„საქართველოსა და აზიის განვითარების ბანკს შორის დაფინანსების ჩარჩო ხელშეკრულება (მდგრადი ურბანული ტრანსპორტის საინვესტიციო პროგრამა)"
📋 განხილვის ეტაპები
სხდომაზე განსახილველი პროექტი
✓ 82 ✗ 0
საქართველოს პარლამენტის დადგენილება
🏛️ კომიტეტები
- საფინანსო-საბიუჯეტო კომიტეტი წამყვანი კომიტეტი
- საგარეო ურთიერთობათა კომიტეტი კომიტეტი რომლის დასკვნაც სავალდებულოა
- დარგობრივი ეკონომიკისა და ეკონომიკური პოლიტიკის კომიტეტი კომიტეტი რომლის დასკვნაც სავალდებულოა
- რეგიონული პოლიტიკის, თვითმმართველობისა და მაღალმთიანი რეგიონების კომიტეტი კომიტეტი რომლის დასკვნაც სავალდებულოა
- გარემოს დაცვისა და ბუნებრივი რესურსების კომიტეტი კომიტეტი რომლის დასკვნაც სავალდებულოა
📅 დამატებითი ინფორმაცია
ბიუროზე განხილვის თარიღი 2010-09-07
ბიუროს ნომერი 139
📜 ტექსტი
საქართველოს პარლამენტის ბიუროს გადაწყვეტილება ნორმატიული აქტის პროექტის განხილვის პროცედურის დაწყების შესახებ
\
l,JdJ14fl 3tqnl, iJ.6qJil06Clll, lllldn U
aJ{J6',U3fl CnCJt) 6n6ilJOItqI tt0nU
JdniltOlll, Ai6bnqSIU JdnDCqXdnt
qJEUtblll, ?Cl,JbJb
r{0o N 139
7 LnjgX8dSr4o 2010 $.
,lrjrr6o63qolr p.: otooL 6u53ooor6glot lo53t tor6ob q.:go6t6tnloL Elr68o
b6q?63t6trq61o
(8q6r6.:qo trdrlo52qo $t6oELJot6$oLr Uoo536b$o3oo Jr6o6rrroSu)'
lrs$6o6qolr Jt63toqC5$o
lrqn5.$lxo-bloX3g3$o 3r.r0o$X$o
2l - 24 tXjgxSlXt6o
tlra*\ta'r
AouAGntJ lbtnrlniPa annoPo
28 LcJodlcC,o - r -J0oarr6"
@
l,Ja.r,,Co n6oxli6oFl-$ d*0J0o; qi6a.'a6qo Ajc6oa.Jol'i
AJc6.€oJtdn J.'R606,r.1,,pao$$o; rasmfuqo Joqo$o,plt,
orEaA#,tCqr'anlt qo a}qqr€dhr5o d,Ad6CLt,r'&610";
3o6xao! qroJol,J Rr rrsaai,o0n 6rwUcr.t JoaoOCo..
,jr'aodb a doatpar pnL,n6n l)r,,J*'Etdtrs!tu
L;Jrr4or3Xqerlr J,:r6qs3X5goL doy6o ;q6nEL:
L;Jsr6or36qoL Jrr4qr8gSgoL ,jr.rSogngndL.: p; LrJsr6qo335gr.r gr6;Jgo6d?o
pso$3rnL 5r'rt40;go2qo .:JgoL Jr6r.rnJgoL 6;5toq3.:
boj.:16o3nqoL J;t6qt3g5goL
ou335poOrt6g
p;3oor b,:Jt6.:dn
საქართველოს პრეზიდენტის წარდგინება
LJ,JJ6o)33R(,)L Jd,A%Ot{C6<bO
lD$:f}o,$q,stb JYt q,$0fu l,
brjrtlor3gq,r'rb 3o6Ugogggoob 65-3 fl3bq,oltr qr,:,,brj.:t(ur33q,('Il-t
brg6orsEo6olro b3q,013t+tgq,30Xbol-t tsgbrb3O" bljr6orggqrob 3r6o6ob
0g-15 0gbq,ob tsgltbrOob:qr, 6,i6ogogo630otlor3oti gs60t'r6oqr636or 2010
$q,ob 21 q6obb b3q,0rn$g6oq, ,,bsjr6or3gq,obr qr :boob 6.r63oor.r6g0oLr
6:63b tso6olr qrrgo6:6b3botr Br6Ber bXq0gtcryqrgbrb (0qr66rrqro
Sttrbrbgq,o 66rbbJr.1616ob bro6pl,t6ogon Jttro66s0r)".
{t,
6obgoq, Irs.r3s03oq,o
N1/254
I8.08.2010
.8.0t
"tO
განკარგულება
L J d Jd.,o)30s3 C1
l, J60%OlSC56 OL
AJS.IS6TAASTCbJ
I$ 821 2010 gqob 18 ,:6gotgo j. oloqoto
6. AodCq,idob lrrdvnor$qxrlt &6,q'rAC6O0o t6s6r8ogo6C6oboo8ol,
$coq''ac6oq, lrrdr6oraCq,ob brg6or8o6ot al uCqaalcpJq,Car$0
Aoabbg6Cbq,N erEofu 6cir 8gb.:bg0
,,h:Jutrqt.:0g66rn 0q9og6ob 03U,:bgb' lr,:j,ltvrorgXgob 3,:6r'r6oU 0g-3
0gbq,ob 0g-5 Sg6igolt 83brb.:0olsqr, b.rj,:6o63qxrb Jtfutoqr36gob EoXfr
b,:j,:6orgq,t'rb Js6q,,:03690o t6s6ogogo6gbobror3ob gst1qg696oq, 2010
$q,ob 2l o36oblr b3q,0er$gt(roq, ,,brjstto43q,ols qr ,:$oob 6s63oorr6X0ob
br63l-t 6o6oU qrrgo6,:6bg6ob Bst6Bo bgq,06l6gqCbr$C (0p6tvrrq.oo
g60r6gqro 06r6tJr'r60ot lso633b6ogoo Jtto06s0r)" lr,:jrdro3gqob
J,:6q,.r036golt 3oAofiftbBo er Jq,CEr6Uq, bbqgodxbtg &'r0bbg696q,sqp
qpso6o66ob bsjsdrorggqrolr go6,:6bors 0o6olrgt6ob ao{'boq,C Esoror
aodCq$C.
u(,o{J(
დასკვნები
bJdJ6o)3ac?(,)1,
1306J5Lo)J bJa050Lo6)tt
MIN\IISTRY OF FINANCE
OF GEORGIA
o,JJJIL \'.
br'Jr6,oBJe"ob bsAr6,C., UrJaCs,J
ao6obo6ou Aa))eBoe,CU
0lorlb q,rgoo, Xrq,reJ6orb
8rom6(r assoo,,
eCJc'6(6C0obroRob aoA$o36oo,2OlO Dqd 2l o36obU trrCr6crJJe,(''Lr
e! r$6ob
Ar63oo,r6Cbob b,$3b (ADB) acxr,oU arg(,6ECAre,
g;A$gq,.
Od,r6l,JofuoU
"Oq6O)(.o"
0rfu.'ord,C0ob LrofuJbooooo J6.r66raou. ergotu6bcbob tud,s.,, bce"d$l',Au6ol, 06%06r<,1,
o%e'obrd, CbitC ()) aou r6,JrlBrR.,Jeic.6 d.'6o/Jq" ojrrrdar6b.
oo'b%q,, Ub6U6OCe'gc'o rq6od6fq,o bCe,ACJdt3q,CAoU drq,Jdo aCbgq,otj)oEob trJ3o6o
J6,c'OJef 60bob 0rbbrl60oCq,J0o.
rarbo,r6, lr,fCr6o8Cexrb tso6r6bo,r Lrao6ou,O/',o a.rS6CaU, 6oa
sr68('l
bcslqldJse" 033Ms03ar brCJ6sR0q'rll, X,a$oaom{6 ooogd,gt gbb Ori6AreaC6oq,o
er t r3!6rUqrjr, 6l1a
rs6o$gqr Urgo6.)6L.l-$o6oaoJ?6o oBlq,b jt6ob.ts, erqC&,o, AC(O jr, a."6Sr,
lllffi,ffiffiHffiffi
2. brctroBlqs! J4Ct pJfu.U mto
16 .B6.,tr,t fr.5 t a
a$.lseggCoorr slqn r a!Jl.'eo)r
3 UrJlE"XSrU J.rtr<,J6jr{ 0 Eqyt
F<dr t6 B6.r,t Na26 D.d.SEDJe,Cn t ,tl<- fu,;,
{ u,Jjl.Ealqsrr tboJl.rn tqje@ lloa.6.qjii6r, t5.6 2oro !(yr s, zrbix_rr 6,...qiir,q5 br+fEB!<nb A]rl6.66Jrrn A5h@urJa.$ b!A$.\)d,.,U la620lo pq.j, NrvrzoiS-tO631,.q-1,
Fr,(roshtr 5bqn (r
(
20 r
12
631'(0)l
6. UrJ,,r-3N.,l,.Jry\F* L$16.\J6.t ra 6.2010 Eqnb trcr23o{-3S2r
ftr.y(rA J](h ( I }3?ftb)i
7' l,ilrEB0c-b
n6gf!*JiAl0irr$
alEJE'lrrra.'ls
bafil}
rrj ra 06.2ola Eqhb N"lt43
Ao
'nmr.63qn
f36.(htj
rk- (l oroacgo):
8 l,rj.focrc-1, f,cor.,EJq- bq@"lnr&{. qD ofula,r:4ltrJrr$ u!a,h$d) 1,.r1j,"s.6"<.,
abco.rl
ecl'\lrar6o.tJ 06 2010.\q)2{5lo52 ffr(r{,
tt
"r,<- ac*<l.t,
9l$Jl6o{Jq!!a36.!.r\y5.,aJfu.EN6C6orEo6<drta.o6.2otot(rtN,l67o-0/tosldf,qrurllqh(r63!6\b)i
15
I0. uJc$oRlqE! Or.'Cd"'l' q,{C.ur ss bcEJor.ln qr5au3o"t rrar"r,5a,Ii r.tL.:o-to gq-',
r{5{r.o5nr2o
FJrr<rt rk. (I a3c'ts.)l
lr r$1,rsBtqntJ !h!6gqn 0.6J.,b { 06.2010 F<t{) l\!2{3/r6s3 FJ.r\r{ rtqr I a3f\n)i
I
12 j o,A.{llrt) drrm! Ii06 20t0 Sey{ N!06€o9a6-4 Eg6-{!1! J<- ( r
(
aO!6A") --
-
Jr0.,3oboCAoo,
o,z
(ooaoO6o A3o6(ordJ
Ac,6.,1106,ob ar)rA0oq,C
I o\\\nt n01H- t ,\on-.aJJ(alt l. d::t6. d,tq.2bHr:.,l,llo: 262,J!,.tq_tr4!on: ntb i
lc
"tot
I6 At .lasah StLNt. Tbiltst 0 t H. Aqrytl. Tel.: 26 t4 t2 rlt: 262t{t9. E-,t|,,ti in fori;ot
!!
t JJJ6m3Cqf'l
G EORG IA
uJtJl(An UJ&},OI
UJa06ft(ff1
IITINISTRY OF
'_----'
tdilr;3qq't S65llr. bae'l'$dn
o1ffi Adp8*n FEDL I1 oa5,rc! tt
-OA869E Vr&q"t' J'Lth'q'
er6t 65,-. \+6-rrq<r[ trCidp ba!66r6i4F t
q' .t-1, 3.Sx-,t6p"t M;L &lnu 'e.l6!5.r51dot f'lqf,c' heqas,rl4rqClol'
(aRe5.lqa
-
r,,}.eX"(, Ctt-St L,60pt
q'tJa6'l' 'L'r!'id'arqoLr
Jt+'A&'e,': S"
}5lt ar&'t
sLx$
"'tru*
qia*qs.'Xl"t (hleoqri&l s.>Jcr\ro0ao) (Aega.rq" 6l}6po
-1,.$v,,"i3x<-L e.
Iu.sJAtOoOdr 3air66dr* Jif'rroo D' s+uJ60ato
q.!6vaob: I tJlt}8o.
q.r6a gq4*or
A6olgrnt arry6oqx
ketsttl
IS.o6 lo
OlltTbilisl36.i,oCtiudrrn.r*4rGtotgizTGl:(99532)?t464t:Far:199532)18a678
I,JJJ6M 3 JqM
GEORG IA
+\ift
"t{.dail<rt a. rL.t rqrdabf f*Jf ll.f* \oto6lsatot ;.6Ca
baet*ro1* qDll{c ,.fu. 6#.AiGt6.t, {.td.U-s*,
lr6Ct6&)' r. 1#E
L qr olar r,tqrqLt r$Jr a,,,a.[
t htt r tFtrEaLf OhlE.ac F qt Oltlo) €g6.q! ?6l$rRo
L"tdc"rp, t qrA ra.,etbo l), tffi,tra
t%.!dgrr l,.JhrJ tSStCar.J S!6LE.I "t rr6%A,crts q.r stnot
&5ilE!6Aaot lr5,i ao6ot "R.l66&ftalot irt r' + :E6ar6.gdot (aqSerRo
Xl9t6:f1o 6 o6tn {€8, Lilet6d6,r' J6r'EriE&f e{ "l$j.6d3p-t} a.,
Jknl A.lEde$.tCa.t f4rt &radt l,rhltre t6a$ii6fiol, (t.IAJc]Ri6o
c'h,t\l{,3L') (a(l.4.{orl.*$aqd td{r0l6rcE J6.'|s6rAq J.6oeJ6p l)"
J.6-aJ&14" cr &8501, t!6p.6ili .lEe6.'d#n Rr
C,rsl'a",fi,,.
}'tt6hfoSt(lQ
g,r6tcxpai6oeo
&lc6a,
li6qoWo5Aub,
ry,i.006$"1,
bili'q4igrhlot e!!fr
E!S.D !C!cllq\$.,.'
&5nlr6t6ot AoJeaoqj
0ll8 T6,lisr.Sitio Cblbd& s- X4: Grecja.Tcl:(995 32) 2tt64& Fax: r99r 12t rfr6?t
{
f,SJJ6Ol30t{f')1t Ol]lr<bil}O0L Ll0060L<bdtr)
MIN1STITY OF JUSTICE OF GEORCIA
Nat/4 o!-:$1,1
l-v..
-d
20{
(}.
lr.rjGor3gert go5o51ror.r 0oSoUgr6oL &".q6oq$r
fr6cr6 q6o${r a3oSe}d2l,
l.r$oSr,l qoao6l6o,
t r1[6oBggf,ol, olt$Urrrt Urao6olr6.6oA 6,$otrqo o.bC5o .Vt'r{,rrl, l l o36olnt
N07{Z/869tt $36rqrn Sorc,AerRaCSoRo lsi}6or3p<'rto q.) rtrnlr
g$3ooro6gi.tr hSdl' (ADB) Aofnt ,Bq6,ry" ?d'Ar53<,o 6d,r5'lrJc60ol,
6,$3norot6Xbot lrx6pt$ogocr J(m6r4t0ot" g$hr66r'pgAot ih$6rm
grLgcx6ilgtrCqo ,,qqoSJ6lrdrrl, 8r.6&', bp8g6gqXfoL", ,,ltcUfrbo
b3q?g6aq3&nf' Qlnffio I) q., rtoo'U g.rS3muOXaot lo63tr qo
bu$t'rorgqoL &C&r6oiry?6o A.S3mridrgil,t W5ql, ?ltadrl, a.tLryF,6aalgqo
,,1rsJt6oftlSo beqA13dffi*rt' @6..AjAa /) Jd,"'gJSaa", qo i1s36c,Ido,, d1<'ts
&n 3o3o6o u6tg&no tsbotr lroi.x6oqCdt6oao bJ$"tolot t 6SotSEClo .16 51s,;fuL.
,\$o3ot1p&ror,
omSo d3dpg.rq..6'
8o5olr$drob Jr*,r6qo &n.ryanqa
ra, ?L\ru): lL(| rrq !Rt1(a); InLFinrvds{ijor to ,* n
l,\r!\r,nilllc-it1. J lll'loflllbo 0146 6.i]!UrJ&)F01, ltlitfiqo t+-O a;)r:: 1O-$
r(!Jo
lrM^lL: t{,nvl.*dq4dui@8ov!!
l.r:,10
5U44,
44.
10 RudrvEI !w, 011(, Tlilisi Co'xi:, lcli
Idi-3 Eg:zT llrae F{M Er
UJJJ'60l3JCnL
JJnSnanJtl.''n aJ53tloJ6JtnlJ
UJa n5flUO.(n
MINISTRY OF ECONO,!IIC
OEVELOPMENT
OF GEORGIA
/ /.
