3glr (2012 $goU 22 ojgoabgt+n - 2013 gq,oU 7 J0goLO('l)
rUi6OoCq,CbeJ ltjut6oSgq,r'rb Jcr6booo00o.,or
Jrd)q,rAC6OoU tfu6q,u0g66cror
C.or
Ar<rBJqtoL$oECbUq, UrCAor&DOrU.
JoAoOCOar re6o3&Jg lsr66r6otso Jg6rxaq0o Bnr066J 39 Lb(x"or, 6)('Iaq,CbtC0
6r6boqxJqlrl ojtu ,1{ 3.:6obJ6oal$o eJ 2 L$r6o6aeCbq,o $o6rereCbr (6r'ra3q,o,rAi6 C6cr,o,
a(')Crq'ij3orr bJo6o0oJO.Bo A6ggol-t do0t6 $.>0og6Xbgq,o $o6rq94.o3b,> ,,0sggg96q,o0olr
aCLrbcb" Lr#6)o,gcq,oU 316o60o ggq,oqrcocbou tsc0r6oL acL,:fub" 3rn0og3goL 0ogfr 0oqgbgq,o
oC6r, ACc!6CtC ao, Lsj.>6or3gq,olt 3o6g0rgo66rgoL6o,r flgaojagqg3boon Jrgtso6ob AoCf)
$sao$6g0Uq, ,,3tio36gq,o Jo6CArOo06).)gooU brbgq'a$ogo Ab6)erlC6oL 63ttfub"
bjr6o4gq,ob Jr6o63o 0gq,oq,Cbg0ol-r 09g;6ol-r tsgb.:bgb", 19r6ca 0o6qn6,:rtrg<,r0U Ogts;obr
$obr(l>eC0ob r30o6)Cbor6).
J(')AoOCOAT EJJOr6r 2 bJlr8q,ooo U\nas l)Jju6orgqou 03g6qdr3broru C6(.)BEUq,
.>3sq.o30ortso: 1."g0rqq'31-to Ar6roq,Caour
aCO6oC6C6oU UtsC6lr'r3bao 5.rttgr63fugo
t+r3go60gbob 0gl!b30" qg.r 2.
"l-tfuq,A$ogo C6oU tsCLrtCb" bj.>6o6gqx'rlr Jr6o6ob J6('tfiloou
6oL.>6$.4pgfusqr 0Xg6oC6C0oUr e! CCI$C6g90oU 0oU0g6.>'.
6r6roqCbob, 0g36oXt63bour er JUq,OC6ob JoaoOCOol, ()6c)0.,10.'3.)o) $6)q,rAC6otso
0roAr6cD Jo6tsCd)Cbgor orgOrtg: "jo6orpq,o p6,> )C(I lr,rg3g6oU 6rAtr$gmCbo", 6o03qb6
ooSggqn o99696 J6q,r036golr ot3&4qpo6s6g, JJ6q,rAC6OoU $3369bo, jrrroryq,o g6oU
L$oo,bCbt3 0<'r0C0J3g 0g36oX63bo qgu Ub3r qoJo6OC6CLCbUq,o o6Ar6o'br3oCbo.
rq6"ts&Jg Uur66ut6oacr Jg6ooqtso JoTAoOCOAo 630o3oqrc (r,(,o 6JoCQC6oboo)
It.>o6gotrl0.rgoo brlroronU 6.rlrq,.> qgr 330-0qp Oojsq'ujob $36oqo. gggq,u 0wr6.>61 6.>6r
Jrl.vobo Jb aobq,J tClrJorAouo trr9r6o5gbr. J('laoOCOob org&;q.ogr0ctrr3, JoaoOCOol, $Ca6,Cbo Ar
rJ.:6.:$olr ot6railt6oAq,Cao 6,36gq,rt6"Jq,re hACA('lAoCb osrCrq,rCCCbU.
Ar
o 3r6o6Jt6ogjggbo, 6olaq,C0tCo br6ro,q,Cbolr, 0X66oglfu6olt qor JCq'OU6oU J('lAoOCOo
ogo o6c,(3olo(,d)o J('raoOCOo (3):
t
. UJCyr,oACq,oU J.)tr,q,rAC6oot or6iorq'Cbou, 0m6r6r<r30ou>
q_or
3Uq,OCd)(,L
3oAo696oL aogd, lr!3r6o60q-oCbq,o o6o6or0qol, $Clrlo, $rdra<'tqSC6oq'r,
A3lsb96" lrj.r6o4gq,otr
UqAt6oACq'oU 3r5o6ou Jt6oflrJgbo:
"4.ry$g6qrr"boL
3.>6<i66o g3q,oq,gbC6<lt Ar AJA\5C0C6oL ECOrEoL B9bb90" , lt>ffor33qoU 3r&60o
"l$j.>t6or3gq,oL
Jrd)q,raC60ou 6,c0q,JaC6OBo o3q,oq,cbcboL 0COr6oL Ecbrbc6" ,
bsbrqt<'l qlr063q,ol,0CtibC6" lro.Ju6o4gq,ob <'x6A!6Cq, J!6oEAcl
"l-Dj.>6or$q,<1tt
oSq,oeCSoL SCOrt(,lt orx'rbrt3" (07-V69,07.03.13)
2.
lqjrrSo8gqoL lsOq,rAgejob 6r6.rory,96oL, A66o9f40ols er JUE OC6ol,
Jcr0oOCOoU &46r ltr3c6o6Aq.o9@o cl6%cl!0rlgrlll $guoor $rt60oqg6g6(q,o
Uqict6o63q,ob 3r6o6ob J6ogi6o: ltj.n6orggq,oU 316o60o ,0rg$g0qx'rbolr ogttb0b"
63q,oq,3b3bolt qg.> qgrA$C$Cbol, 0CO!6ob ACLIbCS"
Urj.>t6o4gq,oU Jrt6q'rAgfuol., 6.>6corqp6olt, 0g66o3t63bol-t
Ar 3Uq,OU6ol,
JoaoOCOol, aogri L:3r6o6AqrX0qo o6o6orgqou $gtroor $r(r,Aoq,.dC6oq,o
Itqirc,qryq,ob JJ6o6ol, 3d)ocCoo: ,,#mgcbo"Jq,o oCro6rc0ob a3l-ub3b" (07-3156,
08.02.2013)
JJ6oEJ6,oCCOCbo, SelAqtCbt'CO 6,>5roq,90oL, 0g66ogdrg6oUr (,J JCq,OU6)ot, JerAoOCOo
ogc) Vra$r6o JelAoOCOo (24):
l. bqCrd,o'3Ce,('tl, Jn6q,.>Ag66olt $366olt on6ror,6 boqor8Cq,ob Aq6 U.>3r6<n6Aqgbq,(,
o6ooo\5o3oL $gtrco Sr,(r,A(,(raC5oq,o Jr6oEl6o&loCbo:,,D(.o0oq'(')b6)%o
or3oof0s6o6gqm6olr Egltbgb' Urjs6o49q,oL 3.>6oEBo $q,oq,C690olD qgr
q,r8xJCbCbol., 0Cor6ol, orrobrtC" qo! ,,brCr6orgCq,ci, AC('Srq'SoL - qrboq,oljob
SCUrbCb" U)Crr,('BCqr 316o68o 3$o63o g3q,oq,goCbolD er e.)A!OC0C0ol,
SCOJEoI or!c6!tC" (07-3141, 08.01.2013)
2. ls.jy6or3gq,oL 0orr36o6ou aogf) l$3.)6o6aQCbq,o o6o6ougqob $9l.rror
Srfraoq.om6oq,o lDjrtrto)3gqx JJEof,ob 3trm9$590o:
^luq)ou6flq,o
ACA$oQ6,Cet0ot, aCLrbCb" brC.)6q,3Cq,c)L Jr6el6tso OBq,oq,CboL ACOr6oL orrlbrtC',
6Cbr6o3Cboll 83Urb50" Urj.>t6or3gq'olr 316o63o mq,oq,Cbob
"q,ogg6$ogboLr e!
0COr6oL orro6!$C" C.o! ,Lrjot6orpq'ob qggqglClq,rdoll - orboqoltoL fl3bbgb"
bqic6orgq,oU 3r6<'r6ao $q,oq,cbou SCODEoL ors<'rbrtg" (07-2158, 13.05.2013).
brjrt6orgq,olr Oorr3rnbolt 0o96 lr>3.>6o60q&,o oSoOorOoOoU gClrocD
$s6aoqeac6oq,o lsjn6orggqroU Jr6('t6olj J6o&joc6o: ,,Ua.>qqllro 6.r6uory,gbol-r
391-t.>fu6" Lrjrtio6gq,oL Jr6o6Bo O3q,oq,C0ob ACOr6oL orr<'r0JtC",,,$cl6.>4-0cl
Arbroq,CboL AgL$96" Lsj.>t6o4ggolj 3r6o6tso o3q,oq,Cbou SCOJEoI o,JctbDtC" C.or
,,lt0bgcg6o grq,qggbgq'3030o1$ qgr br0b3q-ot6o lt,:6L:bg6oU ts3L.>bg6" ll>jr6o4Xq'olt
3.>6<'rEEo 6q'oq,g6ol, tscODEoU o)Job)t)c" (07 -2/7 5; 22.M.2013)
a. b'irt6oroCq'stu aor€d,e,botr &{6, UJJ56(,60ACAq,o o6cgos6ogou $gur)o)
$,:d)6oA6C6q,o lrlCrdro4Cq'ol, 3t5t'r6<i &+x'rglJo:,,gOrqq,gln 6S.toryC6ot
ACUJW" l$jst(ror3gqx'rb Jre'r60o o8q'()q'Cbou ACOr6oU (,))e$rtC" (07-269,
31.05.2013)
ttjrrior3Xq,cfu OotgrroboL 0o3tt Lr3r6o60qg3bq,o rt6<l0rlgcl3rll-r $31-roor
$s6aoq.o6g6oq,., lt:jr6o6gq,oLr 3s6o6oU Jt6oalgo: ,,Jt6r'rg9lt€q,o 6.>6sory,36o1-r
0glt.>b96" lr>j.>l6o8gqxrt 3.>5(.t60o mq,()q,Cbob ACOIEoL orx'rb.>tg" (07-268,
30.0s.2013)
Itrjrdumqx lr6q,rAg66ob$ggfr,t cArfu 3oqt6rdouAoC6br3.>6<'r60q6\,o
C)6 olooSolr$Cll(,C,,0itra('tqtoC6oq,otrlCrfior3Xqob 3r&$ob J6o9fuo:,,LrxJ6o
br8rdtorq,ol, qCf)oQrrCq,o Jodrob 091$bgb'Lrjr6orggq,oU 316o60o ggqoqrS0ol-r
tC6r6ol, orrobr$C" (07-3193, 06.06. l3)
1.