-7J,dO
:, &/Zoo/t-o
2or4
Lsjsr6os6qo! goSs6bor 3o6oU$6oL smsq5oqlLt
dr0(''E Rdo06o ABoSRldlU
arol,S,q Roao06o,
ltls6or3gqoL AJr,6oihJ36o 6s6XoosdrXJoU Uo3o5ol6r6cr0 6sSoboqo orfu$o'
2Ol0 $qoL ll o3SoUoL I'FO7{ZE69E $66oqoo $':63op665oqo ?nAqn6o
prn;j3;15g3do:
trsjsdro3;1qoL.r po storrL 5s{i3oos6nloL dr6;L ?ortoL 6'>L':3rnr60n}3r1o
,,aRAd,"t{. 16do53rqo Od'r6bJ'''d'Oob 6o53ooot63loL LooSgL$o6o
.ror.r5o.raoL" qr3o5o5b;dob Bor6so b1q?X,1r61q13oU Ji6r"3J$oi
ttl,rdur3gqobs qr otob 6s63oo'sr6nlob ls5,1L ?oriolr 6oLs"3or631dg1o
,3eao.e. <rls53qo 06,)6bJm6OoL 6r56oos63doL Uoosmu$oorx')
Jr6olbd'.:AD - Jd,m0doo l" l,DL0l.,b(, bCq?3J6lR0lol' Jd'r'Jdoot
,:'tob 6r53oo;61lot Js5;Ls q; 015ogoJ')q1d'o 5s53"o';r6XloU 3r'r5pL
?cr14oL 6slr;gm63i1l3qo ,,0q6r6sqo X6ArGIqo O6sSLJr''60111 5s63our'>t6 Xl
|,.\oSAJLOooo.e Jdr'"A6rar -
o lt
J6oCJ6o l" LrJ6(,JJOa) b1q?6;r61r1n?oL
)16o,xJgo
6;6sol3ao, rto0 $;63oq5X6oq Jr4ogJ$3los5 Q!J53?o6C'oo,;o0J3$359r'oL
gsr66qi;d?n l.,ra,,60lt$r'ol, ?X5n?nEXlo sri 6ss65o'>'
JJ0oilob0CAou',
aoSoLO6oU 3osq6oqg
.41 $6r6s6 ,)RnAodA
{''rrSql
..
l,\
'-\\
L'lc lrl
0l0B oi.q'.tr., |o6g1d'"0[ J. '\t12
12. G Chlnruria str,0l08 Tbilisi,Ceorgia
Tel : (+995 32) l0 62 6 I : l0 60 25; l0 62 6ar 9't l0 88
Fax : (-995 12) 9:' l5 14
ld:J,)ritlllJi)\(llr rD0iylt,l6,'lq0
&)6A0tDJ60b{L,) qi,)
0636JtJ66Jd6J i(]L bna060L6rrCi - "
:"
1l t\ lS
l'lt\ ()[ R hCtO\ \ L DI.:\ t,, t.( ]t,i\,1 t, \ t.,\ N t)
t\l tt \s it.( Il.t(1.: ot (;t._r)R(;t \
l. ;l , ,":tri,r'.,,t ,.,r,,r,. I t,,,. .,,J,r,t.r
,!r ti../,
." t'r.rl,o t,tnl.l
i,.,,t, ;h.,.,,,;,,,!,.,1t,
rr,t,,,(,rrn, i,,il, n.!...,h1,
rri.,.
,,.,:titt,t, \
'.;tl ,l.l
,. r, ir..r,l il.t,. |l,,.
..,r..hr,
j,^(;1,,,,,,,itir,. ! r,,,,;t l0l0
\,rr-,,1,
',.!,1 , ',, ,t;tt,,,l it-f,,tt!. t,,
, ,r,!!,.r..,rt. ,t;lr,, il;y'.:lt, .r.,
'
iii r.,
i
l
,'
lir ,,
i
'':.i,
i rr
i,
F@1
E{I'E m.
r,/
J'rn. 15 2B1O 03:1f 1 P01
Jt6216
l <tjriUltlllr\(')h rti|D(xlr5rR0 6Jbil(XD.\60Url$ XJ firt|il\l,Odid{)ilt'l()ir L'\il0ti0b$t't(9
1r&rit6(D3{fqo}b L!5s6O0O}Oagl otfl}OU R0JJdCJallt;$o
*1'!:'; ilt /'ta:i
"-11: -..!.:.'.--.- zon v
hrJVoro;1;p,grrlr ".lrrltrt lrrr,r itrlrolr{r0roL
ih rsq5oq';1h
i\'\(ioL qoii('lrr';i) ;'3ol'g'rdXl'
iI'lx' Jtnl
'5,41,r'ril1;ir'o' tr'arfl R0'l'\6osihh0nn
rl_r i
l'_r u"''
tntdrornll'r u't_rl'rrr'' '
$.vtrflr,rg16gt,rlr'3rr
6,rL'11'rr6eg\1tto
11(rr'33{'Xiv, I't'o
'r'J"6or;11g.tl'" "'
'"
'"''
5rt'11'rn'rt4girrrlt
h#1iltJt61l!g1t\ll'\"1' rrrx'r6l6glru
6'rsfrhr'r'
li()flf'0"1"r q' 'll.|tt-'tt']"ik'rlxaqgilol
rr .n L ' ' -;-"'' trt\^"<w'
itnt'(ilt, (41'll) ilc'r"(rl'
rqr ^rd,liill'oq'o'rl' 11r'l ;;'11,iq1'loor
\
I
I
I
I
Jr,Ai)ilI'l{tilil'x'r,
('oJ(',t{$r,'ilil (l"
nr.,;1&51,r'rilr't'rg
ro,rf9(
if.o,'o
'ffi.,"lffix".H?":Iffii,"fl
6ts, M' .tt, a {
I$at t-t! lt, a {!
.
ii,'ff ?iTii,lliTijJ$ii,, Hllgii?:,,1, **,,
N, 1clo_c;/1o
t+
l, ),i.\6i,,r,x{ol,
o6
?j,)t;.\6tn,.t :}G(!U)6ot, 3_,q6,,r3tr
A.r 1o6 q,ril,g6o
,,c,6t,(5,r;d,,6.) ;h_l('rdr
''qil,,lri,. tr{,.I\.K,,,
Ii,,1",,lilf-:[:il1
iT/,3 3F
e,,6.1r.qod,o
G EoRc'A
2n I0
;U,,6q.x,.nr
I/IFPO'I : n& Georgra Arrdept
PltI.E tE. ; +995 32 B9S2
Jtll, 14 Ulo E6 i6ft1 P1
b.\ir,\60tJrrtl,r r,
ilJr,00r,|l] Q.\oi]0r,.\ {.'
au;ll$dioito ..o:)Li)cr Lr i:"i) L
\4r\f s t'RY ()l I NVIRONt\,lFNT
I'tr( ) I t( n( )N AND NATtlttAL
b J 0 0 5 0 b d5 r) r,r
(.iEORCIA
,ccij6o
20 ledr -_-_^ ,_ _ ..
I\F.
fJ#.i{(l, .r.J,,t,lr
rrr|n.?^Far
R FSoI J RCES OT
L'dr6dti<r''l, 866.r6!oD aoCU06oL &a,Ra,qrt
ts6rl5 l5na6& EJ.ErrecU
.tit rr6/rt era, ,.ikd4l46
^.
tath .Oflbr&lu,,'q{'fulolJrJrtorrdla'r
dJ,6rn'r a4rar.rf p.iurarJ*v
.r0.l5c' q'eo0i.,.,
IIr+rFg|ACqliU aJ60&'t qJ(}iot,
ry ryAa6"C. ,qal,f6LCt"t, Uraa6oto6oa a.}6ouqr
orfu6o 2010 Fe{,I, tl oa66t!,1, N07-02869t gC'tuqn. doqqq3
o36oLL, sLnlr a,,6O.E y"aanL tluol,&i
1UCL, ZOIO Fqol, 7-9
6.l&d!.iq nrrqXc,.ldjg'605gdrtX tu$6o6gn!.r qo ,krntr
lo5JU (ADB) tsodot h5q0i;,+sq$3&,t qs'.i.xAc500)ot, l*,qx,{,,
6ci1,6raot &rqtaol, a.,
a{6carb, dne &,r($(r.O}rt' ?UFoar<,,had\rpo AiiarFJeo 06.SLJorc6ol, ar6$bJi0r.rr
Lr|SACLOoOor, J6.lt6,g)U' !r.!f&$haol, B.,.1to biE nCdq?<Aant, ,iaRed,,{n
r6a.' )!qE
0'(sLjc#'0o1, 6.$6oo#4ao! L.f6m\!.u.|.' J6oa6r3r - &qf,,id6o I', r.rl,crE q\, ,,aR? r,.)qo
it6a$&gn 06$ut'r'1{h[ 6J5ioor,8rrr LL,5!rt6.$.r, ]16ogr(gr . J,C-aJ6p I., f$]rtcrj6l'l
t0qAOd'.C(CAC&U J6c)r.j6Cao , g343i6gbo, ?cE ar6d" q\, gros.reoedlao d6
apa3!f,&N
Lgn3o14f r',,
3,n66o t1p3r6odX
3o5al,0.6ot &r.qaoRc
tn.lfir@ ntu 9nnaFJtt;. n,Ej* I lto: N<:47ru.721U, it,ilrr3EJl vwurft{oufl'6A Ad!. ttt. Ot t4, t\;Ati: At6th; r.t !,.|J ;l) 72rffi, ?27i1. r.r't.4ti 12) 2717: wlylt tt oc,tortA.
FPOI'I
: NBG
FAX NO. : 442571
b.r-1,r6,,',,,
tq,,..lr,rlrrr.,1ti-,*.,. ;,.,1,,,
NAT IONAt BANK ()I- GEORGIA
llll15,tr,4"(\,rr..,,a".i;,"I l/t
3/! | 'rorrrtz(r r!lr Thrltsi 0 t05
O0qr, C0r'{tH. .f i,t20 ,"rr,lhn, .l0(,S7;
(,xr..l'xtllh:212,,12 LEG^ | Ct
l)!' fl,rl(5r, r.to@nbg go
fgl 40ti403. 406120 Fd\ 4}6lrtj
Tercx 212,)52 LEGAI. cl
E-matl tnlo@nbg ge
204 'tttx4
/ t. C€.,U / C'- N,t
Jun. 14 2glo 04: f,@tl F
cod.)
20.,'104e4
l" 0..]//( :',)
Ng
lsjuio4gqt rlr gy[s6lror.: &r6n$r5olr
6<,r)q,?,rryClr
brg,r6 qxf o(yxr
ottrJr6b 2ol0 ttqyir L .,Jr!$oh
tr3r6(l:irt
Nu/-0:ld69n Dtc,oq,,b3
\)otin qrit \ltfn.
)t I h,)nfi
3Cl\ygrx!,Vlr'rf 6M,\
o,>3oh 3nil,)1)3ft
qfb
JJO(,3l)boCaoo,
C(rx''O5oqlo oroJotr 3()Og- Jr,,J,b( \UOOo
lrnh g,rfu 11, $no
v
dJqJi' lna0qou0u ac6nr
TBILISI CITY HALL
rJ6m6o
Roao66o,
otilc6o 2010 gq,r,t, ll
,"J6o,aJq,'r,.' q,r .ri<x,u
%6ol,ot,
J'[07-028698
..r'3cmorfurol
y'u *u
66ELJo66or a,,Gcoo,.r{rcaol, *;
baRaaj6"RiaoL, r:oi6o36q,orr
-aqar6oe., r6r"saq"
oo*ut**
9ar+'q't rcr,au'e a$Gc]ado,, 6oa
aolrB.nd'al'cq'o
"aeaa''Ro 76upqo
Jr6o3rtu€olr" qsgoS$rr3rorr
..;d;*;'rTilil:r#:, :ffi
r.ralbo bma&Ir,rqct"r, r6"d0p,
"*u-,"n",IJ,l;;T L****
,3qad,rRd x6tr6?qn
666l,J.d,Oot,
f, U$6oCJ0o tCRAArirfRCaol,
vd,
ilu
oAoodAbodo 16
aJ.f6(!).
6r6fic,
J6erCJ6o
" e-fiA06drt. A'LF.&,., -. I ^r-_ r !
r,)rJ(0J,ltIL. g;t6,)5!
Eliroenu r<JnqJlnal /
-_--
Ir$.t lrgC&-,
aai6oU &rlqaoqg
Criilo .'RJSrda
J. o&qrtn Ot6O.
3"60e$rl,
fJb MZ, A1e, : (+99S 32) .rrr r" _ll'l",'T
ხელშეკრულება
|!,siti,fi rt trl,n,l, ti\d,tir, tril!litJ,t6J|{,JJs
(hi lnr,o,ititslr,; iltOr,sr!o if'l,it,]r{,. 66sr,h,1,160,,1!
V SiAA,JI56J lY.rr|,,f*'61'go[ r,l6Ii!
ll",l.:.:,qa_*.,]' Cl'iJiii,axRo) r
1rc16r,l, 2.t o16i,trn, 20xt
aiIJ,/,nr-,Jd,,1, Jr,,r,O6Jtr)
t iNt?tiUd,:Iq,J]i
(r-[^),
;t-,r, n.v,x",,.,crr,,r, r"r,,rii]o,6it{fl6r
1'riri1
lllI
.,dr,rJnr5r,'ititr,,t!,,an., it"n,(,irrt,"tr ir,it\'ri1t,:
I ,t,,il r,at,;y'{)., fiA.,t,t|{r, f,6.\t,t,n1,r,I)!,1,,,1,i1,.,.\t,(j,.,-r})rdtr,t, tn!,trl,ilr,u\
Il .r,:1,1,,'t, r",,, J,lll,,,,rr,Xr r, Jr,. rl,-fr. :,i.\t,ii ir..r,r,.,.
lll .t, ,ir h,,tj, ,,,. rrn!,trr..lr,,t, it.,r,,",t,,tr ir.Ll,'i.r r,;t,.
,
r,
ila.rtnrl,66.\l;il,,rll,,
ilJili6ol,ito
f,'l,..il1,,il,llr1a Itr,\ .dr .,t.,t,r'-t,.,t, l,:;l.rx,,t(itl -,,,J aiR,!,r,',itl{,a,11,1t). l\DA l,
ti,{: r!\.Fno: r{r r:ti_iLr,l,
(itir.rnE,ii t! iritfi.hrr,
*
iljtt,$,,;r,tr!, it..,lr,.it,6.\
r,ji{.iti,,ln.,'l(,n!,r,,h{,.,il{
.IHrtur iLn,rlrllr\ t,.ni:xntr1.{r0 r.,ri,linrn! !i".r,r,inLrdi,r, ,,,j!\:r..
e.",i.6bi.;$ SF-
t,iE, (ik,r, lirit
r,o< . __
\'1 6.
''.-'r, ;\..r,r"{.i,r1,!r!
q.4.-nl)
rrll
rni,tsr, ..lflrit,}l,
(rat
a
r ri,d.li
ri,,rrr,1n(, ,.tirr,:r!, ii ,trr
r'!!r'frr"r\'(rr'
x]rl,r".r'r"l rL\rrrqrri{i r"!rr ,r,.(l,rir, ,r, ir"lt,,,it q,iri,.r r,t \\ 100:t!t,r, \It
x,\,,Fir\irlo .r,n,ri r: \.,!lr(! r,6!r,rln&, .\orr i,t,
rilc,rrr,t$!3q0iltl6l tr Jirrxaio
:nnFAi}}l q..) r{ jrtrRr}crr
IY-
d',(;
lr.f)i:.llil,
I_6\'ilr' 'l'
r | .,-rr.N,,r r .l Lro$r!,
i Ri ir \. {.,
'
I' rr,rt rl (
\rnt.,, !\J-rrdr..\rl. pfr r, r..
,t.i.-tri,,i rrlir,,r!,
drlq.x\n!
.it
!,
.ir"x",rt,{-jir..\", rl" .I li..prf!L 'nilLs6il,li L,t'xl,r.. r,:nrlr[f,..lr,rii\r ,
l {-l
.r r
liir r,r(rr,il, i ix
',i|*l,1jrri,j[,rid!n
ilrL'r4 l , \il'lin! 16,f,ir\ol, l.\t,r{,ir!il.r,iarn,
lI.,r\tl ,r,rtDr,iiLtt ,(,
nf rtrqrvr qp4rl;\i#. rhf,ilFr, r.{hl!
n,r r\I.rr"irrlr',r, :Lrr' I i,iiETnr,. t,$irrii:r,nr,q, {[ ,,[i., \,.rp\{!q(
rlt:r,,;\:Frd rr4FaJtt,..., r,tt.t, tr,,[{4ir,*l+,t, rtir,;E-F, t,:i{n, iri.f/,t.