Uq}Oor3gqxd, 0or,4t6erboU Aogd) l.,r3r6o66AC0q,o o6o6orgo3ob fStroor
0!6,Ar'rQ6C6oq,o ltr,j.>t6oagq,ol, 3.>&.6ott Jt6t'r9fr1o: ,,JfiogSlrogq,o 6.>6oq,gbolr
Egl$bg6' lrrCr6o,3Cqxru Jr6('t6&l) @q'oq'C6oL ACOr6ol, oru'rbr$o" (07-29,
04.01.2013)
b)j>6rorgq,oL aos36e)boL aoCf, L$r6o6AeCbq,(') o6o0oroo3oL $3Loo
$.yffir'X.o0g5oq,o L$s6ror6gob 3r6o6ott J6oglgo:,,$o0{oo 6ubsorq,Sbob
Bobsbgb" Lsjr6or3gqx'rL Jr6o68o 0Oq'oq,C6oL ACO)6o1, o)lo6!tC" (07-2110,
05.12.2012)
9.ltdr6<rBCq,oll aoDg6r<',0ob AoCf, lrrJr6<.r60qrC0q'cr o6oooqjrloob 0CUoo,
0!({,aaKr0c6<'o U.rjvlo8gq,erl, 3r6ro6oU Jdroalgo ,,U8J(,q'Clro a!6ro,q,c8ob
8CbJW" lrlCrd,o,30qx',b 3r&,,mb o3q'oq'CMr 036.$oU oDo$.)$g"(o7 -2152,21.03.13)
l0.U$.>l6o&qxd, Aor€6xr8rlu Ao36 Ur3r6oE0q-oCbq'o o6r6or6r6ob $glnor
$.>o0oag6g6oq'o lriCld,ogCq,oL JrerEot J{ftrdorr: "6.:6ro{,C6oL br6otbob
&hoo,rd,C6ob 09brb96" l).)j.>6o,3cq,ob 3r&,160r: o3eoq'C6(lr 8C0r6ol, olobrtC',
"tooJAn A56ro,q,Cbou EClDbCb" UrCrd,o,3Cq,rrlj 3s6rn60o G3q,oq'C6ou ACOD6ol)
otalbr$g', "A3.>6t6o rqtrnghou go6€C6ot A9b.:bXa"UsjyrroBgqxeL 3r&'160o
Ogq,oq'C5olr ACO,!6o1, or!obr$C", "JdxrtsCuryJq'o 6.r6.:orqr90ol-r 09lsb9A.llrj.>Ool33q,oll
3r6rn60o $q,oq'C6ol, 0COr6oU Crrr(,,brtC' eJ ,,UAWq,CUo 6r6.>orq,gbob 89LrbC0"
UqlxrrorglqoU 3r&n60o g3q,CqlC6rrlr SCODEoU or.>r'rb.>$9" (07-23,03.01.2013)
tl.l$j.ytoBcqx' , $6'q'iaC6OoU $AdnU AU60r6 A"Jpbrdolr 0o3rt lr>3r6o6aqrg0q,cr
o6(Eoloogou trCLos, $if)0('!ErdC6(('o brCr6(r)3Ce'('i, 3r6o6ou &6og{l.JC&r:
,,aqC$UCbq,i'sotr ogl.,ruCb" lDilr,o,30q,ob 3.:&'160o &3q,oq,CbC6ol-| 0Cor6ol,
ox$rtg',,,trrbgql8Sogo 0glryqBC6ou Egt!:bgO' l$jstrE69q,oL 3.r&'160o
@q,oq'Cbot, 0C6r6ol, ox'O.>b3" (07-32.5, 03.12. 12)
12. U.rjn5o6ge'ol, Jld,q'rACfur,U $m6C0d.,
Cqd(', 8.>godols qg.> Ag6,ar6 (fiA8rdol.,
aog6 br3r6o58(tCbq'o (,6()0(,10()3(,l, $Clrool, 0id,as{6C6oq, l$rdrorggqroU 3.>&,r6oU
Jdx'rglJ$g ,,acg$99\x'rtou oXUrbCb' lrrd!6o,8C('s,b Jr6o68o @q'oq,Cool, 0COr6oU
oDe$.rt3", UrCy{,s8Cqx'tl, JJ6,q,.:Ag6Oob r6C0q,r0C&Jol, &6ofrlotC ,,lrq}({,qgCqx',b
Jr6grAC60r,l, 6COq$C&J0" $q,oq,Cbob 0gg.:6ob oro8.>$9" qrr ls j.:dro49q,{',1.}
odr6iEgq,o 3s6tD6ou 3t(roglSCbtC : ,,l,rdr6oBCqx'll) o60)6pJq, J!6o6ao
,,1$j.v6o4gq,ol, bri{6886o 3o(,elbo" o3q,oq,c0ol, 0Cor6ob aCurbgb" q.o,) ,,I$biq'bcr
q.fg3gq,ol, acblbcb" l$d!6o,3gq,elu o6,0i5"Jq' Jr6c,68o @q,oq'c6ol, 0c0!6ou
oxtu$g" (07-V81, 15.04.13)
l3.S&r$Uor6 oooo.ddnoff$ JoAq5COoU aocO Ur3r6o0oqgC8qxr o6ogorr3qol.r
Sdx,o, $!d,Ac,(RCEoqD lrldrd,o4Cqrr,rb JtExrEoU Jdx'rdQo:,,arp$gCbqs8oL
agUrUCb" lrlditr,ogoexilt 3.>6<'rEDo ggq,q,C8ol, 0XxJ.r6olr ox'rbr$g" (07-3113,
20.11.2012)
I a.
L+6('a0(xrl, ao4t<xnbol-t aogdr ltr3.>6o6fu9\,o o6(Eo\Jr,Aotr $Clro(,)
Syffica96g6q'o lrsjyto8gq,sfu 3r6o6rtu Jtft'rgloo:,,garqq,glm A!6r(,{,C6ot
8CLrbC6" UrCr6oRCq'<'tL 316o60o $q,oq,C0ou 8C$r6ol, orlobrtC" (07-Y11,
10.12.2012)
15. Uqjrdr6gqx'tu &f,q'rAC60ot Sgrnb, fuorag dodo6gttob 0o36 U.r3.:6o60qgC0q,o
o6ooogo3oL $glroo, $5t6act(,0C6oq,o brjr6o,OCq'oU 3s6<'r6oL Jt6ogj6g6o:
,,Ca!eq,CUo Ar6ro{,Cbob SgLrbgb" Lrjr6or6q,oL 316o68o mq,oq,gbou 0ggr6oL
or!r'rb!$C" ar ,,A,)EJoq,Cbol, bu6oltboU 6.>fuooxfu6ob 0glsbgb" Lsj.:6or3gq>olr
316o6ao osq'oq,C8oL ECODEoU o)dr$C" (N07-3R5 19.12.2012)
l6.lqjrdD3gqxrl, 0or>36e6oU 0o9tt Lr3$o60q.og\,o oEcAcl.>O%oU gClroo)
0r6,Asa90C6oq'o l$jr6o6gq,ot Jr6o6oU J6oCdOo:,,g0rqq,3lm br6rs,q,Cbob
A9Lrbg6" ljrCr6o,OCq'('1j J!6oEEo CAq,oq)CboU 099.>5oL orco6,:tg" (07-A31,
30.01.2013)
f7. UrCi6(,rACq)oU Jr6q,rAC6OoL ts6rC0os ,,g6onr5o 6;goo6rq,U6o 0odt6robolr" aogdr
lr.r3r6o60q6\,o o6ogor6%ol-t $glro(,, S!trr'lQ0C6.q,o Jr6(')BJdx'l&IJo: ,,gdcqq,gln
6$rorq,CMr 0CbrbCS' lrrCld)or6Cqxru 3.>6<rbAo 63q,oq,C8olr Bg6^r6ob orrobr$g" (073/53,07.02.2013)
lE.bqCr6('rgCq,(' J.vrtq'rogfuou 66oJrlrr.:6 o6OCA6JOrr,l., JoaoOCOoU AoC6,
br3.>5r')60qgbq'o o6o6orr$6oU trcLo(r, Vrrfo(oac6(K,o Jr6('lEJfxrcCocbo:
rq,ffiob66J3rrJq, br6r6orrq,qrrtiqgmrqrJ Jo{gCClr0o
,,ltjs6or33q,ol.t
$q,oq,CbC6ou tsC$r6ob orrcB.>$3" q.o.> ,,5X3q'u0oU tsgltbgb" lry$t6or39q,oL 316o68o
63q,oq,3bg6ob Bgg.>6ou AgUrbSb' (07-3112, 20.11.2012)
l9.bqC56drgCeol., AC'r€6('I6ou aoC6 LrJJ6Clffi(,C\,(') oboooJoogol, $CUoo)
0!6aoc9ac6oq,o lr.$!r6o4gq,oU Jr6o6ou J6o&loo:,,gdrqq,gln 6r6oq,gboL
39bsQ6" lsjrt6o5gqx r 3s6o63o 6q,oq1boL tsC0r6ob orr}b!$C" (07-269, 31.05.13)
20. Uqj.rdto6gqnlt
Aor€dxrbob 0o3t6 l-t.>3r6o60q9g0q,o o6.Aoi6o3ol, $Clrlo,
$.>OAoq6g6.,q,o Lrjn6o6gq,ob 3r6o6ol-t Jt6ogfl6o:,,tcr6.>qn 6c6roryr3boU 03lrbX5"
lr.{ct6o63q'srL Jr&'rEAo g3q,oq'C6rlJ ACOrEdr orr<'!6r'bC" (07-2138, 08.02.13)
21. UJC.)5(rBCq'(')b Jr6q,raC6OoU $669bolr b.r$r J$UsaOoq,oU qgr bc(,cgr6 gogbrdolr
6o96 Lr3u6o66qrg\,o o6o0oJlj%ou $Cboor $,:60oq-o696oq,o brj.:6orgq,<'rlj 3.>6r'16olr
orCrO6CboL aXltbob" lr.$:6orgq,oU 316(')63o 6q,oq,9boL
J{5<'rgjgo:
"Jdmgglrouqo
ACOr6oL o!<lbr$C" (07 -3/92, 31.05.13)
22. lrqCn6oACqlsn $6,qraXbrJoU gt5.:ftos
"$/1,onr5o
btgo<'t6.>qpJt+n
tud6robol.," 0oC6
UlJr6omec0q'o o6$o\5qol, $gboo, $rdra(')(''dc5oq,o l$j.rdDggqxtu 316('16(,l,
8gU.)bCO" lrrC!6,o4Cq,tru J!6<'r60o 33q'oq1bob
"UAreq'gUo 6r6.toryCM,
ACOJ6ol, o,r(',b!$C" (n .urbgq,opgo SXLgoagBCboL ACUrbCb" lrrCr(r,or3Cq,olr 316<'160o
J6<'rgl6g$o:
@q,oq,CbC8ob Ag0D6oU ox'rb.>tg" (07-3185, 25.04.13)
23. rJJ6ol., r36er6<'rtu"J6o drglBg\,o3ob g0oqq,Cln
ltlot 0ogt6 lrs3.$o66pgfuo
o6o0o\).8ou $gljoor [r6Aoq.o0C6oq, brjrfio6gq,oL J)fm6?,U Jt6ogjgo
,,4l0$U0bqxebob ACUrbCb" l$C.:Ocrn0g,<rb 3r&168o 6q'oqt30oU ECOr6ol, oi('lbrtC"