.t.,1..Lr.i. I..;rr-l(rrr
i!{iir, ! rF-,1.{'
l,y'n,l irh,!\.)tnt r, , _.t,t.tr! :o,N_ji!,t,
'(1i. :!n;iirrf{
lr,'jr rrljl irr
{Iin!\ itrt!.\t1rit,i tt,rrrjr n
,..irrrlr.iAi
iht..fnr,e,n {i6rrl:Fr,r, irirlt d\i odrnr,itid{ (..l|hri!"xf,!r,n iurqjs
.ra'nr jJrJ, r)6xr,l\\ !,,) rirrl { }rtt|Il Jtrri,ll
r r..|f4'ithjs, rrr{*rrar,
trit!.(oIniE_i trlr.i,lt ;rjJ n,_i
^lxt.t,r,:1* lpr,x.
\',,r$1.\-.6. rrR , t.!.,rh- r.i1f}
rr, L.h6Ditirl,lq:r Prr .jy'+$ tr\,,1i t! ,vru t,,i.[ ,r;p r,t,lt.J('
rr, lrrlrr. i/io.r.
i}'{a. lrJ:, .!.tr.r,
hjf\Irhfr nf!
{i.,( !r..,,irikrixn,,B, i
:r.,!{-i$r!r.rr
(.rr Fn
a",xsl$n6xr[ pEI-,l| \linJ\ ,hi, r\, r.fi6 aj]\J,
^DB
il{q..*rdr.rA
(rr it:}l La:rr:iiF kntJlt L [ill.ita/,!oxrj,.\r,
Prn.,rir".st{,.
iri'tr.nM:i,.r::a Bf6il,t,,,,r4,.\ !ti,t, !{,j,ir\.i:rIl
ilt l;,]x:lii:#.l1l.,rlt !,,,i.6i +',in,
ihri J! .'itir,n. itr,trl.:'!n,
,,1,-r@ <,liiA+\I, F! i.,,1RJI,
sr\r-
..,,.,.r,,
ij.6oir^
\.
, ll,i:ll;:{}.1;5;1p,'i.l':'.:,;,t'}.H'i:}:;1)t1u,,,,.,.
V
t5t ilfi,r(rltliflht, ,,r,
,raatr,t,ril.J{t, irirt,r,-.|iq1.\it(,,r,
r, .r.."il,nalih{- t.tit r sl{..f (F,r"n.hti;ii,.
16r I ii(, jr..u.i,r{.ii,.lt ,r,.rr,:r\.t, ,r.|ll.
ir a,i,l*lrr,l, (,r(,. l\r-f,rr\.-
,h trrlri,,,. (,,. t,.,4",[,
.,. r,L{r1,-r|qr
,t, rL _' J'ritrlr,r ,r-,r +r,\,,[tr!-, n,.r.r.n,x" rr$,
x;\,rf,.4x rL.tr.,f6irh'ir,,-i!,,r.,,/,r!;r\irxt-
r A:.jrt",rr',i"x.,.-irr,,r.
r.!,.d',Frrji, .ri ;Ln ,, '.'r" l,iArlrn (yf.hL,irtrff,nt ,l,rin JirrI.,i[1 n oiH;]n
. .1,n,.,r1jl, r-L,r,r,:ijA[ xrl \rri .1ir,.Lr{ir{:,,,N,ir\ja{ l, .a-r{r,
,.!-xk,Ir,[ r+r(i;]a-r]raoJ, r otr,rr ilir;r.iNr+it\r- f.<"r!,, r, {D[r,
oqn.'xr!:,, lxl,r,(, r .x,r.l,l,xrtrd jlxr ic(,,rklL f,rilt|*rr,l,,l,rin(,n
!,, irjtl r',,,r,rlr
Pjln-o (.r-,),r,r!!, L)r, r,r,r,
!,.td'r,r}i\" r ! ,"1"r, .,.r,ir ia,.1..r,. rl, i,.\ riti,r, -tr( ilo,r:,..i,.jrr
!.-.,.(. f"L {.r.+!'n:r.iF1 1l, ir 'ri,l,t rrJ.,lli rii lirx.l:rrJ,
rr!.irr{, F(,1!till'rr',r, r,. itotr, rr,-rllitx,fi ryrnr,|ftfi.xar,,
ir,ir r,tiir.
i rr, \r!,i1,, d,iailrinrU ADlr iir{,|,-,iln :r}iit PFR.dJi lri,n,".
rrir;h! ilri r: {.rli'ixriir^itr1r, .i},:rr tl,{-l'
r\q.ii n!
lxrJ [r.i r ir{ 'rx,f, ihll,$n rr. .l,dr n ,r,i{,i,ii! ,
',
(jr.\
\lrli 1,,,.i.r'!lL r,'}-[:ri.iri, F,,,rrLr,,..,ri, i,!,r,:rirorrx r,-, i,,
r,:h .d ,r. J.l6 iq rr'r,r, ,iiirr,/.:r, ..r,"-.5r|!r", (d.ririii,, rrnriNl,
J, xrr,riq.rr,r, rol",r,iill!\ .ni\{.:11.{r .:a",!r'iir,r,, rJr,jt6 ri,,rd,ll)r(i,
rio tinii 16 r,!riiirr(,arr 6!,.f,rr r,rJ.iA a,rhr\rrr\i .1rj"r
n: .1s'r6.a{ .r,f,r.{.}Fns f";\-n! rr.lr,.rtr ,}:}.( rr.."r, ir
r,
"r/4.:r
li i (! hxl,ril{'xol,. r\Y|<t,i,.r ;lil+.r!l ,l| rin]'q nr'D i]x (lrtr.'inr
i\..1,1{41,:rrh .iriJrn{! l)Il.h'|, ,r{,1,.''i}' nrl,iElq1,,.n t f$'h J;i\,;r.\
r: .{r,ur,L i}dra.ri\;r, ,}rri}. ln iF trnll{ r,.y',r,or,i,x!r,. T}.(,*riFo
.,Jil.r:lxr l,\irrrs,J1.' ri.*.-.!ritl{o hJl,}.,L .\Jl. n'{ .'rx,:F!J, ,(i|.'6u,1)
ixr,.i^\rn,!. ;h+,r,,rxr.n tr,r.r,,{xlni,r\r, !,:r}.{.rr.Nn rJjit\irr.
l:!l.ri!,r,ir,, s, i6 jrklx.nn, il.t,;rt,.r\,. !,,,rir,cr(r,lr!,itr r,i[,,ririir,o
.ti!$.rtr6ist s i?il]:iilt, rir,iirr e,\ ,l,J $ll,l',r'.\, il,,ul Ll,ir,
rr.-ir.idrr"r\.n, [i.F,r,J.i r.l!.!il4$ ,r,rr,t\inL ir{\is,\. ,rn{jrhiklr!
r(<Ei,F :rri{llln jPA. f . nh. Iv-,+\,
lrie.'e*aJ[*4,
:\ r, qsnv.,,r].i tr1$h(:+, i: r-*r.Dri !r.ril1lr,r/,I!:n r\.+{r'-:L!{,.n'
r,l( r1 ir,,r!\li\..ii[,r.,",\i,r,a(,,
irrt..r,,r, ,r, .r r.1lar,Jr\nr,
ir,rJ..r,,n, ,r, rq,1-n,,,t,. {" rr ifi!,(,,Dd/Jr.\i,t, toriil,ln jr^
,/r,ri,r! rr!r:f\,r, r!r1d,xl1.l.i..
,trr 6r,jll,:r\,r. lilr.xr
.Filr 6+L \.i F rh.f{,I"d, .}n I trrt,
itrti?r@n-ilrr'r, rrnllrr:rl.l|1ri F.r t,,rt[{.f4
r\n(,llctr arldn,,Fl{noo.l,
a
r,ri\6o t
{r\lrEr:!rIl,r, ir!.nnirq ;FA..f,irq{ On^6r.kri6r[ {i,ENi,jirqrl, .hrlddna,
i
r
l!0i'sdj[,riq!,
L. f
tri6r\r,i
,!..ur..
'.1
L ror' It..,,r.,",,,1.
^ h.,:h}lr\qo iirr\
l.
lo}) !(-|,.!-N"G l.,+r!'i[nj:f,i" n<'.1r'L r nvrd'tl'r6ara [olilrit'
5
1",1..6.r:HA...r' jri,r"r,,N l,\'r'.r,l.i,na." l'jrli"m_"i r"- ,"1'rliix$-''
r,',r.! i.I.i !, rr,.rilx'r,lEri
ntt tiN,t tl'i,lt. .il\rlah
,t ) !., l\rh lr..yti$t,un
Ltr /L\Lt 9 tn h ; L.ttrttx..
JJ4
'r.r-
'rLIi,r'
t! t r',t)
Lr,,tnLl t1_l
f\,_,t, t\,,,t,t
, r,._o., I .4'rtt
.
2
h
thtt\\
h\t
,t, i,^!t, rJJl
v, x1,r'i,7r<i
.,r
t(t.\Giqrr 6a\6l!)F66o[ a!fu,nrirt\,! :]E1tu
(,) rt,i!rH rr n., r, r",.lirrr,,
!i,ratrrr ri,,f!\.,,\"x, ( :rirr*,
'llilli.sl';:,,r,.'i:'::,:r:,,:i.:,i.,,i,:.rt:;."'l;.:,ir
_l.iill,: ,l;ir",,,.lrl:,; ,ll;;",.,,,,
:rri!e&r!'r.n.n lEilljirxF, ilarili
I
L",1i!r,r.!rr . l.r',rx il.f ,1, ,., 1 rl,,r!'
iro,r idtr,1l()x,lr. r, r1r ,,r rirArJr, ,L11:.irr, irn,ii xi.r, r,,,. : r.l-i0r5 \(.rrn, rf,i.ir,,r 4irtL
ir,.U-|,.\ir\. r\\,rr.lriirx-'..G. l,.nE,lris{i r,r\:L ilxl,r,kl,.'" :o-'rl tx(1, ,\trrai!r,x!r*rr
,,t,r,rsx.(!n", r, - :or.t._ir)tr \il,ll1ii i,lir\i.l'Ur I.il 'n(in,.l \r! Lii,r.,ritn,jll"(t{
r4aHr')xr,!:r!, ird..\4rx +{r\ ,,, .rai, r(.,rr! J, nr,,.,1,1x,r1,4, -tt.", ,r.(",t! l,(:r,!,t, ,,j}{, t,
.,+ilrJ,..,ir .i.n nr\,lL;rJ r! rrn,' ri.,rtr.:F{"n, :r,!*n!!"),. rr ,r..jl!ttir,}\h!,
il r ryir,h{a :r o
,1 rr,,..1,r ,1 ".xrl,r{"]ir"-, ,t',|rlJ,i,, r,,i.lr{,ri ilir'ril,
r
L.*r}|<!.a.*,..r, L-ra#r5
0
F J r.rr..,'l",".r\:.1.,/{:
r,.
ur\ L^r\ir',,r, r,,xa,'f-1. r.,,(.,r ((t,.rr,,,t.
,'iii.iir !.}\,8,,
.(it,i/,,r,!, t! i r., iii, ,, ,
',r
(') r ,i,,,, .tr
r!,'i1,1",! !,il,rt,
(,
i,"r"i,11rli, '!
I r \1r,.iir,.i"r
/!,xl/,.,f-l
r
,, r, rarr-I.ixir,
(ii) r.. r""r,\r,,!r"n,, ,/i, r,r !(,,,,i ,tia.\;|r,, i,r,n1,ltrin ,rnnroxr,,r$ r,. L,rrl,iT
,1n.ir ".,r,J,!,lt irxl, il+n.r".
.lli;!Iil, rirl\1.,.i,ln,irrn rr,..
'.r,1*,'?n,,(
'"
r,l,,l!"rn,,r. Iil l^,rrijrwi,,ri r\.r ,4...,r,
!.ri(iE r!.rn!.1../,$-L ,ir,jrrri.1,Fr.,, iir.r,L
ir.!ir lllil\r 6.rrr,lhl xriD{'Ii r{i{irr{i rrl 4:ir\ir{s, .n,1r,.},!nr.r-y'i ,cd.,,.j,-,
ralrr.rli,,r
I r,l,:.ir!., tnr)rr,
:iri,lirfu:r x!!,t' rhi!jr ;,li r.ii\ r,,\
iL.r4s;ni.,\.irL,|s4i ;rrrl,_n,rn,iinrL .',,r'ntu{,r\ r\
(ir) lllf,rre.1":'I!,r. f,6rtslt,i,rr. *.. x.<oil.! -..r\oxr,jt.,}n'. Lr".f rr.a, !.N|rri]nr,
_n.,q! fl!r.i,o.r,r, rilnlr\Jr.1,. (\ i:r1, ,rlrlror;rliL "r,\,.1" t,,l(riilir.,,,
('v) !,,,:!'rJ nrr,r,\ir!.ri i,r,{,t,Lict,i !n,r!r, xdd,riir:! .rnr,; i,}rr, ,!irirr)}i,
.r'dk:'.\rr r.F1J.an li 'rri/41, uL,ti<r&i$ (\ l, ili {,:i,n,\ _r!trdi6. ,,r,
:rinilr..rri, iirlit {rr,:rlla,i,}i. dErrira,{r +nrfs{tit,l{li
rr"i\ (r
trn.
JtirH ltti. [\+r!rifl+!,tt,l..iLr ,.tn tt
loa.'Ji!ea.xo'\6l!iihlJliE.:Mt&:irI,]1r.6rrrLur,!".tlt/i"i,,i/(|.li,.I'l|t
|,riiflri )nrriif,.li il.r'.1,(,r n'r(,ori^r *:!'ri) ,riro. ]ii\'r,f,l! L .xrldn
x;r'\r..:ri, ,t{"..|}r,r,
{r} r,.1r"' ,l'j|(,'r'
,1r'j.,o r, .r rr:trdi}rr, lq-,t,,|, (.r.rir, liaia nt,h&r,
r !11 r t,tr-.r, ,..,',
r, .r,.. ,.!fr'p n" t.,l\!t,}\.r,r.n'Ld,,1r,xiE]irtlr{rrrrrJ !r.Fr.L i!r*r rur!,*ri\,r!
"-il..q{,.nru
r,,n, rt(,r&k,.
ninr,Ridr
ilr,,\ailinir{,r.,r!
ikrl'l!{iiu,!1,!, Ljr{il'lr)Iitqrrl, iFinFS,,f,J.\,,,,x,'1itt,ir;t il{dkTf"rl! i,itl)$.\idlrry, l'\'6-.,jt,,.
n,$.*,, rhr.,,r!3if{(r, a.y',,1, ir},riir rr.!n.1!":}rri$i, r)di,nirlrrn6.t, tt,,t,J!,ti
(i) r
()
riilt,rF x!-rx?-
rl.. -,[r"rtr,,lr- - .l|lf'nrltr,tr i,,,,hn r,.1r!,l,rr,J, Lrl,ix (!,,,11
!..|lir,jrrr riror{irrlir\\ J.{.,},r, r:rA1iii,r, ir,rri,..rrii.Fi
a,rr.,.rn,.!,rn r,,,n, .xrr,+r
(v)
,kri nrl,.l r+!n,.
.d,;L.r'r{di,r.ji,.t!lo ll.ii6.n,lr r',;ap 1,..i},1$Tiixr" jl.l-,.i1,'L r ttrdnri ir,!i..,,r,t,,1 L
,:|!l',Tit..(- ln'|l,ji,rl li,* +t{w a\i, rrl.if.lr\rl, (r',1-1,\ (,\ ,r,r!l,i,{,r(1,
'jirrF{r.rril,r,,..ri\,.,.1.rr
r,.\rr.q,iiid,,1+rr/'rror r\iiihs,mrt.t, ir,nri(i
irr,,-,it,,f,.i
r
l!J(ri,ri!s, i\rh itE,.r6 p.r,t.\ilioriuliren 6iftrii<,irr
.,x[
t:0r
i\r31,
L h)
,rf t,,,:1t,fill,,.:iJi:i:::;:;lx,:
xlnjr fl]l,.ni :r.n{.iDq,_r., _!,r.
;1,rtlf.. r,. .0xlR"1r .rixr.