Llijr6,q4Cq,eil odr6r6gq,o 3.:6t'r6oL J{6oel0o ,,brdv6o4CExilt c'rfu.>fuq, 3r6o6t}o ,,
lDj.>trtoaSq't1L Ust6866o 3ogAllto o8q,oqcbob ac6r6ob 331r.>b3b" (07-254,
21.03.13)
24. lrjrt6o63q,ob Jo6q,.>0g6goL
g6rj0or "C6oror6o 6c6oo6sq,gt6o 0odt6.>o6olr" 6ogt6
tD3.>6o66q.ogbq,o o6o0oroo3oU $gltoor $r6aoq.oac6.rq,o uJC.)6oocq,<.rl, Jr6o6ou
Jt6<'r3flg90o:
"90,:qq,3bo 6r6cory,30oU
ECO)6o1, crrrobrtC',
"lribCq,A$ogl'r
Bgbrbgb" lrsjr5o6gq,oU 3.>6<'163o 6q,oq,3boL
83\o<pgbol-t Agb.>b30" Urjrt6o6gq,ob 316<'63o
&3q'({'C&rr 6g6J6ob orw)6rto", "U.:C.>AoBCq,r"tr lrroleJDbJ(x') JoaC#Bo
q3q,oq,C8<tl, Aff$Eolr orx.r0.>$g" (07 -3R497 -02.2013\
3c6<'r6Jt6o9jg56o, dmaq,gbtg0 6r6,:ory9bolr, 0366og6g6ott q.or JUq,OC6ol., JclAoOCOo
ogo Jt'rAoOCOo, 6<'rAqrrt qtltgEs b3rq,q'CqJqx"! (14:
l. U.)CJtr,oBC(,ctu $t6q,.>43$ob $6r6oU 3obr (D8oorrASoq,ob AoC6 lta$o6aq6\x'r
o6ogo\yAob $guoo, $cOA<'rq6g6oqtrr 1.,.{sr,orgC<,ob 3r6o6oL J6oAl6o:,,01369
t964q16obr6.>6 .:dt.:lt62q,fu,o3r5orr qo63ob 33ltb3b" Lrju6orgXq,oU 316o63o
o3q'oq,gMr AC6!6o1, tsCurbCo',,,U.>jrOo,gcqxru rqoao6oLof)EeJq'
U.>0.>t6orsq'a.orfug96rorr 3oq6jbtso 6gqroq,C0oU ACOr6ot Bgbb3b", ,,tfu3q,r0oL
0glrsbgb" bsjrt6or3gqx'rU J!6r'r60o $q'oq'C0ob 039.>6oU otobr$3", ,,0r9$g\,obob
8gu.:b96" brjr<6o,3cqx'fu Jr6crfill) mq,oq,Cbob 6g6r6ob otobrtg" $07-3ll17,
20.06.13) (lqorAor6ol, URq,CO.)qrJ q,.l63obr qt lt6ojrq,.$o o6OC66!Ooob JoaoOCOo)
2. lrqdltio8Cq,ou &6gtq-oC6ool, Aqo dt>{pgo6odrgboLro8ob $rff('tQaCSoq' 2012
gq'ol, 9 &rCabc6rll bcq,ao$c6oq,,,ltj.:t6o49qxd-t.r (-or brC6crrra<'t6out'r
6,)Egoc/,!6C6oU rbro6o.>gorlr &rr5nb c.osgo6r6l4bob Sgoro6b0g0rt3 (6g6cn6q,gt6o
6.>6goorrt6gbol-r Agcrtr4 J5o$go) (07-118,07-12.12\. (U.>go6r6lx'r-tt0rry166o
JoaoOCOo)
3. U8.rt6o49q,r,b id{toqgfuoU Ao96 6tq)ogo6odrg6oU:o4olt $.:t60oq9616rq'o
q.o br6 arfn&rL
2012 $q,ob 28 bglJ3a6oou bgqfo$c6rqr,
"urdi6ol3cq,<')l.,!
6ClrJUAq'oJJL Ac 6oU 3g0oU.>3q,301t qrr 3So6rq,bg o60.16o q-orbC6g6ou orSop!6
rgoq,C0ols (r 05(,Jtbrq$0olt .>q$Cqxrl, AgUsbCb" ACo,r6MCbr (07-ll9, I1.12.2012)
(Lrgo6!6uo-lrrb.,:Cxroo 3otu69go)
4. tJJCrd,oACq,F,t J5CtoAC6Oob AoCO d,gogooo6CboLsoAot $.rr68oq.o696rryo 2012
$q'ob 6 q.oCBC00g6L bgq,Ao$Ct(r,q,o,,ltCrfior39q,olrr qrr \,o3g5oolr
{5gldgbq,o3rU 0ot6oL 8g0oLr3q,3bls q.or 3r.loorq,tC o(ffirAo Q.>bC036oL
o.)ooArb rOoq,CSoUr C.or 0rQrlr.)b{,C6ol, owleJbACq,obot rP$Cq,oU BCLrbC6"
0CorEbOC0r (07-ll12, 21.12.12) OlAoEimro-Urb<l"JXCOr't JctroOCOo)
5. ,,b.>jc6or39qxdr 2012 Sq'ol, lrJbCq,A$cgo bog2qX6oU 0gbrbgb" l.rj.r6o69q,oL 316o63o
g3qnq'gbolr tsXa5.r6ob o,ro6!tC"O€o656bo-Lr6oUxroo JctaoOCOo)
lqirt6or3gq,oU aorrg6obot aog6, S!t60oqooC6q'o ,,Lrjrt6o6gq'r'rb 2012 $qrob
blbCq,A$ogtc 6qggXXa5ob OgtdpJq,gbob $qrryt6o .rfur6otso" (07-y56,29.03.2013)
(lttgo6!6uo-lrr6o:JDu6o 3rf ralgo)
7. Itrd!6umq,s 0orr36erboU AoC6 lt3s6o66q9\>o cl6<l9cl16o3clll fCLoq,
$rOaoq6g6oq,o Jr&'tEJfxrdOCAo : "lsjrt6o6gq,erU 0ot36obob lrOdFgdOUd,oU,
ggq,C0Jas$oq,Cbou) qor U)CAoJ6o6ol, $ClroU BClrJbCb" bjuqorggq,ob 3rbm60o
gq'rqSboU ACO)6o1, oD)('}b)tC" tDjy6o)3gq,ou Jr6o6tso o3q'oq'CboL ECO5EoU
ECI$bC6",,,roa('tutsC60q,o3sX6oUq.o43oUBgltbgb"ltjc6o49qnL316o63o
O8q'oq'Cbo[t ECOr6oU o,robrtC", ,,CgCrJ6oCECdlACOoJolrr q,r 6gfubtrn3o 6rtoU
AgLsqb" l$j.v6otgq,ctl., Jr6o60o o3qcryCbol, SCOre,()L crrrobr$C", ,,b,>}56)(,Bgqx r
)(6o6olro6Joo0e ls0.:t6or.qp.:fu36rors 3oa.o3jLBo o3q,oq,Cbou tsCoroolj
tsgh>fu0", ,,oA36t3onU 0qgo0g90ob Arogq,o O3fn0o6tqbob 03j66oLr qrs 6s6or3otr
3gl.,rbC6" l$Cn6o8C<,clb 3r6<n60o o3qxqpboU 0COr6oL crrrob)tC", ,or\roUol-t
C&'rOqCq,o JrSJoL ACLrbCb" Uqffr,3ggoL Jr6c,btso o3q,oq,C6ob ACOr6oL
orrobr$g",,,6st696ou q-o!$ol, aCbrbCb' b.>jnrto)3cq,crb 3rh6Ao o3qroggboU 036J.>6ob
orobrtC" LrCr6C'rgC(,(')L 3c6<'r60o 6grry30ob tsCOrboL EglDbCb",
"C6,o3BJq,o
brJ6rCo3('t ts(',6(rrLr q.or gt6o36gq,o r6do3oL 0CUrbC6" Lrj.:frorpqotr 3r6o6tso
$q'oq'Coou 03gr6ob orrobr$g",,,lsjn6ot33q'olt OC6oO('l6oJtC 6u6B9fuboL
O6)6t.xJoL5 er oaJr)6OoU 8Cl.,rbgb" brj.>t6or3gq,mL Jr6o63o 0gq,oq,Cbol., tsCOrEr,U
orsobstg", ,,t $r6o,ccq,ob lj!\gro 3oqrgjlrao 6q,oq,3boU tsCOrE()U 0Cl.,rb0b",
,,tt0bgq9t6o Jelqngcrrb ACbrbC6" LlC$)or3Cq'olr 3.:6<'163o @q'oq'C$ot tsCO.)6oL
go6(rlb 0vrrorgoU O3ltbC0" ttq#6,oACq,ol, Jr6o60o @q'oq,C6oL
o,>obstg",
"OUob
ECODEoL C,,!(,b5$C", ,,brjs6o6gqx,rb .tro,C('o 6gbbolD" q.os,,$oorgq,o $o66oL"
0Clr!bC6" L,$r{rr(,ACexdr 316o68o 6q,oq16oU ACOIEoU srrobr$C",,,6otru1o0b!6raruq,ou erouq'o OCf)ooelfx,C&ob BCCA6ob! q,r Ar6rq,3ob ACUJbC6"
U.$.y6sACq'si., J!6o6Ao $q,oq,Cbol., ACOr6oU ox$rtC," ,,gboggq,orc U.:6p6<'rU
AgLrbCb" t rjr(r)oACqrlL 3.16<'168o 6q,oq,g6oL ACO!6o1, otobr$g", ,,L:jn6orggq,olt
OUob J(')AC$Ao o3q,oq,Coou 8C0$ob ACt rbCb", ,,ltrcqlfryq,96o $r60elCbror
BgUrbCo" UrCrd,oACqxrb 3r6cr63o OSq'oq'Coot, ECOr6oL o,x'rbJtC", ,,6.)OCD('t6ob eJ
6rtol-r 0gl-rrb30" Lrj.:6or3gq,ob 3r6cr60o g3qnq>5bol, tsCor6olj orw6r$3",
"Urj.>6o)0gq,oL
6orr3t6esou l.,OfpJdou6,ob, Ugq,0orac .,oq,cbot r e) lr.)Caor6obou
$3lntt 09Ls\b" Urjn6or3gqx'rb JJ6o6tso ffiq'oq,CboU 0ggr6oL os('|brtC",
,CJoqlt'rbo36o CdBCf)Ootol., ECl.,rbC0" l$Crlr,o,3gqoU 3.>6o68o 63qoqC6oL ACODEob
or8,Or$9", ,,6,56,CA('l[, ero3ob BCtDbC6' brCr6,o)3Cq'('lu J!5o60o o3q'o(,C6ob BCOrEolj
oJ(,OrtC", .U.)bCq€$oE(t bsgoL A3brb3b" blCJtt)o3Cq,ob JJEGIEBo 03q,oq,C0ob
ECOrEoL cr,robrtC', .tsCord)rqCblr, brabC(6(, OCC6oJol.,r q.o.: o6016o
qor6o8$Cq,Cbol., &rtoqISCOcnU t rCdbJo66to (,r llrct03el60t't 3o666oqoL 0glrrbgb"
Urj.>ttor3gq,oU 3s6o68o 6goqSaoU ESOr6oU orrobrt'c'i ,,Lrjr6orgqmL lnL\roU
Lrar6oq'oL 3oqrgflUao @q,oq,Cbou ACOrbob ECLrbCb",,,Lrbgq,00ogo
lrx,S'gAgoCbob AgbbC6" br.$d,cr4Cq,olr 316<,160o g3q,oq,3boU tsCOrEoL oJobr'bC",