,ta:..:.tr,
15
.r,t-r q
Liih\<$:rq.n^r- :r$a,n i,,,r !,,1\1ii/, q,
6,!,ltrr,
n:r, i, [
,i\,i,ii4
'j.jl
n.orlr,r,{d r.\-(i(,
I(,FFiri,l, r.r. rri lij r"i i6 !,IiiiiL l[,,'r,
r .xrT, +.r ili ,.n n,{in.ltr., .1\rN,.rr.}11, i\."t,rnir5;Fl, .lir{::,jFi,injlu
[:A,.l,.qtli.!1uilI,:.1..;|li'S.|..lliinL.I,..
tt
,iFn,i r,rAilo ilrr,,.ir. i[,L, i1,{,iir,rrrr4 r,$6,JJ, ri".,a, , t,i;r'Jir,lrirri,t,
i\irsnahrl(:n, .il!tr\rr{,u frD)!r\, i,Ii r!..,ilnr-|,,a- i}inli{*ll(n .\.' .rn,L, ii!,,1,a, l.!r..1.'t,
Irrirrrll+.sr, ,r,r r\,Ir".,x"\i i.ir ,,.,i|' r,iirl{r.-. ,,t,ir"" r,ld..a,, r!".re,. ilr!''r-i{4,rjr,.,r
:r.t,r,i ,r.q,. .r,r,. :jr.!,r xi:|l.fis,,1\. 6.ljl(!r, .i r*,ii6xjFrlf .i.rt, ,rjin.|lri (rr 4tr1",i'.i'
rriir,tr.l\y ri'r^n j:!, r r.!,rr,r,i(.rz ,
r....r.:r ,.'il, {, (').tr.,.J,,t, ,1r;Irtr,i &r\ (,1
't.i,.1,,
dq.'l'll\.,l'lr-,xlr,,.,.i'P.
tri$iul, .lhill{!i,n, ir.,iL,N,l!: ",F,
I r'i.,iriui\,;r! ix! t, ni,nr)I,!,,ril
,\(,l,iy',6r1u:rx.tr J.i,iqrr, l\il4,.l (L,ir..11{ &rrfiiy'i,n rr ,rrriri!,r,xri,l(!, ilraorrdr(i
r\.06ilir!r,(io!
r"i[r,irxra-r*rn,. t..rrf,!r,+rrnri
ir{iit\.,|i\i r!-,,
r\i4r.r,i,n{r1 ,I,jll4r, ltor' ir,rEl.i|A\ iHdF,r, tr'i:/ir({ Lir,nt, rrr,i,n{ | r/!\Nriu,!,
,.l,jiH l!.irkr'rDr, :\ijf\!i'r xl4,rrn" $,.l|1,!:irirjr{ .'.qrir,.rL.,lt.,r.li lt,.r"ittr{, iui $(,fllL_
;|.,h!.;Fl4lll.,l".(".1l,1!rl(f;ln,]\n^.'i'J[!\ldtjd.'l$.H(.
LRT !$ BRT rr.;N7!.,rq,1! 6,r'l,L{rrh n!,rlir
i\r"\'t!|lll4!j'\,11,
il,n,.!l,Jn,.r" l\.l,,nrr
irin64 l!-q,,fitr''ir\nl) l"d(l,L,,lLr ,,,, 1r'irl,,kri,jy'o rrn,ft6a\{,anrli
$rrl}.|1lttf.r.:Aq ?riirn,\irJr,:,r-(.4. liil, .r.,nr{4 t{,ii.,lr , tr..1r(nt, !r,.;il,.rD, l!ii'riio
r^ ..lJin:Rr) h\[!r'r,L, jrr, ipirlxri ini}r{rirt[,fr[ ..|r s6.jr::a, i\ia,xntrw)riDt! ir,{uirs
r, .x, Air!, r,,ir ,,r^(l,r-r, r,.:r i:t.!r,r\-|!\sl..rxLI\ r. i 1: .r/ih r,.rh.{il. rirr..xr.
L ;..irnr,r,
,r,:rirrr,rlrlrr r" I r,6-
-
13 "rI"q(I,r,, 1'1q1,{nrlj|\!,( A.n,l!..,troiiFc,
,.F:d,ill. r,r.rd'sr,r, trf{,,o
i.r,ioir.ii. irr r.n,\.ki,-aidl, sr{i,,r,;d, ri,r,4r,\.r
rhl,rat"r,,l' :ri r/'l,ii"h
5:xr{nl|q\\ :BiE:! [r a.lrnF {L
}rlr:|l6rri}\},
'r,ilFhqjiir{
..Ll<r irx"rlli!r,orh.!.r. irjr+{a. n\t o6r,rhw.'irr4),r, Inrrlir-tr
irJ.,r4r\nt ,tr1{:r!uitrl,
.1,.r$rir,,,riFrt n^nirrni, rj,ii{r, niiq{rnr, il r,nJ;ra llr,\ti1I5' ri(,trt,,\(6dtii!,tt nl,plD 1,-,!1,t,
d\r il\.iktliy',;ir! r,ri rHllir\ti::{r\,ir (,.f,,lir,t$ (,t \sr!:!{,if!
1S
nir.p, t,I Lr.,.rr!,
a6,hRr.ts i ril\ i;r.i .,lllllllortnrt rirr1r,ft .!r'l,;iri{4 h r,,r,rri\1ir, ohrqrrln\rnflhrrrr
.Ffl,1Et{! llr r}r,:r,:itrrl. l\.rqr& !. ".lr,i,!,iH r.Lr.rtL\Jrsr4r,lwir[,,.|hji,.
n,r..,innil{q" p.
&n{r\irh r$1( .ir,\ir'rv.x'r. rs\\'tl,/6{.n $,h
:r.ilrr,rrva"r- ilxl.!lg,\{. ".,
,n,irq, nqrirttrn,.,iira,r ..ta(r,L.,n{{ ,]rtr"ah"l,
^.i!iraA#lr\r
ri.;},rl"a. ra\,.. fiitilR.\r
,il.nr!6n\
!r
r6ri\r,, rrr,.rr.f3
.rrrr{.,arh r'!\,r.ri t:F\[
.i].i/,16..115
llitLtt*iiiiir$ ,,1,.rr,
i],,.r,
t.gnnnrr,,i,rr" ir r.!.4-r iJtld.irit,$
:1..Aldr'li F,\t6sid&1,... 6riljx:,r | ".Dt.,,, it,,rs..,.rh{,rrr."rrr
l
i!
.tr4r,$oJ,\ (i rirSn,nilJAr
I 0Glll}.6i0n[,*]iro 6fi|ll.Ur
,
)^,. r,l i (,'j,,
l-l\,,'rdr,'.irir
r nt i'r i
lxl,.,'|lr('1'lll,
L'r.r1,,,] ! ijl\,r,, r r.rar
2 ${l\f,r,i/,{ nJL.JFJ}!S'aia{,
of'r,rnr/ar|6r. lL r,ri'ir"\:,r, r"i l.",r,iHl$,{r-, },,i,1i|],,,r, en'fl,,6ir,Liir.:.\, t,..luh"i
!ri|1rI1,4:iid!,r
'x,rAnn',/rr,!!q.\"i!rrrrEnr:ri,l' rir.l1ii,!i*!,r.rLilr,tE,,l,i
.rr, r ,i,ririrrli!{ rtr,s
r,.rx'r+Ll.f\!J,4,:r.r, ,r)r!.{l-jrrn1.l, r,rx.
r !,n\r6 rirl,r,
,rf,6i 'idr)l{"ar,rr L
2{
r)o !)ri r,r,ki.1!r,t I r,r,rlrln!,t!
25 ar"rr'(!,",,,,, ,1,[r.nr"r""r, rll
! rlx, ,L,r,.xi$,, i1]11nr.!1-E rr l,,t('rn./i ri]r'r,.r/. t!
if{,. ,,,x.r.7,. , r../,_r,,trr,rt ,rr ,, \iJr
!;r"lr!-i ,ti,,,.e&l,I,LjlANi rr.r.,r I rl
.ir lil xr, l. \,l<l! r.|li Lr h'di,E, q!,/iifli(,,r'i,tL
ri{(:a!v",r r,7,rr. lrrrr 'ir.l-,")..r,nr, j{6ilir,ii/rr{n .8i..\.xiH(ii!{,}\}1! ,, !,ir'in,
.1{r.i|}i{ii|t|r !\.,,.ii,Ii l,rr,riIn.r, r,..r.x]6 ni: rlv) {,,.uri,ir\ r..a(!rr, .r.6,!!r,tr{
,ri{riririir+,r, iii},tirrrji,li}, (vr R.,rrr.<i:+. r,\rf.1,rt t, r, liti{1ijf\dr irr i]rf,,. lr.ntyt.
r ifiqr"nir,,,,,
r r.i,r,r,irljr
r,.rl,11r',r. {
'rr".rrr.r, ,r(1r.[r,L
,t.r,l,,l{.r:rr",l, lJ,x"{qrijfi,
,
r,,rir,.Yrr,r6J?$
{\ I r,x.,
,l ?ilsaera<-llEs itJ<.,Jiriai Cit{.r4narro qs il6i*.66Je,
2tr .frr,"16i(,, i.x6r\1r',x,h:/,j,/,,,r.- r". r.i,,r,f.i r. \ r,.,rsr, .i.rr,{-,I:inr, \r,tir!.,r,
rd!iriFl.ri. n:ir. ixi(jiir!,
i..r.,ir,r,,f,r,id{riir.
+rri{riiai(,iiilr4 *\r,rr./rrr,, n. *, r,\'iirl{. ,r, r,.1,6(lnxri .ir rnjrir(irrro i,,r,}ii r,: r,aii,ii i
r
r,!J,ri,.n, r.r,r[rn, dlorr,rLi f. n r. r,xr:xtq
61 ijirta!.D t,.rAr( i
!,r!jr,.,r,.rrd,..rk,r,n{r,
r.,iy'o4jF*rro \r rs"/,nrt,,r, xrr, ri!.t! r
ir.rr-rEji{ir\j , I 1., J,lr'tr rrr'
27 odi.)(,r, ia.n!r, xli.',o pr, r,{"rc,:rlt,.l1rrrL k1il!.r,.y3l1ir1r rill\,r,to,4jr,,,r, t,..l,r',,nn,
irirl, rrrjdraar.nn,. A\rTr:r'ir!.1', rr1, rlrrxt, itrilF-r1t, tr) t!r,.,ii pu,f!6,,r,
rr,nn,"{1r,r, -r,:f-, h..irr.r,.rrri ! ?),}{,i .ia\s[ (rf,]!{r ,,,rr.. }i.( r,ii{.ri,J, .rG4xrt-i(
I rr,r,n\r.,r: 0r) irxr,.n.i[ir irrLrr,'..aaarrirrl,,
,
ll'd',J'klxiir\".l.4,It.il;l.rltlr.('l.
xr'iiL$)r6|rlJl('r+nl.lu).rr|i.rijr\]iinl'.'l,I*J\l/.hlt$'ltgJ'j
({ i r..i'J(,\Fon ,tra El,,r,. r" /n,,r/..,hq- .r t,i,,j'i:rEl.x'!xrl, r\!njlt],{, ri{r l.\li ,1,t, (,.,r,,p
r,,"lit ,f,\ .n,i\/i,t l.ii! \a(i, r!il.,.r-J\.{ts J.6r!\r,riri'i'jro, nt,rx|]r irirxr4 l,;r"r,n,ri
.F{,t J l.x .I,!,rrl., {,:r', ;t'
1,,
,lrihuol.')l!n.
onr\q!tro,x,ir,-Ustir,'!l,r't.rrJi
?010 ?n1! 20rr 2015 ?016.?010
!il, 'riqo ]
(Li.l.r.4oli!.tcy ittir,{n, ,-l4r,[iq,i, 6,4i,,l,I.,6o.rtL r.)r,iF-,.idi!t, ri,ra6n3ir
ri.!,firrr6!rr{i,Fnand.iLn, r,i.}\r.yrai\,tr rj ir,/i6q.r,r,lii\ol, t1116at611.)
I
(-:!h,r, i,'a:,h.1,
rr.'r"6rFi{.IA"r'
xur,r,rLr,rr,.|:r..i$.rr,
.AtL/'i.,!+-n,r!r
.: , \.u-,,.r ,rr, r,.1,,,r
'rdrs nid il:i!,,l,iqloin,
!.^f irr,jy'inll,rir\.n, |l,ir,
qirallri
r,n,.6;t $s,
,llilfrr
'r,:tr\r.hini
r,l4.Yr,4R.[ r.i'n/,jrkr,
d{rxli.rr,.E, r. r,IHi{.r
,i.,,rrf,(.\{.A,1. x1.r!
irrrLr,.jlal^iil. n,ir:4i|;rr.
r0lll [!r r,io,rol,
f,rrtlt,i,.\rr,, l.!;riir,i rir) \' 1rn. rr" irn-,
[rR.]rn,,,\'J((ri,
'r,.
l(f,ir l;rq
'!r!ii.
r".*ir,,,,trlttr!tirx,,
, rrr! r, r1,
r, ijrj,,,. Ihrl!,
I.':i .E,,
tr
I n,ir d.x.r i.
i:::,.) t.:ii:.::r ' +". i ',r'.,,--*,r,"
.,,,.,,,....ir,,.,,,i :;,",.,*.. l "',""'.,
I
r4, \-':,, r. ).r ,
..
," r,,?ir..r1 tr I,, r. I I
f itr. u!,i',ll -ty',i!.r rr..{,ir rn, :r
r:(.ql
ri.t,rsr,t-L i6d,, I r,1,r,l!
ir,1,,'{rn.,slrotr
jx'r l, iror,
oii!*nL xji16.n$ !., \
.'r(r! iirrrj r ,r'iri Iiirr'
x,,r\.)!,,1, I'l .ir ri,,5.1,r
'r,
n.,r..\n,!.x .1{,..,tir, :|lrl
l\.:rAr"rErii.", rr{.-,,r1
r!..iri:r rtiir,jfln ,t lin,
ihr,,.r,i|!rrrh J.(!l,n *.
il\ir.,t! r,!, ir0Dlritnrlrl,
l**"'l'.'
I ri,l.i. r.n'. ..4rr{i
. r,,., .,..nL .dt r,_a\rii.
,.,r i' I ,. i.,., I
ltietr
,1r.
r, L_,
t!.xrin,
ri
i;t,t{ri'x'{,\rts
E'. [EL-$',-__--T--nr6
I
I
( !ti.f I rr.ir,, (,!a,..!,r,j,tl
:IjJI.l1.ix l |,'.|, ,d4II
'J'
,,|.,.\,,l.Ir',n,.,1,1.i'l'''1,
:l"r,.t!r( +.{..,1,+ x:f!
fJri''!,'r,. r,,
llr'r.rA"i1,,
!'\ l,s,tiill\,1
i.!{,
it tY,, rI,...[.
;
r,...'.'.fr..r..
! F!.r
.rlq ;|i rcr\ i.tliN.. Jrq1,
f.
t__
I
l,rrr',.,,.
i,iiri\!,!i
i,6 r,t ri iir,j,t,
i nl,!''jll,l},
. .i|lJia\.d4
r!..".i.jrx,{:ir :r,.rrr irur,,ri,
lilllilu.uaqir:r _...,
rr,rlr,rrr,r,,r r,,
,l:rr{
.l.e J !11'L.r
.r!{,\rir,,/e xJ,x\ ri/{n(
.|!r{i Hri,i.i |{., L'r'.lrt!.
r!-i r4lr1,21\tkr'll| ir.v ir]tix
l-ln!'l.l('f ,T . n, q-',,
I J"eJo6i6Oo
.
.
. irQr.tl'i|<lt 6r/,.nJll#6!,t, t,6i|lin66 hnri,L a.#h",r riA
Y'n:I*',!'l' Ar),!r.:fl{ (",!rnr. I O i'i[,[ l-.|,-rl,L,' I${ ililf,..tllrrln
iflrh,f''r',',tr('ir, l.I.i;D iMD[ IrrNf,(,r r]jrn,trr'n1ll!'irixlir\,h
,ilx,.ii',1'L(. {-,r.rrq ill
i'{,, ror qrr.trriri}\u, i6d.,;r!!!i
!,r,"/,.1,r1l,,irli,,,t
l. .i uiir'.i r\()l iLr,\i{,r i[l
. rl,riitiir,ll.n"'ilJl,x. "rr"\ (... it,\D(-',,rqr i6 a.[! l\rl, ,r,r,r\4-I
iri{x,ri}LIl.i11it \ii.'N;,i\aidR.,rrn
Tl 85 qi,
! F{,.i{ (.1lit1
ir,,
.
i,il,r":rr{.fi,
1,,',,,i,,, ir:,rr,iriir r, l1l,lt,
l|'d'Ir|i.L[,lix!.\!l,llii,.\l.ll]|il-ll].
,rl r\,r ,. , rr'1,{ jr,,r,
f Jr r, !,1, r,'. r- r,1'/, :r!,,r'vtn,r r, \,$ | ll1,.r.,'.\!,,rrii,.r,,l
i al.hiir,:i,,r.
!i( d.r(1ci-.rIr,r,..{ irr (sx) r"r,!,,r,-.1
! \.rr.riirn{-ir,"rrrrr.x,,"{r,!ir,f!\,,r\t,1,,.r,,rx,\n)t
,r,i,
rJ!!r!,h!r'.,.,h,,r.r,. r\..i,r"r11!|lj,!,
f,,e,,l
t
r", l,!'r' rl,, q.rd, ti,r,,.,r!,. ijr: ri.r,rt,t, t, tt ir l,,na ix,r.{Jrr,rr,l
xul, r-,ir"r, r: ",rr (\ll, rn, \,,r-r ri,,,,,rL{"rr,r\r!,,
I a,\,ri,r,,,?!,ir(r,,rrr,i\,,r\ r,. rir,l,it,!r,,,,1, /,
,r, rIr'1r, ,ltrll,,r, rrlir \'rrir.rr"x l\ rt r,,\!!,Irrr",!I!r,1iIri)r,r,,,)
. ,jri.}\.r|l:a,. !,.r l,cx.i,lt.i](" s.. .lrr,.l,,,n
,i,.jri \r i,.i rrk, rr,. dr d.n r\r
:tr."..\,{.rr xirr,i,,:rr (\,iri,jr',
! \'rlf'il'4rr{ nL.:, ilrliti(Jltri rtr.. il!'\i {,1)^rBrr, !1, d irr rNtn, iir i .\ilrx
+rr.!( r8s1,$,trr, xf .r,tr,r,{.jr"ll
2 .,ttlrl"OicrJl1n n Lir!:iaqn}ra.$ nilrlrrri\! nsI|,r
'
r ,iu.i n fn r,sr.,r,i6t!ni,(.rr irrll,.o,i,,,l, t()r,\inN,JR,
!tr,in,rnlt
rJ,itno,.r,rnl r: /rfi {\lt)r, ni4l:lrt(t, ily'({r,rr,qrnrxd,rl
I i Frf r.r",j!i 1{,f.r1,.r x-i"ri.rk.,r,.(,"rir \nr-.r L.r!,x.l1.,;,r,\. t:o.r.l
rs ._:n rai..tic.r
,
!
r6ia6irlnrr il.ylorrt rrb.n r,i(r,n
rl,."rrdo,r,r,Jr,,t, h,,i(rniqiir\ltd(1, Li, L ,lxr4 . lirx rtlrx r(G:\r\rljr
ilili\r .i!1nr\rkrifr,t
!
.
lr1:rii$ l|, ,,.,tl,,r,jr\.
il| ira6r\'!'r,ln.n \rr o,r,n,l.
j.,,r, ru)r...i, fiiq,r r, { |i r..Liri,,I,D,ror.
ri6rftf,ix/,or itririrs il..r,t,r ljrjlfr,, .ll
rrnr - ,r-[
n.t,ir-,.6rr,[
li|lrt
6,,1r,,rirrrr,
.1r{i,^.'r/,n! (. i4r'J{,nxtrlfnr r+r",t,l7.,, ri(io ., r,.!,,.r..,,,,, ,",,1 ,.,_.,,;. r(ii
s1+Fri,;r1. r. rr d..,ijt..,{t r r.\ iy.r.r irrr,:i s,r.r.\r,,ir!i rn(
r,,.,.i, i;,r ir..":+,,r-. r.
\riri
irr.iiFirr'rrLr
i,Jl,r.;,.u:,,1r,, {,,/,rIj, r,,r-,. CWRO
tliij\do,irrs1 ir(,i\r, (, ir.i.!,n.it!t,r {,.,.r,t1i*il,ol, ,,i .tirr,4,.nii,rrtr .i.itlrrrir,.}
.1r,l!'n(r'.l(ir' r, t,f,,?,.,r,krjri.
,r.r.r.r,r.ii.,t!),
":',
i
rJ,"..h, ftrrireri,n:{
I ,rD,
'i;o,,
(! ri rr},ll\i|r
t\fl)l 0 x !-,!r,11*r!,r!,
o
r..,r.rj,Ln,r:.":
(!)
..r.,,.1.,.rr. rii.r.rr\,rri :rrjci<.\,|L.-11.r, ..,...r\rr,ri .Li.L t,.r.\.r..
L-'r'ra,u. rjr.l*,n.E,.'r'. c,, .r,,tJriq.o J{rii. e..}7,.i[i, t,,r 4,,,.1i'.'l,t'
:rrx[ {{i|lri,t r"., irrF4nr lr,trr4,,
,ll, i:n, .l,.l.ljintr t,.Jra jr , ,jir't.
r, t,,,! {l,,,ti irrt.F\i,.t,r,, i,, ,,i.,tirrii,L
,jr
k)
(')
(t')
!r'l
tw)
(v,
(tr),r
(r)
,lJiri ",r.lrr!,l, rrilrlrr,id
nx,lrii,r,,}r.,!ri-,r,,,i|lr,ii . r".r,..ih,lt ttr;{rJ.\..
6 jlk'jr!'r. r,.r,.{:'i' rr, ix,,' r,j,,r,. ,j(,,,,8+ .
t, ,l n,F'J!. F. ilcil. r,.f.j|!,fi irt,:r{,.r..
rJ,rx,,xrI:+i r,jn,., ,!,rn:t_t i/ , it.v!u.r.,
" ri,-!,r. (r, t,.t,r(i\,,1r,, l,.i ,,.r,lr,jr\1, iL)r_,1_
I -r.,Lrr,t'ir.jiir(ir*,i
L.r.,r, rllijli
a dc,,r,irrt,\,,rt o,.rf,,r!{ro\1,t, (,rixr5n .
0 .tirirkn ,irl,lr, o. rtr i!.r, I
r,ii{,IL.artliIr1,,
(i+6o
qF rr,!i,6.{{ n'ir\[i*ro a|6irillki$iti &\$ i^r6ilrr[ ri,r^6si(\,
fur,r+1 d;I\t,r, nr{inrnG ,rioj|l',:r;rni pi qnktrrrin,,ti r6q,rt,o
n ihafifif JniY,ifxr,r:l .l'
f,,r.t1r,r. r. i, .l.r-r r,,.rtr I rir r,,,,{a,r,:
Ir
.\ ,q!-,./r r",r
r,:r-!,.;rl,l, l-/,1.'r,'r{rr, 6i,,frrhl, r,\,+.1 ,r, jixl Lri.r,. r,!r,,l,r,lrrin, t,iJr,
irr I'.G.ll
:
r1,r,,n,,i,jt1}1r.
rn,tr-ui r,\'rlrr
I
' \,rr
rJ i
:-\ i{:,,
r\, rrr q,,
,]ri.r r, !!.
L)ri t,r L, ri'"',
trJr
< ,,,, ,r.,,.J rj,t,\,r,J
r I i.",ir,
il,ll!.llri J' "",1. :1.,t',1',jiJ
t.rrr;rr{
l rerirf!€r ihrqyu\q",i\r6r^-r, iidr.r:ii
I rhr.r.rlnr' r,..J,4"il|1!la,r, 1r-rr{ ihlirr, !r,,rriii., r..i{,,tLr,!,r,!iq r(r,,it,.:/.iir, q,.ri,\8,.i'1,,
(,rarl.t,ry'rlr" I ri,ifrnilrirr, f\nn\^{,r.tfnnux,,r,. +,r,,\,,!-1 rll!( n,t 11!di|l,i|riri ]i,f
f ,raih,{,.,,,rq|, ,r,rriJq! ri r,r,.i,6i,!,r! rt rr ,l,.1,,ir.ri}illtL l.,f!!r ;rxln!,r!.i, r,,iirj,!qj
rq:.\lr. r|| .trr,t , -1,1..h1r r,/,ir.r .r,il,!..
r. rir,f,...r"]r.
r\d.-J{rnx, rrrr rd.Irin.lll r,.i r,Lr.n!r,r. .,r.r ji r+ r,. i,,, .slrr!,,r!, ,d..nr!rir(,r,LJrlfr...Jrll.ir, (fir) frrrny
,ii jlr.rrr\|r.aD i: f.rn,r,iA,r, !, ,r..rxtr)ir\t! r.. {\ir ;rr\r,,-q.!i
dr.n,k i{n.,r, xihrrlirn.,ll'{,r!tlnr
I &o-rh OJlol! ?i.th3t
I n"irl|{! rljir,'\rnrr(!-tlil$Dir ' ,l!r tri ,,!lr'rr!,r, ir:fi, r itl+,.. ,l"L$irr, iriit"r," 1,.,i/.r"
,l6r'lll.jr+h\.n' L YlnhrE: trir
rrr .hr r.n iilr. .rr,:r1.\ r.n r,rN\ rr. /a,1i(.rqr r,i,r,r,! r,r,i,r, dirf, I r,.rr l .i|rjrL:. rlr
'|, r!\iin,6,*tdirF i!,rrr, r,rn}.,,,L rrJr'r\ ,/t,rr! r. rrrr J,a,il;r.( .q.-rr (Dr.i,t,,hx,irit,
r.
r \,.1 J'l'(E\r.,lt!xl,i.r,-ri,ii,l .,,,.;r,-,\xrtrhr,
.,rx.:r,!,,L1/,1,
x"irr,,r./.tr18t
r,r{,r, ri,rttr,ir, ir,a,,t, 'r,
lrr, ,Lu r;1x,k,:rr,
lJ,il r..nijf\.n, r,. lr.r,( i:!,rr,i .qDr,,r.[]\\r, r)irll,,,,rrr,.$ i1 ir,,4iIlr!,\ r
,,ir.xqrrll,irlr, Lr:l.n&,:r -",,1$ (. \lxr li i,rfF,r-.ri ,rr,rJitrr xr ,,irird.
.litrr,r{,,1urn, p.. rrnr {,rr. }rii,r"}1r,
(lrl,*$doi on ci\i.Frl'l1. il^,:ri,r,[ Lifi L"r :llr ""1 ltrrajir ,.l i[,ir,, l".,rir,.dFrri,
r!,"irro(1,.4. .Y(, l+,$ ..(, fur.ir:a,x11,,1, ,.,.r1rrtli ll,l,r"ir{,,.,J,L.ntrrrn{,iFn,t!!lant, q
.l,jr!.,'d,!, kr!,t$dFi!|.,,,r or!:L[rd,,r,
r"r6..rq.rii,r, iji\.I\
i*, n,.1',JA,,M irrl,
r l,,\Jdinn,l h!,l,iHltdri{rr.' i\ \iln, irr,n,Lir!,1, r,.rel;r., {.,r.otr\J}r,, i(!x!,li|,!LI i,]xr
.6n );+,'. r,i!,r,rxi.;h
!",xi.'.r'l,r!,1' x(itlitr,n \ 6r',rr(.:rx,x
^lrlll.'":r,|,,rl,r-{,,rr.r'! n- rhr,,, { ! 1 , ri!. ,i,j*n, .t..r*
r!.:i/n F ..L ino q ,.-:!rr"y.i,
,
r
rNr .r'.{r rli*,l\ r,J,.+rrrr. r,. L i,\.r- ix,r!,x, tr*,r,t,!d$n,, t.,,rr,.
ltilrrn.{ (rir.Llr1}i!
x(!r*,r. ifi\r/r.r.. rrr1tr..r. !.Fi.+-i. r r}.,,r!,s\r.r- .,!.xt,n!i. ri./r1!i"
) i|r.rrlo ll';t,\l,l, IJ.x,iltidr
l
f, iirrh
L
t,r
llll,[|.,,lirrx'rJ",:l'|I6.[n1'|.',x,JirlI\L.i!,lirLi|'j||t,.|
i)i!I.{i,rl.', JirnL iriirrri 1rr..,r,l." 1". !nL,r{,rrr+i, !r
rlrr rr{,i.,r}!irL.Ii-,'r, ,l,rrr,,6t ,irL r,l. xrr'!"r',r,Fn l,,,rf,4Iq,'l.rr ii,!'ri.i.1\ {lntl, ,i^i l,,x,\,r,
:!r ri,.r.jfh f. r],."r, L.r.,..aiirt r,.r,t':ilrq,rr1+, d,rr:d,rr,r. rr.rrir r .].iiir,N,Lr:
rur .Jr'r'., ,,.ii,rf.!i{rr
.ir,rldxr ,.J,r,n,rir'!
,rs - rdnl tL-'.i,|.
.lr,r rn!,,rLri
,lLi,rr.rii
r.{,'.!,r r, r\"rl(r\r,rrr.," rnrr f rr,. tJ ui
(, 1ro{, Llir[ru' rhrtxr,rir\ri
,r .hr(r,x.k1,rsiit,,r!. .i i lr.ri .hr, :rxL(.1..iq! ,,,iii.lx:Nr,\ x-t,,r, irxr,x,.!rrr,. r.,
r,\nr, ixr,xi{1r,r!\ r, i1,.rn,rtri/rr s..iri'irrrl, itrL!.,.ri,.cr tnr, r,rR jrF.irl,t$,1! :rft
'rvr
rv) r,itirlrN iir,rlx,,r,L,,.0
.( !1i,jir,iJ
r,rir,,Jrli!irfl!,1. ,t ,r,,.t!;t,r rr,(,.
\r.riirrr$nr1 ,h1,,*riror,.r, (r|, r r!:, xi|!|6 a(,rr!.r, (l.rir!n,5r.
(vrl t!r,6. ,rrfirni,lDtri'r :l.ri.r ir!1rri\!.irl, trJ,lw,6trlJrl,i]ir'r ir,,t;,rr|f,:f1,,1!\ {.
,r,rt {.J(,f,(r<,.,f,n ii,nx,F,s6irli\ $ xirrrr(lil{r,\ ior, J.\$l,i|^ilt ,1$i[
a nd(I'jl]d,.\ Ni ltnirdJoiiri\or! _lt{oih
r.r ,r(rir.!.n. rL l.ddirE5J,, [" lrrr-, \]lt,lrr{,. .,,,rirp,ir ir \rfr-.r. x.f.
r ai.,.,t r,r, ,|ftr!,llo,r\! -rl{., r....1,,r(;!.rt, ih..ir.,("r,1. r";r,. \fl.rir, fritr,r{,i/,,r
ir!{nrDirJ, .rrid1F.. :-, ry,.rt!lt.,/,r,r,!.r, ilMt. fFn }.rni\{r\., qr t,.yrr,r\itrD rl4nr
i}.lrq i,( r,rq,eirl irii\.nt,. ,lrlqnlrirr&i
[rDr. ,i,r ri,.r,..ri L trl,r] rirL,!.j,,lj I
lll
tf.
v
nriil,tj r[.r!r,lrr,r,.
..rfll;'rr)r|!.],]r11, {.,
.rh.fr r;rr, .li(r.r.a"r;tol!,r. frl(Ii,,L r,,tu ,.r.x.( 1!ri I iii_lri.r !r,xlir i.
,
IlDr. ..irl,,riil, lftr"n"-r:!, $xnrrn,fir{tr lr,irl.
ut,ra,ji,,ti!4( q,) sr).!rl,ir, ,rjn{.irFt, .n,.l.irhiu I lr
r. ,rx-il .!1.x,1.,F ti,r{r ,\..t-iLrc..x[ !,r .;hrr
j|tll.,rr,:lii|:1.
\-r p ,l{:,,,f,
.rlll.ftrtt, ..f,i,i6rn[.
.i;r+,i r(,ire,n rnri{,.r,r,ll.,t, ir,D}4ic",t,,.6 rffl{r
jrlll,,t,iri.
xlL..H6.
Mt)t,,'. .jl')ra(,t,ri t\.rl{wrl\iar,[ [inlr.i]*
f,irD*itlr,G r!,i]_\:rirr..l{, pFR.tr.
16r.r/r,; .rn, Ox[p!t,1rrx,rih+ro,I]fn, ,ri rrjto,.!l,.ir6 ,Hsl;lr,t, ,,r,r,.-n.d;"i il.,_.{,
ar)1r,il,, r" 1,.,r(1,r!rjrrr!ir.
(l,iJ,il6oxinl-..e rt{ i,rl4
i6^iti'nq,. oriit,t,.Fn6nr i.,.rn{m.!5i)&,[ .)d.6rrs ti,
it.!.,;ti[rll!r,xlil.6n qs li,{r!,rEril.,o itt,ri6orloJaal, r,rn"nrioji tr
,\.:nn.,r a ir ,,ir:N,r,,1,,h .r-rrt,.1,it, r. 1,,.!i,,1,,,.j,n r,,,,,r1,r,/r,i,f\trrt.
!
,inrror{$r Lir ,,4 ;ri)r,l \ ir;rr i r, i\_i ,u. r r \l,l
\ll
,r, ;,;1)l.l'fi.J;i:;l' ''l:tl;;:;l:::il",,r:r" ,ii" ",,,;.1;.,.,]lrl'*"r'
,1
rr'r'{rr,i
i;^J"lr;l;,,J;i;1;";1.,i: ,::"l,t];;*:t;ltiilli::t.,i:t:1;::ll;,,,::*,.,.111i,;,._ ,_,.,"",,,,,,
L";'i:#'j:lilfi:i:l:,lll1lr,il.tr.lt,l;ir,;;:ii;lirt.
0 lnoGe.i6r r,#ra{ti}e$}i irfercir(n
, ,-"$ i, ,,i\iii,,ri,,,".. r.r,
ifr,i}.,!ii|.,, (J l,$iD }s.,,h[.A,
tr,[
i i.iL,,r hrfr ! ]t,i,L, .r r,,rii.1,.r1, -'j
oDJ.iro$I:n, rr!l6i(!l rf,.ir,illtr 66$t,ihnl.oh nihir-.\6r&,tt,k6oariliN
IRr{xlill{'iiir'
,r lL*.!rx{,.Frr!,
, rii,iiqi
IxrP,,
\rxr r.t!.,rx4x^lr, a! rLie,r.iirrr x-rl.f,.,r.ir,ir, lrrii L /.1i,
r..li-.xrr,,
,,rr,L
,r.,.' 1r.i,/.rr" r,irr. ,ra r,, , r.