,6gr6o6$30olt qor UJJC6('I6Oo rQ0oqC6ol., lr.r6o6rfq3q'o q.o43olt tofuooU
Agbr\b" b,>jr6or39q,oU 3.>&'160o OSqD.,q,CooL ACOJSoI, o,J(,bJtC", .CrqrC
or&q,olnL brbQ3f)CbAo q,os 0odqgSb!69 OC6oOo6,ortC .>t6U98gqn 0$3169
6v60!3C0oLr er trbCq,A$(,ge) OgoL go6(r,u SrEl$3Uor6CbCq'o qrg3oU 03Urb3b"
brjc6or3gq,oU 316<'168o g3q,oq,C6oU ACOr6ol, o,.)ob.)tC", ,e!Ouq'o OC6oO<'r6oC6oL
UolrOC0oU ACU5bC6" Uq$t6or39q,c'tU 3.>6o60o 6goq36ou 0COr6oL g1r1';brtC",
,,org8gonl-r, 0J$J6J-b!bJ6C06ol.,, q,c6el*ogbolt q-o,) grtqxr3J6ou C,orggq,o
OC6,o6t'l6oC6ot Ad06oUr pr 0r6o4oU 0Cl.rJbCb" LiCrSoBCq,r'rU 3r6cr63o ggqoqrgboU
ACOr6oll o,rr'tbJtC',
tgAojACACboL 6Cbf,o,0ol, Eglr\0" tr>jrfror33q,ob
"6rr40ofu
3,>6<'163o 6q,oq'90oU tsCODEoU
orobrtC", .erOoq,o g9r5ogot6o30oL LO$Ulrol,
A9Lrb90" l$jrOor3gq,oL JrSobEo O3q,oq,C6ol, ACOr6oL oJobrSC", ,,JoqlbCorol,
AlOUq,o OCd,qSstEr)CboU Efr66obr qrr 0r6or3oU aCltbCb" lrrjst6orSXq,oL 3s6o6Bo
Ogq,oq'Cbob ACOr6ol., orl(',brtC", ,,bgfu06rqo 6SUgt6ltgboor tr>t66\n0olso4olt
0olu6Cbq,CboL 69Urbgb" Urjn6or33q,oU 3.>6<'rEBo 6q'cq,X0oU 0ggr6oU ocobrtg",
,JCLOoOoeCboLr q.or r66ojo0o3.>g30ob 03tt.>b30" ltjrdror3Sqolr 3.:6o63o
6gq'oq'CboL 3CO!6o1., or!r,rbr$C", "U.>Crtr,oryq'srU lttqg.><n tng$goU fuLsbgb"
tqdr6,o6Cq,oL 3,:6o63o 6gq,oq,9bob ACOJEoI o.)obr'bC",,,ltrjrfr63qrol,
b$gq,a$oeo UrteB6ol., agb.>b0o" ljrCr6,(,acq'e)l, 316o68o 03q,oq,c6ol, BcOrEoL
orroortg'i ,,brbC(f$o$I'l jo6gbou 0gL.)bC6" LrCJd,otCqloL 3r6obao 6q'rx9g6olt
ACOJEoU o)('18r$C",,,Ur.JJ6,o,3Cq,cll, rq,Ao6oLO6,rOo"Jq, ttJt6q3cUo JoACCbBc)
g3q,oq,3boU ACO!6oU orrcrb)$C", ,,or6JeoL BCbrbC6" lrrCr6,qBCqoL 3s6r.r6tso
g3q,oq,gboU ECO!6oU orobr$C', ,,bol6o6gq,o Cpr 6rqnr0o{Cq,o gltg6ortx'tgboL
09lrb3b" ltjrt6or3gq,olr 3r6o6Eo o3q,oq,C8ob 3Cor6ol, or('lbrtC",
"lt6g$u60go
U.rj0oo6obotr Jo6o6oq,ot oCl.,rbCb" lrdJ6qr3Cq,olr 316o60o me,oq,C6ou ACO!6o1,
orrobr$g", "t6g6gq,o69boU Ir€JJU6ol, ACLrbC6" Utv6 gq'oL 316o63o
63q'rlq,C6ol, B3go6oU or.>ob.rtg",,'bqjrt6o6gq,clU Lr64rrltbsqxr JoAdLA.,
$q'oe,C0ou A9g,r6ob tsgbJbCb" (NO7-2125, 14.01.2013) (6u690<'rU qrs6olt qgu
6g636t6qo OgLt gOltCbdr Joao666o)
UJil6dRCC,srL 0or4t<x'r6oU 0"Ctt, br3.>6<'r60qgbq,o o6o3or6qol, $3tmor
$r6taoa-o695oq,o Jr6('bJ6c)cdoc8o :,,1$to6rqxrg06o3o xr606or9qoboL 8obbgb"
UrCJf)ogCq,('tU J!6o6Eo 6qxq,g0oU Eggir6olr orrobrtg", ,,6o,4g.r6ou 3o6lrgrrr3.r6cnl$
q.> ErgogogtrrSboL rqq.oAC6.)-6!"Jfur03LC6oU ECLrbC6"trrCrd,o,ggqol.r 316o60o
OOCgoqtCboU ECOJEoU olir'rbrtC",,,$gq,ob 8glsb3b" ltj.>6ror33gob 3r&'168o
mq,oq,C6oU 0go6oU orx'rb.>$3" N07-236, 07.02.13)(A$,CAoU qr.43obr qgr
09090O<6o OgltgOtrgbob JoAoOCOo)
9
Lrjn6o4Xq,oU 6ot3t6o6ob aoCr, Us3r&r66qg\'o o6o0o\)o3ou ggtrror
9J6,At'l(,6C6oq'o JiEoEJEx'rAlJo: ,,t >j.>6o6gq,cltt U.>Aojlq,rCo 3slAep8o mq,oq,C0ou
0gg,>6ob Bgll.:bg0" (07-287, 07.02-2013) (ctg6rc4rryq, br3oolborr Jr'rAoOCOo)
10.