(rr iridJill{n anJ.r*litFr, Jxll,ir5t,n,
rr., .,,,i I (t,,.4,L .j.ri'
l}l,,'-,r,t t.r,, r: r.i)rllr
a.i,.!(ri ii r\". r,rr rrjrr
ხელშეკრულება
Susta,nable Urban Transood Inveshenl prooram
{RRp cEO i2r' t4-O1r
FRAMEWORK FINANCING AGREEMENT
(GEO: Sustainabte Urban Transport
tnvc;i-"ni irog.",,,,t
Parties
This F.amework Financing Agreerhent (..FFA,,)
dated Z1._ Junel 2OlO
is between Georgia and sia; oevetopme"t
el.ki:,;b-Er.).
MFF lnvestment Georgia is commi ed
Program
fo an
system in urban areas ot c
(lo be tmptemented kom
equivalenl The tolal cost
secior, over the peflod of
equivalenl
The rnvestment program wrll impr
sustarnable urban lransport for abou
It wtll provrde. as appropflate. tar
Municipal Develoomenl Fund of
managerial, and lechnical performan
The lnvestmenl program willcompnse the
followtng pa(s:
Componenl I Urban Transport Infraslruclure tmprovemenl
r Koao ano bldge Constructon and urban habrlat and waterrronl
tmprovement
2 Public transport network and infrastructure rehabilitatjon and
exlension
3 Muttimodat facitities including parking and trafric rnanagemenl
Component I: lnslitutional Capacity Oevelopment
Component Il prog.am Management Facality
Multi-Tranche
Financing
Facility
Tte_ irrittrkanche Frnancrng Facrtrty (the
nnaoce prolecls under ihe lnvestment
.o."prv *,rri rnu
;;l
"i,iJi;
set out in this FFA
are comptred with
Fac,trty or MFF) is rnlended lo
;i;'$l,J,j[%"fl .j'::lL't'j"J"i,""I,::ffiJ:
provrders
on the part of ADB to commit
easonabty, ADB has the right
gra, cancel the uncommitted
rgra's nght to requesl any financing
kanche under the Faottly Flnancing
.kanches may be made available by
AOB paovtded maters contrnue to be
in accorjance wilh ihe gener;l
underslandtngs and expectaltons on which the Factlrfy is based
and whrch
are lard out In this FFA
This FFA does not constrl
requesl any financrng Ge
under the Facility Georgra
uncommifled ponion ol lhe
respective rights to cancel I
lo refuse a financing req
other parlies The written
lion or refusal and. in the
( cancellalion takes effect
This FFA will enter rnto lorce upon notice from Georgta lo ADB on the
fulfitlmenl of domestrc procedures for enleflng rnto force-tn accordance
with
Georgia's applicabte tegistatron. but not taler ihan effectiveness of the loan
agreemenl lor kanche 1 proleci
Flnancing Plan The llnancing plan for the tnvestmenl program is summarized betow
Financing Source
Asian Development Eank
Government
Total
Source asran De,etoomlniEailili fGi
Financing
Terms
Total(gmillion)
300 00
51 63
351.63
Share (%)ol
Total
a5 32%
14 680/0
100.00%
ADB wrll provide loans to finance components under lhe lnvestment
Program, as and when lhe later are ready for financing provided, Georgia is
rn comphance wiih the underslandrngs hereunder and lhe componenls are
rn hne wrlh those same understandrngs
Each loan will conslitute a kanche under the Facitily Each kanche may be
,inanced under terms different from the llnancing terms of previous or
subsequenl tranches. The choice of financing terms wtfl depend on the
project, capital market condilons, and ADB s financing poticies, all prevailing
on the date of signing lhe legat agreement lor such lranche T.anches may
be provided rn serquence or Simultaneously, and some may overlap tn trme
wrlh each other There rs no maxtmum or mintmum size for a tranche
lnterest, commilment charges or guarantee fees are nol payable on the
Facrl(y They are payable only oo financing actually commi ed by ADB as a
loan or guaranlee ADB rules on inleresl. commrtment charges and
guaranlee lees, which are rn effecl when the legalagreements are signed for
a tranche, wrll apply wrth respect lo such lranche
Amount
The maxrmum flnancrng amounl avarlable under lhe Facrlrty rs $300 mtllton
ll wrll be provrded rn rndrvrdual lranches from ADB's ordrnary capttal
3
resources and Specral FL,nds resources2, subject to Ihe laner
avatlabrl v
and allocatton under AOE s apptrcabte potrctes
pro""drr"".
tme
fr". fir. ii
"nd
Availability Perlod
The lasl oate on which any dtsbursemenl under any
lranche mav be martp
w,ll be 30 December 2018 The tast penodrc Fina;cinq R;";.i i#il ,"
expected to be submrtted no tater than 3l August 2016
Terms and Cooditions
Georgia w l cause the proceeds ol each tranche to be applied
financrng of expenditures of the rnveslment program, rn
to the
accorua-nce with ihJ
conditions set forth in lhis Agreemenl and th; Iegat
ea;h
lranche The loan proceeds under the Fadlily witt 6e r.rs-ea
"gr""_";f;-;
to fi"a;c; r;;;;
lransporl projects. ,or whrch ehgrbrt(y and ipp.ovat
"n,"r" "r" ""i Jriln
Schedule 4 to thrs FFA
Execution
The Executrng Agency (EA) tor the tnvestment program
will be IVrDF with the
assistance of the participating municipatities. T-ne En witt ;"";i;
i;;
subprojects under the tnvestmenl program in accordance wiffr tfre
orrnc,oi.i
set forth rn Schedute 1 to this Agreement and the selection criteria'Jf!,ii
rn Schedule 4 lo this Agreement. as supptemented in the legal
for each loan
"g,""r"nii
Periodic
,#'?i;,i" ?ltiii lli#;,lli,"l,iii
Financ tng
Requesls
Request (PFR) Each pFR shoutd be
he roa n,n a ccorda nce wrr n tne rerate jepa#";t"tl",l'"
H:,
lhe lranche
r
Hr::ffilrt;:
kanche wr be tor an amount of no tess than US$50 mi ion,
or ils equivalent ADB wilt review the pFRs, and f founO sariifactory,
Each indNrdual
wtii
prepare the related legal agreements
s requesled under the pFR will be
proval process sel out in Schedule 4
preparation of relevant safeguards,
,mpremente_o,n accordance *nn,n"
n"#lii,"j,l';-J,?"."1;:l ll rH,|.
j:
J to rnrs Fl-A and the Facility Admrnistration l\ranual agreed between
lhe
parlEs
Unless otherwise nottfied by Georgra rn writing, pFR wt
s apprrcable
ppty ro each
od nary
op
phcable to Loans t$ade
uch Loa.. sub,ect to m
s Loen RegLrlations. es
CR Loan Regutatrons th
be stgned on behalf
f.om AOB,S
ll"i;llilJ
tFunds
may be
elnatter
ot Georgia by lhe Mrnistry of Ftnance
with the senerar rramework
f,,,T,i'j1",",,." Ji"":il1'gJ.:,T Plemenred in accordance
rmprementatron
der;'|rs mav be ser our
r.i.e*oii."- ;i##;ifi:: :,i::"i""rt3""*
Paocedures
Each lranche lo be provic,ecl uncler lherFacrllty
will be sublect to the lollowing
procedures and undertakrngs
(r)
..
(rr)
Georgra wr have notrfted ADB of a fonhcoming pFR
at teast 15
days rn advance of the subnission ofthe pFR: "
ceorgra wrt
FR rn the ror;at agreed w,th AOA:
ADB may.
o""r,n" to
and execull
"urn-orir'.ii;
0n)
I
(,v) once ADB
PFR information
;;il;;"
,"^"J"",",t#'"'r'll'lili;ili"o,.._".,.
The PFR wllt substantally be rn an agreed format,
and wi contarn the
lollowng detarts
(i) Loan amount:
Description ofcomponents to be financed:
I(nr)
I Apprarsal
repons for all constlluenl subprotecls tncludino
envrronmental assessmenl report. resenlement ptan,
rf anv. anO i
due drtrgence report on safequards
PFR:
,mptementation ,n th" 6*u,oirl
(iv) Cost estrmates and fhancing ptan tor the proposed toan and the
subprolecls,
(v) lmplementation arrangements specific to the subprojects or
componenls:
(vi) Conlirmahon of the continuing validity of, and adherence to, the
provisrons of this Agreement;
(vti; Conlimatrcn of compltance w h lhe provisions under previous
--(vt") Other rnformalron as may be requlred unOer tf," i"",fr,
Administration
Loan Agreement and project AgreemenL as appropriate,
aiA-'
Manual as reasonabty requested by ADB.
Safeguards
An€ched as.Schedule 5lo thls Agreemenl, are
the soctal and envrronmental
saleguards
thal wrll b€ compled wth duflng lhe rmplernenlatton
_lrameworks
ol lne rnveslmenl program
ADB sateguard poficres tn effecl al the time ADB approves the provisron
of a
frnancrng tranche wt be appl'ed wilh respect to the subpro]ects tinanceJ
under such tranches
Procurement
All goods and works to be financed under the Facility wi be procured in
accordance wilh AOB'S Procurement G,.ridetines (2OiO, as amended from
lrme lo lime)
Consulting
Services
All consulting servtces to be flnanced under the Facitity wr be procured io
accordance with ADB'S Guidelines on the Use of Cons,r[ants (20j0, as
5
amended from time to time)
Advance
Contracling and
Retroactive
Financing
commttmenl by AoB to llnance
the ret
Disbursements
be made in accordance wrth the
relevant Loan Agreemenl and rn
ment Handbook (2007, as amended
Monitoring,
Evaluation, and
Reporting
Arrangements
date of the loan agreement for
each
ll establish a program pertohance
nd subslance acceptable to ADB
agarnst each
indicalor
The EA wi also prepare and sub
component
ADB wll field revtew mrssrons as
Jnvestment Program under
each I
The
rveys and update ADB on lhe progress
rmplemenlalion arrangemenls any oUtstandrng issues,
envrronmenl and
reset ement as well as olher safeguard rssues; achtev;ment
of scheduled
Iargets conkact management progress, and other issues,
as approp ate
Representations SchedLrte 6 hereto sets oul the undertakings provided
by Georgia tn retation
and Warranties to the Facitily
GEORGIA
ASIAN DEVELOPMENT BANK
a
SCHEDULE 1]
SCHEDULE 2:
SCHEDULE 3
SCHEDULE 4
SCHEDULE 5:
SCHEOULE 6
FACILITY CONSTITUTENTS
DESIGN AND MONITORING FRAMEWORK FOR THE FACILITY
IMPLEMENTATION FRAMEWORK
SELECTION CRITERIA AND APPROVAL PROCESS FOR SUBPROJECTS
_
SAFEGUARO REQUIREMENTAND SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT POLICE'
UNDERTAKINGS
(GEo: sustainabre u,ot"?1?3.'"tt
A.
l ,**rment prosram)
Strateglc Context
rematnrng organizattonal gaps tnt tnfrastru
and regutaton ol kanspon operators efrec
generalton rn the lransporl sector. and rnteg
munrcrpal inkaslructure and reduce road
3. The developmenl of a suslarnabl
lhe development of urban areas and to
B.
Road Map
'1.
A vision for Sustainable urban transporf ln Georgia
by 2O3O
promote a suslainable, integrated, socially
ent urban transpori system By 2030. with th;
wll play a maJor role rn improvtng access lo
. and enabling citizens lo tap economtc anc,
roads. weak traffic managemenl and lmperfecl publtc transpon
ADB 2007 lntenrn Operatrcnet Stralegy 2OO8 2Om and Counlry partn€rshrp
servtces ll wilt also boost the
Sirategy und€r preparatron Man,ta
rmprovemenls tn matn urban areas
rnslitutronal slrengthenrng and capacrly
5
Five matn goals have been tdentlied for Ihe
urban lransport secior ln Georgra
tn urban areas Io boost the economy anct
d, efficient ttme saving road network
anc, suslatnrng u"ono-,i O"r"toprn"ni ,n
-
Goal 2: pafiote a suslainable clevelopmenl ol road netwotk
opelallon ln order lo maintain
a proper quarrty of road network, the management of rh"
t."m", tne qu"iitv of service and
lhe organisation ot rts maintenance wrl be improved ,"ing p.,r;t;
tnvotvement and
publlc private partnershrp (ppp)
i"li;;'
-
Goal 3: lmprove pubtic rranspotT netwo* to match defiand
and reduce
congeshon and cat
-rtrai"gy
usager An aflordabte, environmenta y krenc,ty and
."ring
Io upgrade,
renovate, complele public transporl tnfraskuctures.
and"n",gy
reniw vehrcl! fleet
Goat 4: tmp@ve
fibbihty and quatity of service with integrated
and sustanable
rransporr and
rntegrated kansporl network
ra,
eilJfflr:"JT,"ff],"ffi,i:lJ;txlrj;
- Goal 5. lmprove quahty ol lile with spect
pollulioo, no$o and ttamc accidents An
rnside the dense pa.ts of the cities and to d
cily partrcutarly sustainable coaslat wate
transporl uses (pedeslrian, hvo,wheeler, etc)
6
The sector roadmap aims to altocate over its 20 year-period
equal effort for the road
model polrcy shoutd be,avord,,,shtfl,
and.impfo
need lo kavel and lo encourage kaveters to
'green" vehtCles and fuels
2.
7
A sequenced urban transport development plan
transport
a trst of aclions
oevetop.ent
f+lffr:l"J:n
The princtple of the urban sustainable
whrch atm to deat wtth drflerenl tssues identified
These
prolects, rn order to rmptement a
i-o-t,-e-renl
'ADB E akea
and 2 (MSD
. ADB
2009
sustarnabte
nis-n^s,nail-mr''nGrpal €s lhrough MLrnrcrpal
servrces phase 1
,,uev6|opment Fund otGeorgra (MDF)
ror suslarnaDc urban lranspon'. Manrla
and aD8. 2010.
3
slructures are developed In a holislic
vrsion:
tor all lransport modes, especrally
road and
ptemented rn 3 phases which
may coinciae
(r) lmmedrale actron ptan. wrlh u'genl
uro
aclrons and investmenl lt mainlv rncludes
lhe akeady
prr"^ut;;.1;;i;. '- ' "'!'|
0i) Medium term actions aim at-providing transporlalion
jmprovemenl solulions
to matcl
and sustainabte urban habilal
(,) Lons rerm deveropment,r"';;i:: 1.':1":::;:"1j":"rjil","
development and ihe lransporl network.
9.
." ;;":
Medium term actions: differenl aclions are proposed
ar ,mprovins rhe currenr r,"""po,i plor;.,on-lo cope w(h the increasing
nu* ,,s"n,
i,il:;:",Jl"j
"'n"J"",l",iinn
(t) Road network creation of ssmglints upgradrng errsllng
road lo rmprove safety redesignrng marn Drobtemati rossioads
andi"norit.n J t"r.,"-#,,ir'i"!"
( ) Pubttc kansporl: restructuftng and
c,emand and new development in
kansporl servrces: extensron of th
refurbishmenl o[ lhe main stations
..
reorgantzatton of mrcrobuses servtces,
(iii) Parking organization and man agemenl: reform of the parking policy
and concession
for new parking lot.
(iv) Non motorized transportt devetop urba
factlities to paomole pedesklan and o
coastal watertront improvemenl gtven
life quallty improvemenl, urban regener
10, Long.term developmenl: rl promotes a dramaltc rncrease of quatty
and quarrty of trre In the pantotpaltng muntctpaltltes,
ol lransponatton
tncludtng.
(l) Road network creatton of new roads connectrng the surrounding areas,
to trmit traffic
rn the downlown area, and relurbrshoent anO
,p-gr"o,ng oi th" ;Jnli;o,k
(ir) Pubtic transport refurbtshment the.whote publtc__ lranspon syslem
tncluding
rnlerchanges facitities to provrc,e -of
safe, anraclrve ;nd afforJuOr!-."rJt.". creatjon of
new fast, attractive and hrgh-capacrty pubric transport r,nes on
tne.l,n cor.dors o,
demand.
(iir) Parking organization: creation of safe parking lots and ,,park and ride,, faciltties
at the
extremities ol the metro lines to encourage people to leave their
car and use pubhc
transport or walking zones tor thejr trip in the centre
(v) Non-motonzed lransporl creafuon ot traffic celmrng
zones In lounsllc areas of cttv
center lo rmprove lne quatrly ol ltle,
enhance cullural henlage and promote
peoeslflan and other soll modes
the use o'f
3.
Overvlew o, Roadmap interventions
a connecton between lhe two dense drskrcls
a
13
Pedesktan accessrbrlily and promo
lbrlrsr and Kutatsr In Kutatst brcycle
developmenl ts projecled lo ease pedestr
health impltcaltons The conslruchon of the Go
condrtrons by removing a malor lraffic bolUene
of rhe t\4tkvari Rrver, offenng drrecl pedestrian pathway
fl",rB:kl-r
slrong governmenlal rnvestmenl stimuli in touri
coaslal crlres of Bal ml and Anaklta This wrll
pedeslnan infraskucl re developmenl
measures
from the Otd City to the
devetopmenl of the related urban areas.
and enhanctng lheir aflractiveness for
rnlernationat tounsts whtch generale
domestic and
erhptoyment and re;enues
6
C.
21.
Pollcy and Relorm FEmewo.k
ln order to meei lhe ob,ectives of lhe inveslment program it
is necessary
!rban sector roadrnao anchored withrn a hotistrc and rnregr;ted *f;r,-;;;;;" to develop an
rmprovrng the
sustarnabtlrty, qualtty. and reliabrlity ol urban transport se-rv,ces Ttris
req-urr'e-S rncent,veS
anO
supporr lhrough 0) an enabl,ng po,rcy framework, (r) effectrve rnstrtutrons profeislonal
operalion
and management: and ( r) sustarnable llnancrng tor operatton anO invesim'enf
'-
22
Outside Tbilisi in Georgia,s seconda.y crlles, turlher tmprovements
need to be made in
urban plannrng and Servrce detvery ThlS tncludes bul rs not limrled to
tong-1"|.rn ,,",on;
clarily of rnsttlutonat mandates. lhe process and lhe outputs ot rntegrateO
"iei,
anO strategtc acton
plannlng, and coordtnatron rn rnveslmenl decrsrons thal would
ens_ure eflectrve penOrng tn
addilion, here rs a polential ol tmprovement in development ana imptemenfat n
of poticy
Ftameworks
1.
tnstituflonal change options
23
One of the rnstitutional reform coutd ultimatety lead to the creation of a Transport
Authorily'-under lhe Municrpatrty organizing all moaes of kansport in tf,e-oiy a"O managing a
aspects of transporlation. traffic managemenl, road mainlenance, public transport services
non
molonzed lransport and parklng ll could enable a global vrston and coherent acttons in
order to
promote an integrated public t.ansporl system,
2.
Flnancialopportunities
24
Drfferent financiat solutions could be rnvestigated lo bener cover operating and
investmenl costs for kanspodation Olhers options could also be proposed
to linance ne!,! road
rnvestmenls. especialty tolls on maln hrghways or pub|c pnvate partnershrp (ppp)
lo finance
new pub|c lransport slalions
25
3.
Monitoring
Monitoring refers to the regular and systemattc collection of dala on specifled rndicators
lo provide stakeholders of an ongoing acttvrty
achevemenl of objecttves Monttoring systems
performances according lo the contract cond
subsrdres to cover soctal discount in publtc tra
road congestion: (iv) help to decide on set incentives; and (v) direcl on the future organization
of
the public transpod market (e.g benchmarking among ditferent operalors, tende.ing decisions,
etc )
4. Capacity building through assistancc and training
26 To implement the proposed roadmap. with these rnlrasiructures proiects and
olganrzalional reforms, TbiLsr and other munrctpalities wtll requrre assrslance and trarning
Assistance will be required for engineenng. projecl management and supervlston lo implement
properly the proposed rnfraslructure according lo tnternattonal standards
'Ttrs lype ol organrzatron rs tound rn most wesrem and devetop€d countnes and rs called .verkensveftund. rn
Gsrany passaDger T,aF3oort Althonty rprA) ,n UK tL,Uar r,anspon Ua.agement euirroirry qaOrul ,n
rrance
lano Transpon 3,s1611r qgTA) ,n SrngaDore Toryo meropornan Bu.ea, oi r,".".poi"i.i
and r,anspol
Authoniy (RTA) rn Oubai Th€re are usuelly headed b y Mayot ot Vtc6
"ih""d
Mayot
7
akeholders, capacity building wrI be needed
trends, take inlo consicteration urban developm
future needs and focus on ihe matn futures tssues.
II
INOICATIVE INVESTMENT PLAN
Subs6ctor lnvolrmsnt R€qujromonr! to 2O3O - USt M ltons
lrpg;;;;
Tralfic llanagem6nt tmgrovements
Car Pa ,ng
18604
Road mprovemens and ntrastruclu.s
pub.r.enspo.,mprovemen.andhwshenrs
conneciion
hlermodalty and rnteqrated measu.€s
Non mororized l.ansporl tacitities
lnlerchangs and rntermodat
Brand,ng.s€nage,ntomanonandcommunrcarion
Polrcy afld lnsntulronat Retorm
OO
11 0O
O0
20 0O
iilOO
1333
7
Mass raprd trans,t ConstructEn UfEradhq and
S
I OO
83
1500
25
P,osramnanasemenrcapacry ,;::
Totrt rnvostnenr USt M, ron
Source SYSTRA AD8
2020.20t0 Toht
OO tSOOo
i27
1?4 59
15
25
OO
OO
40 OO
O
,iiI,:
15
OO
OO
2OO
37
,:;:
332
42
,;;:
44A42
d
tbd
79
ng:al
22 OO
15O OO
ffi
ffi:;
tDd
45 OO
lbd
tbd
ibd
62 83
ff
];;3
I OO
IZOO
334 r4J94
SCHEOULE 2
(GEO: Sustainable Urban Transport lnvestment Program)
OESIGN ANO MONITORING FRAMEWORK FOR THE INVESTMENT PROGRAM
lnd'canvs Perlormanco
Ta.qets/lndic.tors
Desi9n
Oata Sou.c€6/Repo.ting
Assumplion!.nd Rish!
lndrcalo.s lrom Municrpal
The Government pursues
8y 2018
Atiraclrveness and preservalrcn ol cullural
heilage wlh 10o/o ncrease rn tounst
nghrs compared ro baselrne rn 2008
Reduce utan road accdenis and
cas!altros by 59o compa.€d to baselrns ln
2009
Crlrzens wllbenent lrom protecl
conslnJcron lhrough,ob increas€
(berw€en 1 000 io 1 500tobs)
depanmenis Munrcrpal
companes and NGO
€ntr es as aporopaale
SLalrsncal sutueys {MRDI
Pnvale s€ctor rnvolved in spec fc iasks
lor slreamlrned,mplem€nlatlon
enntes as appropnaie
By 2018
NGO and rnlernalronalor
Polil|cala6d €conomrc
Dully mpl6mentanoo ol
lhe urban lranspon MFF
Economy vuln€rabrliiy lo
lmpemenlatron ol the
urban lranspon roadmap
Prog.ao wrr benefl atleast 2 m,lllon
people rn u/ban areas compared to 2009
Ulban populalDn rn Tbrhs, wth drrect
access to publrc transPorl rncrease by 5%
compared ro 200E
Pubhc rranspon ndoBhp ,nc.eased by 5%
compa.6d ro 2009 bes6[n6
Marnlah public transporl modalsplrt r.
Tbrrsr ai leasr as rhe same level as 2009
Appropaals envronmental
Melro, bus companres or
other agenci€s statrstrcs
Prompt decrsrcn-making
releasrng counlsDa( tunds
release by GoG
MDF Tb' lsrend olher
MRDldara base
Weak coordr.ailon amorE
goverf,menl depanmenls
Wonen usrng ounrcPal urban lransporl
rncreased bY 5% compared lo 2o0E
undermrnes operalrons
Oulputs
Ay 2Ola
a 1 5 i.n long Tb'lrsr Mero Ert€nsron lo
Unrv€rsrty compleled
ofle ulball redevelopmeni on GoEasalr
rmplemented rncluding one underpass
20 km ol Mesta road upgtaded
27 km brcycles lanes rmplemented in
Kulalsr
All desgn and constructron addess
sD€cilic n€6ds ol wom€n and men nders
urban rransporl roadmap
published 0y lhe relevanl
munlopahly eniorced
Company, annual reports
empowe.ed rnstrrutions are
able io eteclrvely deliver.
oPerale, and manage
Parlrcipatng oly vrebsie
arld o$er municipal
communicatron and media
m6tenals
Managemenl capac'ly for
lh6 relevant .n unlcrpalites
strcngthened
Press rsroaso reporE and
Rlrks
Tbd's' Mslro and bus
N€w rn unlcrpal governmenl
sh,ltrng focus kom ulban
By 2016
iransporl rnvestmenls
One Badge on Mtkven compleled rn Tbrlisr
A l5km utan lnk TbrllsiRuslavr
Foohfidges co.slrlcted rn relevanl €tes
r0 km ol urban road and coastal
walerlronl,mprovemenl
Iratfc manege6e.l cenier rn operaton rn
sorveys conducled by lhe
Capaoty of domesl'c
contractors rs exhausled
due io larue number ot
ongorng externally- funded
rncrease oDeralron cosi and
Ay 2018
10 km ol urban road wih urban renewal
s!PPoded by consumers
upgraded rn urban areas
Mulirmodal rnterchanges rcdesqn€d and
Segregaled bus and tram trnes and tor
rN6.sde !lba6 rege.eraton consdered
I By 2o1a
Gendernespons've urban transpon
roadmap endorsed by Tbrrrs,
Parlrcipanng crly websne
ons ser-d'saqgrcgaled househoE surv6y
ca(led our rn Tblilsr (5O% ot respond€nis
Mu.icrpal{les rMpnv€ lo
reronn agenda and srrategE
Agreed rnslil!tonal reloms
ars lmplernented and
cont,nu€d politrcal will lo
manag€ and monrlor
Prog.em developmenl and
One multrmodar lraflic modet imptemented
A mulimodal team set up rn Tbitis wth
women .eoresentalives
OnB mullrmodal transpod webs{e w h
gendor .esponsrve desEn ol pubrrc
Rlrlt
A city twinning wrh tocus on g6nd6. pubtic
lranspon dBsrgn rmpl6mented
coo.drnallon and suppo.l
wilhro m!nrcrparrty rs not
By 2016
Ulban kanspon maslelptan devetoped
Divsrgence bstween
csniralgovshmenl and
and endorsed rnctudrng PPP optDns
munrcrparautnonl|es on
O.e iniegraled llclering systom
lhe relo.m to rmplement
A pad(ng management outsourcrng
MErobus organrzation set up r€thoughr,n
the context o, the uoan transDon
Plann,ng processes sircam ined and
monriofi ng tools estabttshed
Ay 2018
One Public Servrcs Contracts (pSC)
Tralric calmrng zones or podestaanEelion
EslabIshment ol
gy 201i.
Fe3srbilty strrdes and proJect due
panlcpalrng munlcpahttes
MDF B g'v'ng pnoniy ro the
urban transpo( prqects
and 6 wlftng to hlfe
Gender sens{rv€ oubllc awareness
neo*sary r6ources
drhgences lrmely prepared by MOF and
management and
the
campaqns organzed
F'nancal management gender
sens(lzalron p.ocu.ement saleguards
and I.arn,ng provd€d
MDF annual repon and
Ri.I
PonEal rssues shri urban
3
managemenl co.rracis camed o!l
Slud'es and due d,lgef,ces ro.
subsequenl propcrs prepared
ciivitie. wllh Koy Milestone!
L
Con3lructlon, inprovom.nt and r.h.biliUtion ol u.b.n t?zn!port ifitr.rtructurE
AOB 3300 00 m,lhon wih
. Delarled desg. compleled by month 12 lrom lhe efiecrrveness ol lhe ta.cho 1 roan
AOF/OCR
Tl 565 mrlron (AOF)
. Urban rnkaslrucllres constrlcr6d, comm ssrooed, and made operanonat n phases by
Gove.nne.l 551 63 mrtton
agreemenl (ldDF PM)
monlh 60 (MDF PM. Coniraclors)
. Equpmeni procured and d€l,v€.ed by monrh 36 (MDF. PM Manulacture6)
. Oelarled desEn complered by month 12 trom lhe effedNeness ol the tranch€ 2 loan
aq.eenenr (MOF PM)
. Trmely land acqursitron and mplemo.talion ol resettl€menl plans before conlracl awards
([!DF, PM)
. lJrb6n nt astructures con3lrucred, cornmisson€d, and mad€ op€ratonal rn phas€s by
month 60 (MOF PM. Conuaclors)
. Equrpmenr procur€d and del,veled by monlh 36 (MOF. PM Manulactur66)
. Derarled d6s€n completed by monlh t2 lrom lh6 efl€ctvenss o, the tranch6 3 loan
ag.mmenr (l(oF PM)
i Tm€ly land acqursrlron and implemenlanon olresetlem€nl pl6ns b€fore conlraclors
contracl awards (MDF PM)
. U6.n nlraskuctu.es conslructed comm'seon6d and mad€ op€rrtbnalln Ohas€s by
month 60 by contraciors {MOF PM Conkaclors)
. Equpment grocured and delrvered by month 30 (MOF, PM Manufacture6)
2
lnstirutional C.p.cily D€volopmonl Pl.n
. Household survey and srralegE rafic model oevelop€d by mon'h 12 (MOF, TM)
. Murlrnodar ream set,up at rhe munErpallevsl by Month 12 and mullimodal conc€pl
rnrtrar€d bv monh 18 (PM)
. Ser{rs.g9,asaEd publlc ransportsutuey and database develop€d by monlh 24 (PM.
3. Progr.m M.n.g.msnt F.clllty
. Safeguads spocralst(s) recrul€d by month 6 (MDF PM)
. Ge^de, Fooal pornt rn MDF denlrfied and supoorcd by ADB
. Trarnrng plan carned oli as appropaate by mo.lh 48. wlh al leasl 30% ol women
pa.lrcpanls (MDF PM)
. Suppon prcvrded to ihe Prcg.am developmonl rmplemenlatron and manag€ment for the
whole duraton ol the Program (MDF. PM)
Tr.nch.ll: lo bo approv.d by.nd ol20lo.b.ginning ot 2011
Tr.nch.lll: lo bo.pprovsd by ond of 2013
ADB = Asren Dovelopment Eank lvlDF = Mu6rcrpal Oevelopmenl Fund. MROI : Mrnrslry ol Regronel Developmsnl and
lnfrasrructures NGO = .on-governmenl organ[alDn OEM : operatlon and maintenance PM : Panrclpaling
munrcrparrtles PPMS = protecr prcparclrod and rnon(ofinq syslem TM : Tbrlsr Munlcrpally
Sourca Asran Oevelopment Bant
D,rccror CWJS
Dl,ector General, CWRO
SCHEOULE 3
(GEO: Sustainable Urban Transport lnvestment Prog,am)
IMPLEMENTATION FRAMEWORK
I
Unless modrfred and amended in loan or pro,ect agreements under the Facrtily, the
investment program w(l be rmplemented as follows
A.
2
lmplementatlonArrangements
The executing agency for ihe rnvestment program will be lhe Municipal Development
Fund (MDF) Participating municrpalities wrll assist MDF for the implementalion of Ihe projecls
under the lnveslment Program tor lheir perimeler
3
lvlDF Supervisory Board whrch is chaired by the Prime Mrnisier of Georgia witt provide
overall policy drrection and guidance for the inveslmenl program- The board includes rnlea a/la
Minrstry of Finance (lvloF); Ministry for Regional Developmenl and lnfrastruchJre (irRDl) and
Ministry ol Economic Developmenl (MoED) Representative of other relevant ministries and of
municipa|lies can be rnvrted to altend as appropnate The board wll be providing overatt
gurdance, revrewrng rnveslment program perfolmance and decrdrng on all majot tssues of lhe
rnvestmenl p.ogram managemenl The dulres of the L,IDF will lnclude
(r)
(ir)
('!i)
(rv)
(v)
(vi)
provrsron of strategic guidance on and overseetng the implementation of the
investment program
preparahon ot lhe periodic financing requests (PFRS) for their submission to ADB
preparation of annual budgel estimales for aciivities under the investmeni
program for lherr eventual approval:
recrurlmenl ol add(ronal staff and consultanls, as necessary, to prepare and
manage the program
procuremenl of services, works, and goods, and approval of disbursements; and
approval of the subprorects and ensuring comptiance with safeguards and
acquisrtion of land, and other similar matters with the help of the participating
munrcipalitres
4
MDF wrll be expanded as appropriale to execute, manage, and monttor the
rmplementaiion of lhe inveslmenl program The team dedicated lo the MFF wtll comprise
technical, flnancial, procurement socral and environment, and administrative specialists The
MDF wrll have adequate staff wilh relevanl expertise and should include: a road engineer, a
financial management specialist an accountanl, a procuremeni specialist, an environment
specralisl. a socral safeguards specralrsl. a moniloring and evaluation spectalist, an tnterpreter,
and a management rnformatron system specialist Supported by consultants under lhe program
management lacilily (PlvlF) (Component 3 of lhe investment program). MDF will be responsible
for
(r)
(r)
(iii)
(,vt
(v)
(v )
appraisingsubprojects;
undertakrngfeasrbrlrtystudies;
supeNisingdetaileddesignsl
procuflng lhe goods and servrces.
direclrngconstructronsupervrsron
overseeing the rmplementation of lhe institutronal slrengthening and capacity
development;
(vl) monrlonng and evalualrng lhe rmplemenlaton progress and rmpact:
(vrii) checkrng and guidrng saleguards compliance;
(rx) coordrnalrng among government agencies; and
(x) consolidatrng and preparing periodtc reports for lhe investment program
5
A municipal project implementation team (MPIT) will be set up in each particrpating
municipality and wrll be responsible lot day-lo-da,! rmplemenlatlon of lhe subprojects within ils
perimeter Each [4PlT will be headed by a munrcipal focal point
B.