ltjr6o6gq,ob Jt63soq-og66ol., 0.,c6 6,>6ogogo696oLro6oU $.>60oq9696oq,
6r9t6onrfubgq,o gtfuboL odi6.>6o$.rgcri-t 2006 $q,oU 13 q.oglc066ol., ,octegqriq,o
ECl.,Jdq'C\,obot 0jo63 Jo6or.> UtsqlC0C6oU 3ofu36gorUc' pr 3ofug6gcnlr
tsrJCq,O\)C6r., ('t#o (N07-144, 13.05.2013) (trgo6r6l.,o-l$bo0xroo JoAoOCOo)
ll. UqCr6oac<,t'r1l 3r6o6olt JtloSfl6gbtc: "6c,lq,raot ts0tt:hb" L.>jr6or$q'olr 316<o60o
63q,oq,COgOoU tsC$D6oll orc0rtC",
lrrC!6o6Cq,erl, rq,Ao6oUOd)EoCq,
U.>0.>t1orrq,q9.>fu93.>orr 3oagglb0o 6q,oq,gbgbob 39gs6otr 031-r.>b36" (07-3163,
"
22.02.13)(pn66ob6rqo g3o6o0o3oLr q.or 33o6oAoJU6o Joq,oOoJoU JoAo6COo)
Jr6<'r6ou Jd)t'rCCOtC "UrAbCq,6o Olq,AC0Cq,C0ol.,.) q,r l.,r0bCq6o
UrAbrb36olr ACblbCb" b$rd,o3Cqlob 3.:6o66o mq'oq,C0Cboll ACOrEoU orc'ArtC'
12. Urj,:6o49q,oU
(N07-241, 04.03.2013)(or.>3q.oc6ol,
13.
"lr>jr6to8gq,ol$
q.o! b(
er g0o0Cx'rX0ob 3oaogggo)
dBgffl., d,CUJU\,o3rU Bot6oL agaols3q,Col)r AJ JrJoO)q,tC
ot60.>6o qrfu6jt6ou )OoqCbolrJ eJ AsAJI$bs(,CU, olAr"JbeC(,Crhr sq$Csrou
SgUrbgb' 3gor.>6b096.> (N07-l/32, 04.02.2013) (Lrgobr6lx'r-lt0ryp6o JoaoOCOo)
14.
qor Jo6OUArq,oJl, Eo6x,l, SCAoLJAq,COUr er JrJoOrq'tC el6A10rl
"lt.:jM5orggqoUr
pr83636ot .4oq,Xoob.: Cgr 0{,rlDbreC0ol, blAJubeCq,('lbob .:q3ggonb 0gbrbg6"
83or.:6b6gbr (N07-169, 18.03.2013) (sgo6r6ll<'l-1l!6og116<'t JoAoOCOo)
l5.l$j.u6o69q,ol-r Jr6o6oL J6oCdOCbtg,,Lr0bgq-ot6o 3.rq,pgbgqrgbolr e! l$0bCe6('l
U.>Abrbgt6olt ACLJbCb" UrCr6qBCq'('lU Jr&'rEAo g3q,oq,gb36ob ACO!6oU crrJobJtC" ,
0r'rls0Lrbg6ob l$r6Ulnlt 0gltbgb' ltjr6o4gq'olr 316o63o 63oqlC$ou
LoL\,olt lr.>Orfloryob 3r,rq-ogpAo g3q,oq,Cbott
ACOr6ob ol<'r0rtC" q,s
"brj.>6ro6gq,ott
"ltdbgqr6o
0C0F)6o1.,
16.
o,itlbrtC' (N07-A53,23.O5.20l3)(atr3qos63ob! q,J UAoA6,<'rC0oL JoaoOCOo)
U$r6q,r0966o gt6rj6or "gdronr6o 6rgcm6rq-gdro 0od6ro0olr" 0o36
l.ts3r5o66qp\,o o6ooonJoooL $gbor $rt50oq6g6oqo ltjr6or3cqroL 3.>6o6ob
J6oglgo: "ltjrt6o3C(,(,l, lrro)q,rbJb!('(, J(')ACCboo" $q'oq,C6Coot tsCOrEoL
Eglsbgb" (07-3186, 25.04. l3)O.)go6r6lro-lrrboUxCoo JoAoOCOo)
17. Urjr6or33qoU
0oJA6er0oL AoC6 Ur3r6o60qg3bqo o6o6oq)o3oU $glxo
$rdrAoq-o696oq,o UrCol6o4Sqx'rb 3r6t'r6oU Jd,<'l&loo:,,1rCr6o,SCqxdJ
i(6o6obo6,rooUq) U$r6orq,q.ou6q3gcot 3oq-oalbao' 6q'oq'C0ou ACOrEr,b
o,rt'rbJtC' (07-2ry4, 22.05.2013) (qt6rryrryq' l.,DJc,obor JoaoOC6o)