6
Approval Procedurc to. Tranches
C.
7
Reviews
For the subproiects lhat will be rncluded rn the laner PFRS, the selection and approval
are set fonh rn Schedule 4 to ihis FFA
After revrew of the semi-annual progress reports, ADB will field review missions as
required to discllss the progress of the lnvestmenl program under each loan, any changes in the
implemenlatron arrangemenls. or remedial measures thal are needed lo achieve the overall
obiectives of specilic subproiecls and ot overall inveslment program.
ln addilion to regular reviews, including a midlerm review for each loan, a detailed
midterm revrew of the investment program wlll be done 3 years afier the effecllveness of lhe
loan for the first tranche The midterm review for each loan will be done in accordance wth the
project
implementation period ol each loan Such midterm reviews wlll evaluate in detail the
8
aclivities, implemenlation arrangements, any outstanding lssues' environment and resetllemenl
as well as olher safeguard issues, achievemenl of scheduled targels, contract management
progress, and olher rsiues. as appropriate The midterm review for the investment prog'am wlll
ioc,is on: 11 performance under the Componenls ot the investment program; and (ii) any
changes to rmplementalton arrangements or remedial measures needed to be undertaken
toward achevrng lhe obieclives of lhe rnvestmenl program
I
The AOB review missions will be underlaken iohtly with MDF and MPITS
SCHEDULE 4
(GEO: Sustainable Uiban Transport lnvestment program)
SELECTION CRITERIA AND APPROVAL PROCESS FOR SUAPROJECTS
A,
1
SELECTION CRITERIA
The Asran Development Bank (ADB) wi finance projects and/or subprojects
that (i) are
parl of lhe Invesrment Program and/or achreving the obrectives of lhe sustarnabre
urban
lransporl seclor roadmap as descnbed tn Schedule I of the Framework Frnanctng Agreement
(FFA). 0r) adhere lo the imptementatron arrangemenls sel fonh rn Schedule
3 of the FFA. ( r)
lully comply wrth lhe social dimensions and safeguard frameworks rn Schedule 5 of lhe FFA,
and (N) meet the e[gibility requirements sel fonh in thrs appendix
1.
2_
Selection of participating Municipatities
All muntcrpatrlles tn Georgra are etigrble For activiies lo be frnanced under
j
of lhe lnvestment Program, the parttopating municrpalites should presentComponenl
an overall
assessmenl of the urban kanspon (UT) situation whtch includes (t) city urban a.ea poputation
and demographic lrends, (ii) urban transport network and pubtrc transport services, (iii) urban
and economic developments prospects, and (iv) urban transport management system.
2.
Selection of Subprojects
3
ln selecting the subprojecls for each munrcrpality, the following generat criteria shoutd be
tollowed:
(i)
(I)
(ri)
The subproject deals wilh (i)
and urban transpod infrastructures,, (ii)
'_lrban (iii)
transpon services management,
or
intermodal measures and kansport
management tmprovemenis
The subprorect has a proven consumer demand analysts, is ttkely to trigger
posrtive externalities tn lerm i of tourism development and economic
regeneration. ts technically sound, and its feasibility assessment meets the
engheering, financial, economtc, envtronmenlal. and socral requrrements of
Georgra and ADB;
The subprqect has been granled government approvals and endorsements and
has been allocated sufliclenl counterpart fundtng lo tmplement the prqect or
subprorect as scheduted and matntain such projecvsubproject facilitiea upon
comPletion: and
4
For prolects or subproiects that are added in the course of updaling the Governmenfs
lnvestment Plan. all relevanl clearances should be soughl prror to submisiion of the pFRs to
ADB
3.
5
Appraisal of Subprojects
yvhen apprarsing the subprojecls, fotlowing generatcriteria
(r)
shoutd be folowed:
The feasibility study shows that the subproject meets ADB s technical, economic.
ftnanclal andinstrtuttonal requirementsi
Conslructron ertensron up9radrng 0r .ehabrlrtanon ol !ruan lransporl r.irastruclures rnci!drng wrthout trrnrtaron
roads urban walerlronls publE transpon kaffic management partrng a^d mulhodal tacrtri,€s
(ir)
(tit)
(iv)
(v)
(vi)
B.
6
The economic viability of the subproject should have been demonstrated by an
economic analysts undenaken rn accordance with ADB'S Guidelines fot lhe
Econofiic Anatysis ol Prolocts (1997)
The ftnanctat sustainability of the subproject should have been demonslrated
through a linancral analysis and financiat management assessmenl undertaken
rn accordance wtlh Chapters 3, 4 and 5 of ADA,S Handbook for Borowers on the
Ftnancial Management and Analyss ol projects (2006)
For a subproject with land acqutsltion and resettemenl impact. a reseuement
plan will be prepared. in accordance wllh the Land Acquisttion and Resetflement
Framework of lhe tnveslment program (incorporaled by relerence tn Schedule 5
lo lhrs FFA),
An rntkal envtronment examrnatton (lEE) or an envrronment impact assessment
(ElA) as apptrcabte shoutd have been undertaken lor ihe subproject with
sufticient mrtigalion measures and budget for managing potential negative
envrronmenlal impacts, in accordance wrth the Environment Assessmenl and
Review Framework of lhe lnvestment program (incorporated by reference in
Schedule 5lo this FFA)i and
The implementalion arrangements and instilutionat strengthening and capacfy
development plan for the subproject have been prepared
SELECTION ANO APPROVAL PROCESS
Approval procedures for projects proposed for financrng under lhe MFF will fo ow the
required review and approval processes in Georgia as supptemented by the requirements
attached to Schedule 5 of lhrs FFA For lhe Tranche 1 subprolects proposed for linanctng irnder
this MFF, all necessary approvals in Georgia have been obtained prior to the contract awarcts
The followng process wrll be lollowed when preparing and submttting a perjodic financing
requesl
(r)
MDF reviews and screens the subprojeci proposals to confirm lheir compliance
wrth eligibility criteria, and has them revrewed and endorsed by lhe Supervisory
Board l
()
[4DF, with the supporl fiom the Program Management Facitity, ensures
implementation and apprarsal of the feasibrhty and due diligence studies for the
subprojects;
MDF p.epares the periodic linancing request (PFR) based on the subproject
feasibiiity and due diligence reportsl
The Supervisory Board reviews and endorses the subprolect feasibility and due
diligence reports as well as lhe corresponding PFR;
l\,,lDF subm(s, through irrnistry of Finance (MoF), the endorsed PFR together
with subproject feasibility and due diligence repons for AOB's approval
Subject to satisfactory complrance with the selechon criteria and approvat
procedures, and in compliance w h ADB s relevant potrcles, ADB will approve
lhe proposals of the projects
MDF will proceed with procurement exercrse in accordance with ADB's
Procuremenl Gurdelnes and Gurdetnes on lhe Use of Consultants_(2010, as
amenc,ed from trme lo lrme)
(iii)
(rv)
(v)
(v0
(vii)
7
[4oF, N4RD|. Municipal Development Fund of Georgia, participating municrpaltties, and
ADB will maintarn contact lhrough periodic ADB revrew mrssions and semt-annual progress
reports, and in so dorng may etfect advanced consultatton on PFRs prior to submtssion to ADB
1
SCHEOULE 5
(GEO: Sustainable U.ban Transpod lnvestment Prog,am)
ENVIRONMENT ANO SOCIAL SAFEGUAROS
1
Georgia wtll ensure that all the requirements prescribed in this Schedule and the
following safeguard frameworks and plans that have been prepared with respect to lhe Facitity
and lhe frrsl lranche. and Of whrch ADB has been provrded full Copies. and whrch are deemed
rncorporaled herern by reference. are compled wrlh duflng the processrng and tmplementation
of the proiecls llnanced unde. lhe Fac'irly
(r) environmental assessment and review fiamework (EARF),
(ir) land acquisition and .esettlement framework (LARF), and
(iii) envrronmental managernent plan (EMP)
The frameworks cover the Facility-specttic tnlormation and requiremenls in accordance
2
with AD8's saleguard policies: (i) the general antrcipated impacts of the componenls or projects
likely to be financed under the MFF on the envrronment and involuntary reset ement; (ii) the
safeguard crileria that are lo be used in selecting components, projecls; (iii) the requi.ements
and procedure that will be followed for screening and categorization, impact assessmenls,
developmenl ot managemenl plans, public consuttation and info.malion disctosure (including
the 120-day drsclosure rule if requrred), and monitoflng and reporling; and (iv) the institulional
arrangements (includrng budgel and capactty requiremenis) and the client's and AD8's
responsibilities and authorities for the preparalton, revtew and clearance of safeguard
documenls
3
Pnor to the preparatton ol each PFR, the applicability and relevance of each Safeguard
kamework for envrronmenlal assessment rnvolunlary resettlemenl, and indigenous people will
be reviewed and updated to ensL,re relevance and conststency wilh appltcable country legal
frameworks and ADB's Safeguard Policy Statement (2009), as amended from time to time
4
ln all cases, for each new PFR preparation MOF will review ongoing projects under the
Facility to check on the status of compliance with lhe safeguards plans and frameworks, and
submrt the review reports to ADB logether with olher required sateguard documents relevanl to
the projects rncluded in the kanche being processed ln any case if major noncompliance is
drscovered in lhe course ol the review of ongoing subprojects, a correclive action ptan wrll be
prepared and submitted to ADB
5
ln addition, all ADB Safeguards Policies in effect as of the date the financing of a project
is prepared or provided under lhe Facrlity will apply to such proiect ln the event lhere is a
discrepancy between the laws and regutatrons of Georgta and ADB s Sateguards Policies, then
the slricter of these two regulations shall be applied
Environment
6
MDF shall ensure lhal each proiecl and all facilities financed under the Facility are
developed. conducted rmplemenled and marnlarned rn accordance wtth all appicable laws and
regulatrons of Georgra and ADB's Safeguard Polrcy Statemenl (2009)
7
MDF shall ensure that a relevant environmental impact assessment (ElA) or in,ltal
environmenlal examinalion (lEE) (as applicable) is prepared for each project flnanced under the
2
Facility in accordance with all applicable laws of Georgra and ADB s Environment poticy,
and
that all EIAJIEES are approved by ADB an I Georgir's Mrnistry of Natural Resource; and
Envrronment Prolection (when required by Georgian legislationi and are adhered
lo during
desEn, construclton and operalion phases of such projecla.
8
l\4DF shall ensure that the Etltp is imptemented Alt recommendations of
lhe EMp are
rncorporated in the bidding documents. crvrr works conlracls anct consurtant's conrracis
to
ensure comp[ance
I
MDF shalli (i) monitor the implementahon of El\rPs by the contractori (ii) ensure that
civil
works and consulting servrces contracts inclLlde spectflc provistons for E[,ips,preparation,
mittgation measllres in EMps are adequately
adequale budgetary a ocation for thrs activily.
semi-annual rnonitoring reports on El\4ps
ct implementatton
10
No civil works contract shafl be awarded untrl the corresponding in[ral environmenlal
examination or environmental impact assessmenl as may be applicable lo project financed
under the Facihty has been approved by ADB
B.
11
Land Acquisltlon and Resetflement
[rDF with the partrcrpating municipality shall ensure that land and rights-of-way required
by the prolects are made availabte free and clear from any and
rights and claims of thlrd
parties and any olher encumbrances whatsoever ,n a timely manner and that the provisions of
the LARPs are implemented in conformity wrth (i) atl apphcable laws and regulations of Georgla,
(ii) ADB'S Safeguard Policy Statement (2009) on tnvotuntary Resettlement, and the agried
LARF
a
o
LARF shall be reviewed, rf necessary updaled, and submitted for ADB approvat at
leasl annually and al the beginning of the preparalion of each tranche under the
Facility A LARP consistent wlth the revrewed and updated LARF sha be prepared for
each proiect entailing land acquislllon and resetUement under the Facrlrty
('i)
The review and update of LARF and preparation of a LARP lor each subsequent
projecl consistent with lhe LARF shalt be a conditron for such proJect appraisal
() Preparatron of an updated LARP lor each projecl based on the final design and
consrstenl wilh the LARF shall be a condition for approval of the award of relevant civtl
works contract(s)
(iv) Completion ot the implementation of lhe LARP shafi be a cond(ron for the
commencement of crvrl works
12
0)
(ii)
Pursuanl to ADB'S Safeguard Policy Statement (2009) on Involuntary Resetflement, the
following shall be requrred:
compensation shall be provided at replacement cost togeiher w(h any entiflements as
strpulated rn lhe approved LARF and LARP:
lack of formal lrtle will not be a bar to rese tement assrstance or rehabilitalion for land
or any other loss:
(iii) counterpart funds and disbursements shall be timely provided to affecled persons
with agreed compensation and rehabilitation provided to lhem pnor to any land, house
or other affected assel being laken;
(rv) Georgia shall meet any unforeseen obligations in excess of budget eslimales;
3
(v) consultations and grrevances related to ihe inveslmenl proJect,s resetflement
shaltbe documented:
aclivilies
(vi) LA_RPS shafl be updated rt an investment project is modlfied
such that lhere are
different or addrlronat resetflement impact;: ;"; ,".;G;;i"".tivrties
shal be
reported io ADB
parl
as
of the semi-annuat progru"" r."lori;-;;li;bf:.'
greement under
[u"1T?l:#
14.
No civil works contracl shalt be awarded uhtil an
LARP as may be appticabte to the
project ftnanced under the Facility has
been approved by ADB
15 . Conlractors may only commence ctvtt works after the LARP has been rmplemenled
accordance wrlh tts lerms
C.
in
Social lmpacts, Gende. Development and Other lssueg
hall ensure a monltoring of the social tmpacts
consultation wrlh local governments, local
ln thrs respecl. MDF shall ensure lhal all crvrl
undertakings and compriance wifi be stricty monitored
Prog.am implementation.
during Road corrdor rnvestment
1I
_^YPl with the pariicipating municipality sha devetop, as appropriate, the gender action
ptan (cAP)
wirhrn srx (B) monrhs of the Effe;tive Dare
ens.,re that it is
lrmely rmplemented_ over the prolect period MDF
sha .""ito, Cnp iipr.i"-"tiron and report
the progress to AOB semrannualty
"r;;; i;;;,
;;i
flom the rmplemenlalton ot the lEEs/ElAsi (ii) c,v,l works contraclors,specltications
Include requirements lo comply wtth lhe environmental mrtgatton measures
contarned in the tEEs/ElAs and El\rps, and (iii) crvit works conkactors are
supervised lo ensure compltance with lhe requiremenls of the lEEs/ElAs and Elrps
(vii) Local consultation and gende.j (i) Gender Action plan agreed under the MFF is
implemenled: (ii) alt local consultattons to address safety, s;cial, and culturat
issues
during tmplementalion of lhe investment program are car ed oLrt as recommended
in the summary poverty reduction and socralstrategy: (iii) men and women are grven
equal employment opporiunities direc y, or indirec y arising from the tnvestment
Program and wilhout any dilferentiation of wages for ;quat work; and (iv)
mechanisms for maxtmizing local employment benefils will be promoted
(viii) Health ,isks and provention: aI crvil works conkacts wi[ include a requirerhent lo
conduct an informatton and ec,ucation campatgn on sexually ransmttted diseases
and HIV/AIDS for construction workers as part of the heatth and safety program al
campsiles during lhe construction period
(ix) Anticorruption; transparency and good govgrnance: MDF wtll folow ADB,S
Anliconuption Policy 11998, as amended to date) and acknowtedge that AOB,
consistenl wilh its commilment to good governance, accounlability and
transparency, reserves the right to underlake direc y, or through its agents,
investrgalion of any alleged cofiupt, fraudulent, collusive or coercive praclices
relaled to the MFF and cooperale wlth such investigation and extend all necessary
assistance including access to all MFF-relevani books and records, and engagtng
independent experts who may be needed for satisfactory complelion of such
investtgations. All conlracts financed by ADB under the inveslment program inctude
provisions specrfying the righl of ADB to audit and examine the MFF-related records
and accounts of the MDF and all conlractors, suppliers, consuttants. and other
servrce providers as they relate to lhe MFF Addilign3l mg3su1s5 to improve
governance. accountability and kansparency under lhe MFF, include (i)
independent external audiiing of contracts, proJect accounls, and financial
slalemenis. (I) pubICafuon of decrsrons on all procurement-relaled matters by lhe
MOF: and (Ii) ttmely dtsclosure of Inlormalon on selec|on of consultanls and
contraclors through local newspapers